Misprize Thou Not These Shadows That Belong: Lost Mines of Phandelver

After glancing through the other window, Rabbit moves back towards the others.  Still invisible she says. "There's just the one big orc. Though there are smaller rooms inside I couldn't see into.  I saw nothing to indicate anyone was being hurt - but we should poetically go take care of him." 

She pauses to see what the others might have found.  Then she adds, "He does seem to be blocking the entrance though."

Rabbit returns to a scene of carnage, and only one orc remains here. 

Quote from shimshon123 >>

Margret look at Krull, not sure what he intends to do but does step back. Then to her surprise, he kills the sleeping bound orc.

"Well, that may help me with my interrogation. Very gruesome work, Krull."

She then wakes up the bound sleeping orc.

"Hello there my friend. I have a problem. You see, this creature here (she points to Krull with his huge weapon) wants to kill you. Look what he did to that guy." She looks disgusted. "I asked him to keep you alive since if I ask you a few questions and you are honest with me, I might let you live." (Persuasion: 12)

 The orc simply looks at you not understanding.(unless you speak orcish) 

Try same in goblin. 

It seems to only speak Orc.

"You captured orcs to question, but none of you can actually talk to them?" Rabbit's voice says. Then after a pause, "Where's Droop?" 

“Droop. I am in need of your skills my friend.”

Margret calls back gently in goblin to him.  “Please help me with this orc.”

"To our wagon" Krull points ."Didn't like we killed one of them..He was the one with the idea..no actually was to kill both..anyways should I kill him or let Droop question him?"

(OOC: Between his passive perception and not really running away earlier (mostly trudging off in defeat), gonna assume for now the call goes out before he gets too too far away. So at DMs discretion, the following occurs:)

Droop seems to ignore the call at first; but, following a few more steps in the direction of the cart, he eventually stops and droops his head with a defeated sigh. "Even when not want mess up, still mess up." He mutters sadly to himself,  but then does an about face and halfheartedly jogs back to the group, or at least those still gathered about the orc. "What's matter? You want Droop stab now?" He asks as he drew forth his short sword and levels lackadaisically in the orc's direction.

In goblin, “Droop, do you speak orchish?”

Droop immediately deflates, already sensing where things are going. But after sparing the Orc a sidelong look he crosses his arms and says in goblin, "Yea.. Learned long, long ago. Back in the worse times than even with bugbears." He then sighs and looks up to Margret to say in common. "What you want Droop say to tusky?"

“Droop. Tell him you speak for me and I will let him go if he answers my questions and promises not to attack us.”

She looks at Droop, then at the orc, hoping Droop will translate using her words.

”what is your name?  What are you doing at this farm? How many are inside and why are they there?”

Krull grunts and stands near the orc with a menacing look (intimidation roll 17)

Droop nods, and after taking just a moment to clear his throat and brush off his clothing, looks again to the orc and says the following nonchalantly in orcish:

"Alright fathead. They wanna know your name, why you're here, and in the many big Gs' name are you rooting around inside instead, oh I dunno, stealing the animals you guys let out or somethin?" With each point made, Droop raises a finger at his side. But then after counting over said fingers after the fact, he snaps his fingers and adds, "Oh! And she said that if you don't be a dick and and answer honestly, they'll let you go. Unlike the dumbhead there." He says, pointing to the bound orc with his head split open. 

"Ogg, Having, fun killing huumons, whild hiding from the white dragon." He snarls "puny green thing" then spits

“Well, Droop. What did he say?” Margret asks, rather impatiently. 

 Droop just sighs. "Ogg says what Droop figured already. They wanna kill humans for shits and giggles, but not die to dragon." He says in common, before offhandedly gesturing to the house. "Both things they do inside easy enough. Heck, human inside probably dead already 'cause waste time out here. "

Krull says"let him leave and he will kill more in the future..your choice..as for the house If the humans are dead we burn it with the orc inside"

Rabbit shakes her head, though nobody can see it. "Not giving us answers? Leave him tied or kill him but do it now!" she demands. "I'm going to take care of the house."  And she starts walking carefully back.

Margret will knock him out and bring him to 1 hp. (No good way to do this in D&D so just role play and creative license please, hard knock to the head.  Take all weapons, search bodies and head out)

”Alright, we are done here. “