Thrax: Continuing to watch our 6...

Seeing that they want to be quiet, Kayassa waits to see if the mail strike is tried taking her time to ready an Eldritch Blast.

Ryzen rushes forward with lightning speed towards the goblins. Before the first one can turn around, it crumples to the ground, courtesy of your maul (-16hp[Dead]).

There is now one goblin left, who has drawn his scimitar and is preparing to fight. For now, let’s just say everyone in the party may take an action, then the goblin can go.

Keep in mind for the future: anytime you wish to knock a creature unconscious, just say you would like to make the hit nonlethal.

From now on, if you do not specify an attack as nonlethal, I will assume it is a regular hit.

Kayassa will finish her spell and let the blast of energy fly towards the goblin. She will attempt to trade the creature in an attempt to not kill it.

Eldritch Blast: Attack: 10 Damage: 8

Orro pulls his warhammer quickly and swings the flat of it at the creature's head, trying to knock it out. "Don't make this harder than it has to be, surrender, tell us where they are, and you can live!" he says in goblin.

Readied warhammer attack, nonfatal: 18 Damage: 7

The goblin dodges Kayassa’s eldritch blast, but the blast still offers just enough of a distraction for Orro to dash up, swinging his war hammer at the Goblin. It makes contact with a dull thud as the goblin falls back unconscious (-7hp[Unconscious]). 

Combat has now ended, and the party stands in a small clearing, with 2 goblins. One is dead and the other unconscious.

What would you like to do?

Orro softens the backswing of his hammer, peering down at the crumbled goblin and frowning.

"I didn't mean to hit 'im so hard," the cleric says. "Didn't even give him a chance to reply. Not very neighborly of me. Then again, he took my cousin, so that's the way the biscuit crumbles. Now then, should we head inside? I'm not sure we'll learn anything from him sleepin' like this that we won't find out inside here."

He peers inside.

-Jasper watched his party take the combat...he didn't think there was much to do that wouldn't have gotten in the way. he peered inside along with Orro, mumbling "how the cookie crumbles, indeed" with a chuckle, before straightening his jacket for whatever reason-

Jasper and Orro: Peeking inside the cave, there seems to be a few uneven stone steps that lead up to a small, dank chamber on the east side of the passage.

Kayassa watches this but merely shrugs as she walks closer to see what the others were looking at. If the goblin that is still alive looks as if it might stir soon, she will go over and poke at it with the end of her staff. "Wake up."

Kayassa: After some prodding, the goblin stirs before slowly sitting up, groggily clutching its head. It looks around for a second, before reaching for a weapon that is no longer there.

The goblin is awake and defenseless.

What would you like to do?

"Comrades, do any of you know this worm's tongue?" Thrax asks the group. "We should bind him, and gag him if he refuses to be helpful." He removes a coil of rope from his pack, and starts cutting a strip from the bottom of his cloak to use as a gag.

"I already said I do, and don't gag him yet, until he starts making noise," Orro says in Common. In goblin, he says, "Well now, that didn't go well for you now did it. It'll go worse if you try to run away or make a loud noise. I'm Orro. Kin to someone you have stolen off the path. I know he and his friend are in there. Tell me what you've done with him, and who's in there, and when we tie you up, we'll leave you nice and comfortable, and maybe even let you out when we're done. If you aren't helpful, well, then I'm afraid my friends here aren't very diplomatic and they might do something rash. And violent. And permanent."

Orro, why don’t you make an intimidation check with advantage because of the situation.

Yikes, not Orro's strong suit. He's a really nice guy. He sounds a bit like Iofur Raknison from The Golden Compass, but he doesn't have nearly that sort of gravitas.

Intimidation: 18

That would be a natural 20, minus 2. I'm not sure I've ever rolled that. Amazing.

With this, the goblin begins to whimper and shake before saying “No please, don’t kill me, please, I was just followin’ orders,” in common. “Me’ mate and I were to watch for and eliminate anyone coming towards the cave. Its boring work ye’know.” 

 He stops talking, realized that he had gone off on a tangent and sits there for a second before saying “What were we talkin’ bout’ again?”

Ryzen flicks the blood off of his maul and begins to scout out the cave they found. He stays close to the wall.and looks for any signs of where their employer could have been dragged off to. He also keeps a look put for any possible loot and traps.

 My Perception and Investigation are the same: 7

"You were going to tell us everything we wanted to know so we didn't kill you. Or at least that is what you said while you were begging." Kayassa tells the goblin in an innocent voice, tilting her head as she looked towards it.

Orro looks up at Kayassa, and nods helpfully in agreement, then back to the goblin. He quirks an eyebrow at Ryzen wandering off on his own, but figures he can handle himself.