DMs who do not give short rests should be given 3 options:
1. Give short rests as the game intends. (optimal)
2. Give all short rest recharge abilities 3x as many uses per long rest. (sub-optimal)
3. Find a new group of players to DM. (not optimal)
And this pretty much perfectly explains why short rests are a gorram problem.
Apparently there's absolutely no possible earthly reason a team of PCs might not be able to sit on their duffs for an uninterrupted hour whenever they feel like it. Standing right outside the door to a thousands-strong skeletal army commanded by an ancient dracolich who's almost done with his intimidating pre-invasion undead pep talk? That's fiiiiine! Just tell the DM "okay, we take a short rest", and stop those skeletal dastards in their tracks for an entire hour, as if you'd cast Time Stop on the entire room. After all, if the DM decides y'all are being a bunch of lackwit numblenuts for sitting down to have a spa session five feet away from the Gates of Inevitable Doom and has the Army of Darkness march through said gate two minutes into your short rest because she bloody well said they were two minutes from marching through the Gate of Inevitable Doom? Then she's just a terrible DM who's an anti-player jerk, she's not playing the game As Intended, and she should quit! Hell, if the players really want to Save The Realms? They could just keep saying "we take a short rest" right outside that room and prevent the invasion forever by holding the entire land eternally locked in temporal stasis, never to grow or flourish again but also never to suffer the ravages of the Draghoul King's armies. After all, that's the way the game was Intended to work!
Why do I even bother? Y'all time-hating crunks got what you wanted - the warlock got nothing, and is right back to being a carbon copy of the 2014 print. They walked back everything. No updates for anybody, just more stupid pointless useless "Pact Magic" that either doesn't function at all, or allows at-will spellcasting of fifth-level spells without restraint.
****.
Your incessant hyperboles prove nothing except that you have little actual logic behind your stagnant claims.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Look at what you've done. You spoiled it. You have nobody to blame but yourself. Go sit and think about your actions.
How I'm posting based on text formatting: Mod Hat Off - Mod Hat Also Off (I'm not a mod)
Why did you wait till you were at the door to take a short rest?
Dunno. Ask the people who feel like they can take any short rest they like whenever they want, without exception, and if they're interrupted it's the DM being an anti-player jerk.
I seriously question, and you have never answered, do your players never spend hit dice? They go into a fight battered beaten and mostly dead? Who is stopping the army when they die in the first round of combat instead of taking a short rest before getting to the doors so that they would be prepared?
We don't generally use Hit Dice recovery, no. Either we push on and endure, using rapid recovery when pressed (our table houserules that anyone with Medicine proficiency gains the Healer feat for free because someone with medical training ******* knows how to use a first aid kit; we end up using a lot of healing supplies), or we admit defeat, retreat, LR, and try to fix the problem later. We will if we're absolutely forced to, but whenever we take a short rest to recover the situation we're fighting to resolve gets worse and the minor HP boost we gain from spending Hit Dice is not sufficient to offset the increased difficulty we let ourselves in for.
The general idea is either you're not under time pressure at that moment, at which point there's no need for a short rest and you can just endure until it's time for a long, or you're under time pressure at the moment and thus have no time for a short rest without severely compromising or even outright failing whatever objective you're pursuing is. The moments where it "makes sense" to take a short rest are almost strictly limited to Classic Dungeon Crawls where time is wobbly at best and you're expected to get through 12+ encounters a "day". In almost any other situation it doesn't make sense to sit down and powder your gonads for an hour; either the bad guys aren't currently up to anything and you can powder your gonads for eight hours instead, or the bad guys are Up To Shit and people will die for every minute you spend powdering your gonads.
No in between. And no, there is no in between. Those two things cannot be simultaneously true. Either the bad guys are Up To Shit or they're not; there is no "sorta" up to shit, or "up to shit but only, like...maybe half-assed up to shit, y'know?"
There. Is. No. In. Between.
This warlock doesn't need 2 rests to work. It needs 1. If players are spending hit dice to recover health, than the warlock is fine recovering spell slots.
No one who enjoys/clings to the current short rest-centric Pact Magic model is content with 'one' short rest. They're playing the class specifically and solely to abuse short rests by forcing as many into an adventuring day as possible, to break the game's resource economy wide open and allow them to cast fifty-plus fifth-level spells per day. They're clinging to Pact Magic because they want at-will fifth-level slots, and convincing their table to just let short rests occur naturally for zero time investment whenever the party feels like it is how they get at-will fifth-level slots.
Even better question, if your games are so fast paced why are you not using the shorter heroic rest rules with the 5 minute short rests and 1 hour long rests. Sounds like 1 hour is a long time in your games and 10 minutes seems fine for rituals why not make it 10 for short rests?
It's not about five minutes or ten minutes or an hour. It's the idea that sitting down to powder your gonads and actively do nothing to stop the enemy from enacting their Evil Plot for whatever arbitrary length of time whilst the enemy is actively in the process of enacting their Evil Plot is ******* stupid. It's a giant signal saying "we don't give a shit about this problem, we don't consider it a problem, and we don't care if the enemy succeeds at what they're doing; we'd rather powder our gonads." If there's an Evil Plot actively afoot and you stop to powder your gonads, that Evil Plot is going to progress and you're going to suffer the consequences of your actions.
Which seems to be an extremely sore point amongst people who think they're magically entitled to Time Stop-level short rests at will no matter what is actually happening in the world, "because that's the intended game design!!1!" Buddy, tell the ancient dracolich who's waited a thousand years for the confluence of the heavens that it's simply not allowed to invade the Realms with its Army of Darkness at the first light of the Blood Moon because it's intended game design that players be able to freeze time like a goddamned Joestar whenever they wish for as long as they wish. Y'all ****ed around and picked flowers, romanced bar stools, argued about crafting, picked bar fights in the town library, and so on when y'all were told that the ancient dracolich was invading the Realms at the first light of the Blood Moon. You knew the timeframe, and you acted like this was a Bethesda game where the Main Quest would sit tight and wait for you to "get around to it." You did this to yourselves and have no one but yourselves to blame when the DM does exactly what they warned you multiple times they'd do and overruns the land with an Army of Darkness.
Apparently there's absolutely no possible earthly reason a team of PCs might not be able to sit on their duffs for an uninterrupted hour whenever they feel like it. Standing right outside the door to a thousands-strong skeletal army commanded by an ancient dracolich who's almost done with his intimidating pre-invasion undead pep talk? That's fiiiiine! Just tell the DM "okay, we take a short rest", and stop those skeletal dastards in their tracks for an entire hour, as if you'd cast Time Stop on the entire room. After all, if the DM decides y'all are being a bunch of lackwit numblenuts for sitting down to have a spa session five feet away from the Gates of Inevitable Doom and has the Army of Darkness march through said gate two minutes into your short rest because she bloody well said they were two minutes from marching through the Gate of Inevitable Doom? Then she's just a terrible DM who's an anti-player jerk, she's not playing the game As Intended, and she should quit! Hell, if the players really want to Save The Realms? They could just keep saying "we take a short rest" right outside that room and prevent the invasion forever by holding the entire land eternally locked in temporal stasis, never to grow or flourish again but also never to suffer the ravages of the Draghoul King's armies. After all, that's the way the game was Intended to work!
This doesn't really address the questions we raised based on your earlier post and claims. Is every session, starting at Level 1, nothing but time-sensitive, world-ending scenarios? Are your games literally nothing but the equivalent of being two steps away from the Gates of Inevitable Doom?
What prevents the party from resting at a slightly removed location? Who would actually try and take a short rest a few feet away from the gate? Is every square mile between Module City and the Gates filled with wandering undead that are deadly-level encounters?
And once the party hits Tier 2, spells like rope trick and tiny hut make taking a short rest MUCH easier and more feasible.
Nobody is arguing that short rests aren't sometimes difficult, or stupid, or deadly (or all three) to take, depending on situational specifics. A number of us are arguing that the hyperbolic claims you're making (taking either 1 rest or 12, no other options) aren't reflective of what the RAW expect from a gaming day nor do they reflect what most games are like. You keep presenting short rests as this broken mechanic because once Session 1 starts, it's breathless racing around the globe to stave off the Eruption of Hell on Earth every second of every day until the campaign is done.
Which...could be true? But as I keep saying: that sounds exhausting, from a player's (and DM's) perspective, and I simply don't accept it's what most people experience at the gaming table.
This doesn't really address the questions we raised based on your earlier post and claims. Is every session, starting at Level 1, nothing but time-sensitive, world-ending scenarios? Are your games literally nothing but the equivalent of being two steps away from the Gates of Inevitable Doom?
What prevents the party from resting at a slightly removed location? Who would actually try and take a short rest a few feet away from the gate? Is every square mile between Module City and the Gates filled with wandering undead that are deadly-level encounters?
And once the party hits Tier 2, spells like rope trick and tiny hut make taking a short rest MUCH easier and more feasible.
Nobody is arguing that short rests aren't sometimes difficult, or stupid, or deadly (or all three) to take, depending on situational specifics. A number of us are arguing that the hyperbolic claims you're making (taking either 1 rest or 12, no other options) aren't reflective of what the RAW expect from a gaming day nor do they reflect what most games are like. You keep presenting short rests as this broken mechanic because once Session 1 starts, it's breathless racing around the globe to stave off the Eruption of Hell on Earth every second of every day until the campaign is done.
Which...could be true? But as I keep saying: that sounds exhausting, from a player's (and DM's) perspective, and I simply don't accept it's what most people experience at the gaming table.
Ironically, just tried to address this with Aquil.
I subscribe to the idea that short rests are one of two things at any given point in time: 1.) Unnecessary, because there's no time pressure at that moment and thus no need to bother with a "short" rest when you could long instead, if you're in a situation where you can't endure and keep going. 2.) Actively a bad idea, because there is time pressure at that moment and stopping to powder your gonads is handing your enemy free, uninterrupted, uncontested time to progress their Evil Plot and you should not be surprised when they use it.
Short rests exist for the sole, singular use case of "we need to get as much done within this day as we possibly can for whichever weird, alien reason, but we have absolutely no time pressure whatsoever within the day working against us so we can use Hit Dice to artificially extend our endurance before we call it quits for the night." I.e. there's time pressure on the day as a whole but not any time pressure within that specific day, which is a situation that has arisen precisely never in my five-odd years of playing D&D. Again - either there's no overriding time pressure and thus no reason to sit down for an hour and powder our gonads, or there is time pressure and we need to be doing everything in our power to make effective use of time. Which precludes short rests because short rests are quite possibly the least effective use of time in all of D&D 5e.
In other words, person who doesn't play at a typical table, using house rules to avoid using hit dice, complains because they don't house rule Warlocks the same way. If you can "rapid recovery" for hit points then you can "rapid recovery" for spell slots.
No wonder there's no communication here. You're not even speaking the same language.
As for the original topic.
Patron's Favor: "Warlocks gain one spell slot when initiative is rolled. This cannot take them above their starting spell slots."
Why did you wait till you were at the door to take a short rest?
Dunno. Ask the people who feel like they can take any short rest they like whenever they want, without exception, and if they're interrupted it's the DM being an anti-player jerk.
I seriously question, and you have never answered, do your players never spend hit dice? They go into a fight battered beaten and mostly dead? Who is stopping the army when they die in the first round of combat instead of taking a short rest before getting to the doors so that they would be prepared?
We don't generally use Hit Dice recovery, no. Either we push on and endure, using rapid recovery when pressed (our table houserules that anyone with Medicine proficiency gains the Healer feat for free because someone with medical training ******* knows how to use a first aid kit; we end up using a lot of healing supplies), or we admit defeat, retreat, LR, and try to fix the problem later. We will if we're absolutely forced to, but whenever we take a short rest to recover the situation we're fighting to resolve gets worse and the minor HP boost we gain from spending Hit Dice is not sufficient to offset the increased difficulty we let ourselves in for.
The general idea is either you're not under time pressure at that moment, at which point there's no need for a short rest and you can just endure until it's time for a long, or you're under time pressure at the moment and thus have no time for a short rest without severely compromising or even outright failing whatever objective you're pursuing is. The moments where it "makes sense" to take a short rest are almost strictly limited to Classic Dungeon Crawls where time is wobbly at best and you're expected to get through 12+ encounters a "day". In almost any other situation it doesn't make sense to sit down and powder your gonads for an hour; either the bad guys aren't currently up to anything and you can powder your gonads for eight hours instead, or the bad guys are Up To Shit and people will die for every minute you spend powdering your gonads.
No in between. And no, there is no in between. Those two things cannot be simultaneously true. Either the bad guys are Up To Shit or they're not; there is no "sorta" up to shit, or "up to shit but only, like...maybe half-assed up to shit, y'know?"
There. Is. No. In. Between.
This warlock doesn't need 2 rests to work. It needs 1. If players are spending hit dice to recover health, than the warlock is fine recovering spell slots.
No one who enjoys/clings to the current short rest-centric Pact Magic model is content with 'one' short rest. They're playing the class specifically and solely to abuse short rests by forcing as many into an adventuring day as possible, to break the game's resource economy wide open and allow them to cast fifty-plus fifth-level spells per day. They're clinging to Pact Magic because they want at-will fifth-level slots, and convincing their table to just let short rests occur naturally for zero time investment whenever the party feels like it is how they get at-will fifth-level slots.
Even better question, if your games are so fast paced why are you not using the shorter heroic rest rules with the 5 minute short rests and 1 hour long rests. Sounds like 1 hour is a long time in your games and 10 minutes seems fine for rituals why not make it 10 for short rests?
It's not about five minutes or ten minutes or an hour. It's the idea that sitting down to powder your gonads and actively do nothing to stop the enemy from enacting their Evil Plot for whatever arbitrary length of time whilst the enemy is actively in the process of enacting their Evil Plot is ******* stupid. It's a giant signal saying "we don't give a shit about this problem, we don't consider it a problem, and we don't care if the enemy succeeds at what they're doing; we'd rather powder our gonads." If there's an Evil Plot actively afoot and you stop to powder your gonads, that Evil Plot is going to progress and you're going to suffer the consequences of your actions.
Which seems to be an extremely sore point amongst people who think they're magically entitled to Time Stop-level short rests at will no matter what is actually happening in the world, "because that's the intended game design!!1!" Buddy, tell the ancient dracolich who's waited a thousand years for the confluence of the heavens that it's simply not allowed to invade the Realms with its Army of Darkness at the first light of the Blood Moon because it's intended game design that players be able to freeze time like a goddamned Joestar whenever they wish for as long as they wish. Y'all ****ed around and picked flowers, romanced bar stools, argued about crafting, picked bar fights in the town library, and so on when y'all were told that the ancient dracolich was invading the Realms at the first light of the Blood Moon. You knew the timeframe, and you acted like this was a Bethesda game where the Main Quest would sit tight and wait for you to "get around to it." You did this to yourselves and have no one but yourselves to blame when the DM does exactly what they warned you multiple times they'd do and overruns the land with an Army of Darkness.
So taking an hour rest says “we don't give a shit about this problem, we don't consider it a problem, and we don't care if the enemy succeeds at what they're doing; we'd rather powder our gonads.” Then you shouldn’t be taking an 8 hour long-rest either. 8 hours is way longer than 1 hour.
3. Find a new group of players to DM. (not optimal)
You know, Dming is already hard enough as is. This gatekeeping bs really doesn't help anyone. There's already a shortage of Dms in this community.
I also don't know why people think that it's just the dm creating no short rest sessions. Some players just have an irrational hatred of short rests. Sometimes things go to shit in the session and the players have to take a long rest sooner than intended. (My players once accidentally triggered 3 encounters at once and were forced to take a long rest instead of the short one I intended.) Some groups just enjoy having fewer encounters.
Rather than forcing groups to conform to an arbitrary 'adventuring day,' maybe d&d should grant more flexibility? I don't feel like that should be a controversial take.
A number of us are arguing that the hyperbolic claims you're making (taking either 1 rest or 12, no other options) aren't reflective of what the RAW expect from a gaming day nor do they reflect what most games are like.
You forget that Yurei lives in Yurei-land, where taking five minutes to most of your health means the universe exploded.
Why did you wait till you were at the door to take a short rest?
Dunno. Ask the people who feel like they can take any short rest they like whenever they want, without exception, and if they're interrupted it's the DM being an anti-player jerk.
I seriously question, and you have never answered, do your players never spend hit dice? They go into a fight battered beaten and mostly dead? Who is stopping the army when they die in the first round of combat instead of taking a short rest before getting to the doors so that they would be prepared?
We don't generally use Hit Dice recovery, no. Either we push on and endure, using rapid recovery when pressed (our table houserules that anyone with Medicine proficiency gains the Healer feat for free because someone with medical training ******* knows how to use a first aid kit; we end up using a lot of healing supplies), or we admit defeat, retreat, LR, and try to fix the problem later. We will if we're absolutely forced to, but whenever we take a short rest to recover the situation we're fighting to resolve gets worse and the minor HP boost we gain from spending Hit Dice is not sufficient to offset the increased difficulty we let ourselves in for.
The general idea is either you're not under time pressure at that moment, at which point there's no need for a short rest and you can just endure until it's time for a long, or you're under time pressure at the moment and thus have no time for a short rest without severely compromising or even outright failing whatever objective you're pursuing is. The moments where it "makes sense" to take a short rest are almost strictly limited to Classic Dungeon Crawls where time is wobbly at best and you're expected to get through 12+ encounters a "day". In almost any other situation it doesn't make sense to sit down and powder your gonads for an hour; either the bad guys aren't currently up to anything and you can powder your gonads for eight hours instead, or the bad guys are Up To Shit and people will die for every minute you spend powdering your gonads.
No in between. And no, there is no in between. Those two things cannot be simultaneously true. Either the bad guys are Up To Shit or they're not; there is no "sorta" up to shit, or "up to shit but only, like...maybe half-assed up to shit, y'know?"
There. Is. No. In. Between.
This warlock doesn't need 2 rests to work. It needs 1. If players are spending hit dice to recover health, than the warlock is fine recovering spell slots.
No one who enjoys/clings to the current short rest-centric Pact Magic model is content with 'one' short rest. They're playing the class specifically and solely to abuse short rests by forcing as many into an adventuring day as possible, to break the game's resource economy wide open and allow them to cast fifty-plus fifth-level spells per day. They're clinging to Pact Magic because they want at-will fifth-level slots, and convincing their table to just let short rests occur naturally for zero time investment whenever the party feels like it is how they get at-will fifth-level slots.
Even better question, if your games are so fast paced why are you not using the shorter heroic rest rules with the 5 minute short rests and 1 hour long rests. Sounds like 1 hour is a long time in your games and 10 minutes seems fine for rituals why not make it 10 for short rests?
It's not about five minutes or ten minutes or an hour. It's the idea that sitting down to powder your gonads and actively do nothing to stop the enemy from enacting their Evil Plot for whatever arbitrary length of time whilst the enemy is actively in the process of enacting their Evil Plot is ******* stupid. It's a giant signal saying "we don't give a shit about this problem, we don't consider it a problem, and we don't care if the enemy succeeds at what they're doing; we'd rather powder our gonads." If there's an Evil Plot actively afoot and you stop to powder your gonads, that Evil Plot is going to progress and you're going to suffer the consequences of your actions.
Which seems to be an extremely sore point amongst people who think they're magically entitled to Time Stop-level short rests at will no matter what is actually happening in the world, "because that's the intended game design!!1!" Buddy, tell the ancient dracolich who's waited a thousand years for the confluence of the heavens that it's simply not allowed to invade the Realms with its Army of Darkness at the first light of the Blood Moon because it's intended game design that players be able to freeze time like a goddamned Joestar whenever they wish for as long as they wish. Y'all ****ed around and picked flowers, romanced bar stools, argued about crafting, picked bar fights in the town library, and so on when y'all were told that the ancient dracolich was invading the Realms at the first light of the Blood Moon. You knew the timeframe, and you acted like this was a Bethesda game where the Main Quest would sit tight and wait for you to "get around to it." You did this to yourselves and have no one but yourselves to blame when the DM does exactly what they warned you multiple times they'd do and overruns the land with an Army of Darkness.
This explains a lot. You are very contradictory. According to you pulling back and resting one hour to recover health and resources is too much and gives the enemy too much time but doing so for 20 hours is just fine. Ticking clocks arent just "do this in 5 minutes or everyone dies". They also include "reinforcements and supploes will arrive tomorrow, once they do it will be impossible to thwart the enemies." You know what you dont have time for at that point? A long rest. You know what you cant afford? To go in low health and unprepared. You know what you can afford? A short rest.
Another thing, I don't care if the warlock players WANT 2, 3 or 7 short rests. It is mathematically full caster equivalent with 1. Except at levels 8,9 and 10. 3 entire levels of the game. Not a lot of classes can say only 3 levels suck.
"The army of Darkness is coming, we need to be ready for them lets send the adventuring party that only progresses for an hour a day and then jacks off for 23 hours for a long rest because taking a lunch break is too long."
As with most tables, we all very rarely play 5e as written or intended. We all play our own homebrew version of 5e. Yurie your homebrew version is extremely loosely based. I have played with around 6 different GM'S, a very small sample size, and none have come close to either end of your thing.
In other words, person who doesn't play at a typical table, using house rules to avoid using hit dice, complains because they don't house rule Warlocks the same way. If you can "rapid recovery" for hit points then you can "rapid recovery" for spell slots.
See, what we actually did was say "the Medicine skill is almost completely useless in 5e, and the Healer feat provides rules for combat medic/mundane healing that are actually really neat but basically never come up because taking Healer as a feat is actively stupid. So...what if we just make mundane healing a thing people can do if they're trained in Medicine?" As it turns out, that enables a surprising amount of mundane healing, and makes healing/first aid supplies actually useful. We don't need a constant drip feed of hundreds of healing potions because our emergency slap patches come in the form of Healer's Kit uses, and restocking the healer's kit from a local apothecary works much better than the random podunk village at the edge of the frontier just having a dozen healing potions to sell whenever we need them.
We didn't houserule away short rests; we houseruled first aid back into the game properly. I actually recommend the rule for anyone who has issues with Healing Potion Spam or who wants nonmagical characters to have a better way to contribute to group healing/CLS. It's worked very well for us and made a formerly dead skill proficiency prized and valuable.
So taking an hour rest says “we don't give a shit about this problem, we don't consider it a problem, and we don't care if the enemy succeeds at what they're doing; we'd rather powder our gonads.” Then you shouldn’t be taking an 8 hour long-rest either. 8 hours is way longer than 1 hour.
You missed the part where I said "we admit defeat, retreat, long rest, and try to fix the problem later." If that's not viable, then yes - at my table, the players would push without long resting and do their best to stop the Evil Plot while at the edge of their HP and resources. That's what heroes do. Sometimes heroes fail, the Evil Plot resolves successfully, and we have to pursue damage control and a different means of progressing in our objectives, but that's how adventuring life works.
Ironically, just tried to address this with Aquil.
I subscribe to the idea that short rests are one of two things at any given point in time: 1.) Unnecessary, because there's no time pressure at that moment and thus no need to bother with a "short" rest when you could long instead, if you're in a situation where you can't endure and keep going. 2.) Actively a bad idea, because there is time pressure at that moment and stopping to powder your gonads is handing your enemy free, uninterrupted, uncontested time to progress their Evil Plot and you should not be surprised when they use it.
Short rests exist for the sole, singular use case of "we need to get as much done within this day as we possibly can for whichever weird, alien reason, but we have absolutely no time pressure whatsoever within the day working against us so we can use Hit Dice to artificially extend our endurance before we call it quits for the night." I.e. there's time pressure on the day as a whole but not any time pressure within that specific day, which is a situation that has arisen precisely never in my five-odd years of playing D&D. Again - either there's no overriding time pressure and thus no reason to sit down for an hour and powder our gonads, or there is time pressure and we need to be doing everything in our power to make effective use of time. Which precludes short rests because short rests are quite possibly the least effective use of time in all of D&D 5e.
I think you posted seconds before I did!
I just don't agree with your extreme takes on short rests, for a few reasons.
Not every gaming day of every campaign is a race against time. Some game days - some entire campaigns - are exploratory in nature, not tied to saving the earth from the 200 Foot Tall Colossus of Fire. What if you've been hired to map out a territory without a hard deadline? Taking a short rest makes eminent sense then, because you simply have no idea what might be encountered later that day. It benefits the fighter, it benefits the warlock, and even other classes. It's not about abuse; it's about wisely recollecting resources after a fight with some grippli when the next encounter might be with a T-rex. Your argument that short rests are only available when you don't need them does not at all mesh with my experiences of playing 5E since 2017.
Also, not every foe or BBG of a campaign is going to be a fiend or undead who never rests or recuperates or the like. Sometimes the BBEG is just as mortal (if far more powerful) than the party, and as someone wrote in a different thread, even the BBEG has to sleep and poop.
You rightly point out that when dungeoncrawling or some very similar activity in very hostile territory, taking a short rest can be very, very tricky (or impossible or deadly). Yes. Everyone's acknowledged this truth (though, again, once the characters hit Tier 2 and above, there are a LOT of magical helps that can be used to obtain a short rest assuming the world won't end in an hour). But there are many, many encounter economies and scenarios that fall between "never a need for a short rest" and "taking a short rest will be our certain doom." Everything you describe about your campaigns (which as I've said before, sound pretty damn cool in terms of tone and situations) seems to be far more demanding and exhausting that what seems to be the norm, if posts here are any indication.
Finally, please stop saying that anyone who likes the 2014 PHB warlock only does so to abuse short rests. This is actively offensive to me; I f**king hate that kind of approach to the rules via finding "loopholes" or unintended gamebreaking dealios - and I'm someone who really loves the 2014 warlock. I've never wanted nor tried to abuse the use of short rests - I really think the most I've ever take in a single gaming day was three (but more likely two). I've certainly never taken 6, or 10, or 12 short rests, nor would I try to abuse the rules that way.
ETA: the house rule about the Healer's feat is a neat one. Might consider incorporating that into my game.
The more you do your patron's bidding , the more likely your patron will reward you.
Technically, this isn't accurate. While there's no explicit in-game explanation for the growth of the warlock's powers, the game assumes whatever agreement or contract was made between the warlock and their patron was completed before gameplay begins. This has been discussed in various threads in the Warlock forum (folks [like me] wondering if a warlock can lose their powers - consensus is no, they can't, because they've been granted in perpetuity in exchange for whatever the warlock's already done).
Now, the DM and/or player can certainly choose to make the contract an open/in-progress one, in which your statement makes sense. But per the game designers, the rules were written on the assumption that the character does not owe their patron anymore actions.
Ok, fine, but the point is, it's a cheap way to get power and with explicit terms and conditions.
Plus, to be frank, the pact magic and spammables are what differentiate the warlock from other casters.
They don't have levels and they shouldn't be relying on them.
Otherwise we have 5 classes of casters and every one of them has the same spell slots, same progression, and generally all behave the same way with very minor nitpicky ability differences.
Edit: also a lot of the reason warlocks feel so limited is because they don't get enough of anything. The invocations are generally weak and don't scale, the magic slots aren't enough to compensate, and the pacts are just laughable for how stingy they are. I mean why bother with chain when find familiar is there for everyone and a ritual spell? FFS. And tome is for one spell slot. It feels like you're trading your soul for a wizard's damned post-it note.
To be perfectly fair, Warlocks (generally speaking) are Warlocks because they took the easy way out by calling up an otherworldly kingpin to get some perks rather than studying magic and learning to master it on their own terms for years. And most patrons aren't interested in making their Warlocks more powerful than themselves. So from a work ethic point of view, Warlocks getting the short end of the stick compared to Wizards makes some sense.
That is one type of warlock I guess. I generally see them as focused arcanists who realized the magics cast by normal people did not go far enough so they researched deeper into knowledge mortals were not meant to know.
This explains a lot. You are very contradictory. According to you pulling back and resting one hour to recover health and resources is too much and gives the enemy too much time but doing so for 20 hours is just fine.
Pulling back to powder your gonads for an hour is "okay, this is now way harder to succeed at, hope you guys make those five extra hit points and Derrick's one whole spell slot count."
Pulling back for twenty hours is "okay, you guys failed to stop the Evil Plot entirely, and now you're going to have to deal with the consequences of your failure."
Never said pulling back to LR was "fine". I said it was an admission of defeat, and that we'd have to cope with the fallout of that failure.
Ticking clocks arent just "do this in 5 minutes or everyone dies". They also include "reinforcements and supploes will arrive tomorrow, once they do it will be impossible to thwart the enemies." You know what you dont have time for at that point? A long rest. You know what you cant afford? To go in low health and unprepared. You know what you can afford? A short rest.
A situation that arises in almost no games. I could craft a purpose-built scenario to "encourage" short rests too. Doesn't make them a good game mechanic.
Another thing, I don't care if the warlock players WANT 2, 3 or 7 short rests. It is mathematically full caster equivalent with 1. Except at levels 8,9 and 10. 3 entire levels of the game. Not a lot of classes can say only 3 levels suck.
You're assuming the warlocxk is casting spells perfectly, emptying their tank flawlessly and restocking at the exact optimal time to do so in service of utterly maximizing spell count per day by pre-emptively knowing when they're allowed to cast and when they're not. No warlock does this. Warlocks have so little leveled casting that they are forced to conserve resources against future need, which results in a sharp decrease in use and thus a sharp decrease in spells per day.
White room math never tells the whole story.
"The army of Darkness is coming, we need to be ready for them lets send the adventuring party that only progresses for an hour a day and then jacks off for 23 hours for a long rest because taking a lunch break is too long. "
Is it my fault a majority of D&D players are faffing ****abouts who wouldn't know a ticking clock if you broke it over their heads in a bar fight and are outrageously wasteful with their resources? At my table, players who make egregiously poor use of time will discover that it doesn't go well for them. No, this does not mean "no downtime" or "constant rush"; it means when you know something needs to be done and you spend five sessions seducing the town's furniture instead of doing the thing what needs done because "lawl that's so funny and chaotic let's tell CritCrab about it!", you have no complaints coming when the DM says "well, y'all spent a week seducing furniture instead of forestalling the Army of Darkness, so now the Army of Darkness is here and they broke all the furniture. What do you do now?"
The more you do your patron's bidding , the more likely your patron will reward you.
Technically, this isn't accurate. While there's no explicit in-game explanation for the growth of the warlock's powers, the game assumes whatever agreement or contract was made between the warlock and their patron was completed before gameplay begins. This has been discussed in various threads in the Warlock forum (folks [like me] wondering if a warlock can lose their powers - consensus is no, they can't, because they've been granted in perpetuity in exchange for whatever the warlock's already done).
Now, the DM and/or player can certainly choose to make the contract an open/in-progress one, in which your statement makes sense. But per the game designers, the rules were written on the assumption that the character does not owe their patron anymore actions.
Ok, fine, but the point is, it's a cheap way to get power and with explicit terms and conditions.
Plus, to be frank, the pact magic and spammables are what differentiate the warlock from other casters.
They don't have levels and they shouldn't be relying on them.
Otherwise we have 5 classes of casters and every one of them has the same spell slots, same progression, and generally all behave the same way with very minor nitpicky ability differences.
Edit: also a lot of the reason warlocks feel so limited is because they don't get enough of anything. The invocations are generally weak and don't scale, the magic slots aren't enough to compensate, and the pacts are just laughable for how stingy they are. I mean why bother with chain when find familiar is there for everyone and a ritual spell? FFS. And tome is for one spell slot. It feels like you're trading your soul for a wizard's damned post-it note.
To be perfectly fair, Warlocks (generally speaking) are Warlocks because they took the easy way out by calling up an otherworldly kingpin to get some perks rather than studying magic and learning to master it on their own terms for years. And most patrons aren't interested in making their Warlocks more powerful than themselves. So from a work ethic point of view, Warlocks getting the short end of the stick compared to Wizards makes some sense.
That is one type of warlock I guess. I generally see them as focused arcanists who realized the magics cast by normal people did not go far enough so they researched deeper into knowledge mortals were not meant to know.
On the other hand, wizards are also focused arcanists who can also delve into magics most mortals can only dream of wielding.
I feel this flavour would shine more if more of the eldritch invocations actually did something potent and weird that you couldn't find in any other class, instead of a number of them simply being at-will spells.
I definitely wish they had gone into stranger invocations. It requires a lot more work though on their end. Its this spell is just easy.
Heh. Reminds me of the UA5 drop and everybody posting all at once.
I just don't agree with your extreme takes on short rests, for a few reasons.
Not every gaming day of every campaign is a race against time. Some game days - some entire campaigns - are exploratory in nature, not tied to saving the earth from the 200 Foot Tall Colossus of Fire. What if you've been hired to map out a territory without a hard deadline? Taking a short rest makes eminent sense then, because you simply have no idea what might be encountered later that day. It benefits the fighter, it benefits the warlock, and even other classes. It's not about abuse; it's about wisely recollecting resources after a fight with some grippli when the next encounter might be with a T-rex. Your argument that short rests are only available when you don't need them does not at all mesh with my experiences of playing 5E since 2017.
In narrow circumstances sure, short rests can factor naturally into a campaign. Does that mean entire classes should be held hostage by them? This isn't just a case of "there's no undead so our cleric can't use Turn Undead"; the cleric has other uses for Channel Divinity and Turn Undead is a side gig for them at best. Warlocks in campaigns where short rests don't factor naturally into the campaign are denied effective use of their primary class resource. It's not okay, and thousands of players have complained to Wizards about it. Nobody ever seems to acknowledge that J-Craw and the company as a whole have repeatedly said that the most consistent feedback they get on warlocks is "more spells please" and "this feels bad to play I don't feel like I can ever justify using my magic."
Also, not every foe or BBG of a campaign is going to be a fiend or undead who never rests or recuperates or the like. Sometimes the BBEG is just as mortal (if far more powerful) than the party, and as someone wrote in a different thread, even the BBEG has to sleep and poop.
Sure. The BBEG also tends to have hundreds if not thousands of minions, however. And even if they don't, the players have no idea how willing the BBEG is to push into exhaustion to accomplish their goals. Even if all you're doing is trying to stop a mad scientist from magineering a spellplague that will turn an entire town into disco zombies, well - how many mad scientists have you met who obey a healthy sleep schedule? Time is a resource that can never be gained, only spent, and whoever spends their time most effectively has a definitive edge towards achieving victory.
You rightly point out that when dungeoncrawling or some very similar activity in very hostile territory, taking a short rest can be very, very tricky (or impossible or deadly). Yes. Everyone's acknowledged this truth (though, again, once the characters hit Tier 2 and above, there are a LOT of magical helps that can be used to obtain a short rest assuming the world won't end in an hour). But there are many, many encounter economies and scenarios that fall between "never a need for a short rest" and "taking a short rest will be our certain doom." Everything you describe about your campaigns (which as I've said before, sound pretty damn cool in terms of tone and situations) seems to be far more demanding and exhausting that what seems to be the norm, if posts here are any indication.
I've seen plenty of players who openly state that any DM who denies or interrupts their players' short rests - for any reason - is being an anti-player TPK-chasing jerk who should quit DMing. There are absolutely people out there who think they should be entitled to a free short rest two steps outside the Gates of Doom, and I cannot fathom why anyone thinks that makes for a good game. Talk about murdering the pacing of your tale. Yeesh.
My general play group is blessed with players who all keenly understand the impact of time on events. Nobody has a Bethesda mindset of "the story won't happen until we show up to make it happen so we can faff around seducing furniture all we want", and our games tend to reflect that. They're not always ticking clocks, no, but even when there's no obvious clock we'll often try to play efficiently anyways. After all, you never know when you're going to discover something was burbling away behind the scenes after all and now you're stuck with a clock you didn't know was there. Or, hell - play to maximize your use of time and you can just get more done.
Finally, please stop saying that anyone who likes the 2014 PHB warlock only does so to abuse short rests. This is actively offensive to me; I f**king hate that kind of approach to the rules via finding "loopholes" or unintended gamebreaking dealios - and I'm someone who really loves the 2014 warlock. I've never wanted nor tried to abuse the use of short rests - I really think the most I've ever take in a single gaming day was three (but more likely two). I've certainly never taken 6, or 10, or 12 short rests, nor would I try to abuse the rules that way.
I've played multiple warlocks, and in an older time they were one of my favorite classes. In some ways they still are. I crave the customization and responsiveness of the Invocation system, the ability to make a warlock that's actually different from other warlocks. But it's in part because I've played them and crave that part of their identity that I'm so upset by the horrid limitations of Pact Magic. We could be doing better. Warlocks don't have to be weird, janky edge-case not-really-spellcasters beholden to too many short rests...but because "The Community" raised an uproar Wizards gave up on it and now we're back to the 2014 version. No improvements for us. I can only surmise this is because people so addicted to Pact Magic that they refused to allow anything else at all are addicted to Pact Magic because they like abusing it. There's really no other reason to like it. Especially when most of those people are in this thread praising the utter destruction of any hope for the warlock to be improved in any damn way.
It is Upsetting.
ETA: the house rule about the Healer's feat is a neat one. Might consider incorporating that into my game.
It's one of our most successful house rules, to the point where it's largely assumed in any new game we play. Allowing healer's kits to actually heal people is one of those things that makes you say "why did we have to houserule this, why sin't this just the way the game works?" once you try it. Especially when you observe the once-per-day limitation, which we do. Mundane healing can only do so much, that's why potions and magical healing exist...but mundane healing is also not nothing. It's a really good balance, honestly.
deleted. This is just dumb at this point. Short rests are modular in time for a reason. They are a part of the game. if you aren't using them you aren't playing 5e full stop. The warlock is effective with 1 short rest, everyone should want at least 1 short rest to spend hit dice.
Spending hit dice IS natural healing. Just make using bandages count as a short rest.
And if players were playing to maximize their time they would be taking short rests. If you aren't than you are really crappy at maximizing your time.
Apparently not, Apparently at your table wasting whole days is how you stop the larger plot because a lunch break is too long. You can not take more than 1 long rest per 24 hour period. Fights last around a minute tops. If you are NOT using any short rests to spend hit dice and continue the adventure than 23 hours of they day is wasted doing nothing allowing the villain to advance the plot.
If one hour makes such a difference in your games I hope you double time every single travel at all times. You better have those horses running at a full sprint every time and I am sure you never give out exhaustion for that for some odd reason. If your GM is punishing every short rest (not just extraneous ones) with the enemy getting a bunch tougher than they are an absolute moron who has probably never worked a real job in their life. Even the worst job sites get an hour for lunch so that the employees dont collapse.
Time may not exist for your table. You may run on Bethesda Time, where the world doesn't exist unless you're there making it exist and the story only ever advances when the players decide it does. This is not the case for every table.
You act like we only ever deal with one fight. This is incorrect. We simply don't blow our load in every fight on the assumption we'll get constant free short rests. Every player in my group naturally tends to carefully meter resources and play as if they have no idea what the day before them holds, when we're in an area where this matters. We take multiple fights without the 'lunch break', using resources as carefully as we generally can. If the situation allows for a short rest, which it rarely does, then sure, we'll take it. But as I said to Xukuri - should entire classes be held hostage to a mechanic that only really works properly in a distinctly smaller subset of campaigns?
The difference between our core assumptions, Aquilontune, is that you assume short rests are free. That they're an expected and natural part of every adventuring day, Because The Game Book Says So. I do not. I assume short rests are a luxury afforded to you only when the world you're playing in does not deny you that luxury. Frankly, there's been times that goes for long rests, too. The Game Book does not run our games - our GMs do. And our GMs are not going to let the Game Book tell us what kind of stories we are and are not allowed to run.
Apparently not, Apparently at your table wasting whole days is how you stop the larger plot because a lunch break is too long. You can not take more than 1 long rest per 24 hour period. Fights last around a minute tops. If you are NOT using any short rests to spend hit dice and continue the adventure than 23 hours of they day is wasted doing nothing allowing the villain to advance the plot.
If one hour makes such a difference in your games I hope you double time every single travel at all times. You better have those horses running at a full sprint every time and I am sure you never give out exhaustion for that for some odd reason. If your GM is punishing every short rest (not just extraneous ones) with the enemy getting a bunch tougher than they are an absolute moron who has probably never worked a real job in their life. Even the worst job sites get an hour for lunch so that the employees dont collapse.
Time may not exist for your table. You may run on Bethesda Time, where the world doesn't exist unless you're there making it exist and the story only ever advances when the players decide it does. This is not the case for every table.
You act like we only ever deal with one fight. This is incorrect. We simply don't blow our load in every fight on the assumption we'll get constant free short rests. Every player in my group naturally tends to carefully meter resources and play as if they have no idea what the day before them holds, when we're in an area where this matters. We take multiple fights without the 'lunch break', using resources as carefully as we generally can. If the situation allows for a short rest, which it rarely does, then sure, we'll take it. But as I said to Xukuri - should entire classes be held hostage to a mechanic that only really works properly in a distinctly smaller subset of campaigns?
The difference between our core assumptions, Aquilontune, is that you assume short rests are free. That they're an expected and natural part of every adventuring day, Because The Game Book Says So. I do not. I assume short rests are a luxury afforded to you only when the world you're playing in does not deny you that luxury. Frankly, there's been times that goes for long rests, too. The Game Book does not run our games - our GMs do. And our GMs are not going to let the Game Book tell us what kind of stories we are and are not allowed to run.
You had 10 fights... that is 10 minutes... what did you do with the other 23 hours and 50 minutes of your day. I am assuming LONG RESTS are expensive not that short rests are free.
Short rests are LESS expensive and highly rewarding by comparison. The clock IS ticking. There is a LOT to get done I don't have time to go back to town and screw around for 20+ hours when we could have hidden, regrouped taken a lunch break and planned our next move and kept trucking.
The DMG sets rules about adjusting long and short rests for a reason. Because your rest system should match the pace and style of play. Spending hit dice is intended by the system as a whole if your group needs to make short rests 5 minutes to match what is expected in your games and so classes like warlock, monk, fighter, druid all function than do that. Give the Warlock a Rod of the pact keeper. There are ways to do things narratively that also function mechanically with the game.
The reason people want warlock like this is because it is DIFFERENT and it is a different way of looking at spells and spell slots.
I have given a whole thing on how warlocks look at spells differently than other classes. Other classes look at spider climb and go "this is a great 2nd level spell" or will take web, hypnotic pattern, and confussion, all different level AOE control effects. The warlock looks at that and goes "why, you only need one of those for AOE control and you should probably have a different tool". Because their question is what is best in the moment rather than what is best "for this slot".
I was 100% fine with the last caster, I thought it worked too. But I also know we aren't going to get that and want to make THIS one work. This has SOME tweaks needed still to, but it is still better and I like a class that functions with just 1 short rest. I think that is fine, because I do think that an adventuring day with 0 short rests means an adjustment of short and long rest time needs to be done.
A short rest is what YOU make it. 5 minutes, 10 minutes, an hour, or 8 hours. In games where we are playing more exploratory leisure paces with a lot of wondering and exploring with 1 or 2 fights a day, the "adventuring day" becomes an adventuring WEEK and 8 hours becomes a short rest and a long becomes 3 days of down time. Make it what you will, but the 5e ruleset expects at least 1 short rest per long rest. If you didn't short rest before you long rest, you did not take advantage of your time and the plot will progress.
Apparently not, Apparently at your table wasting whole days is how you stop the larger plot because a lunch break is too long. You can not take more than 1 long rest per 24 hour period. Fights last around a minute tops. If you are NOT using any short rests to spend hit dice and continue the adventure than 23 hours of they day is wasted doing nothing allowing the villain to advance the plot.
If one hour makes such a difference in your games I hope you double time every single travel at all times. You better have those horses running at a full sprint every time and I am sure you never give out exhaustion for that for some odd reason. If your GM is punishing every short rest (not just extraneous ones) with the enemy getting a bunch tougher than they are an absolute moron who has probably never worked a real job in their life. Even the worst job sites get an hour for lunch so that the employees dont collapse.
Time may not exist for your table. You may run on Bethesda Time, where the world doesn't exist unless you're there making it exist and the story only ever advances when the players decide it does. This is not the case for every table.
You act like we only ever deal with one fight. This is incorrect. We simply don't blow our load in every fight on the assumption we'll get constant free short rests. Every player in my group naturally tends to carefully meter resources and play as if they have no idea what the day before them holds, when we're in an area where this matters. We take multiple fights without the 'lunch break', using resources as carefully as we generally can. If the situation allows for a short rest, which it rarely does, then sure, we'll take it. But as I said to Xukuri - should entire classes be held hostage to a mechanic that only really works properly in a distinctly smaller subset of campaigns?
The difference between our core assumptions, Aquilontune, is that you assume short rests are free. That they're an expected and natural part of every adventuring day, Because The Game Book Says So. I do not. I assume short rests are a luxury afforded to you only when the world you're playing in does not deny you that luxury. Frankly, there's been times that goes for long rests, too. The Game Book does not run our games - our GMs do. And our GMs are not going to let the Game Book tell us what kind of stories we are and are not allowed to run.
You had 10 fights... that is 10 minutes... what did you do with the other 23 hours and 50 minutes of your day. I am assuming LONG RESTS are expensive not that short rests are free.
Short rests are LESS expensive and highly rewarding by comparison. The clock IS ticking. There is a LOT to get done I don't have time to go back to town and screw around for 20+ hours when we could have hidden, regrouped taken a lunch break and planned our next move and kept trucking.
I've learned in other threads that Yurei has his own thing going on, and it's best to not feed him.
Another thing, I don't care if the warlock players WANT 2, 3 or 7 short rests. It is mathematically full caster equivalent with 1. Except at levels 8,9 and 10. 3 entire levels of the game. Not a lot of classes can say only 3 levels suck.
That is factually incorrect. Here's a chart comparing Halfcaster, Fullcaster, and Pactcaster progression. The values are in conversions based on Font of Magic.
Lvl
Half
0SR
1SR
2SR
Full
Lvl
Half
NoSR
1SR
2SR
Full
1
4
2
4
6
4
11
30
21
42
63
62
2
4
4
6
8
6
12
30
21
42
63
62
3
6
6
12
18
14
13
36
21
42
63
62
4
6
6
12
18
17
14
36
21
42
63
62
5
14
10
20
30
27
15
42
21
42
63
62
6
14
10
20
30
30
16
42
21
42
63
62
7
17
12
24
36
36
17
55
28
56
84
62
8
17
12
24
36
42
18
55
28
56
84
69
9
27
14
28
42
55
19
62
28
56
84
69+
10
27
14
28
42
62
At no point after level 2nd level do Warlocks compare to fullcasters after 1SR. Even with the new (awful imo) Magical Cunning feature they cannot compete after 5th level. Now to be honest I don't necessarily believe that Warlocks should compete. What I find annoying is how much of a power swing Warlocks have. A Short Restless Warlock is worse at spellcasting than half-casters. Warlocks are casters!!
Your incessant hyperboles prove nothing except that you have little actual logic behind your stagnant claims.
Look at what you've done. You spoiled it. You have nobody to blame but yourself. Go sit and think about your actions.
How I'm posting based on text formatting: Mod Hat Off - Mod Hat Also Off (I'm not a mod)
Dunno. Ask the people who feel like they can take any short rest they like whenever they want, without exception, and if they're interrupted it's the DM being an anti-player jerk.
We don't generally use Hit Dice recovery, no. Either we push on and endure, using rapid recovery when pressed (our table houserules that anyone with Medicine proficiency gains the Healer feat for free because someone with medical training ******* knows how to use a first aid kit; we end up using a lot of healing supplies), or we admit defeat, retreat, LR, and try to fix the problem later. We will if we're absolutely forced to, but whenever we take a short rest to recover the situation we're fighting to resolve gets worse and the minor HP boost we gain from spending Hit Dice is not sufficient to offset the increased difficulty we let ourselves in for.
The general idea is either you're not under time pressure at that moment, at which point there's no need for a short rest and you can just endure until it's time for a long, or you're under time pressure at the moment and thus have no time for a short rest without severely compromising or even outright failing whatever objective you're pursuing is. The moments where it "makes sense" to take a short rest are almost strictly limited to Classic Dungeon Crawls where time is wobbly at best and you're expected to get through 12+ encounters a "day". In almost any other situation it doesn't make sense to sit down and powder your gonads for an hour; either the bad guys aren't currently up to anything and you can powder your gonads for eight hours instead, or the bad guys are Up To Shit and people will die for every minute you spend powdering your gonads.
No in between. And no, there is no in between. Those two things cannot be simultaneously true. Either the bad guys are Up To Shit or they're not; there is no "sorta" up to shit, or "up to shit but only, like...maybe half-assed up to shit, y'know?"
There. Is. No. In. Between.
No one who enjoys/clings to the current short rest-centric Pact Magic model is content with 'one' short rest. They're playing the class specifically and solely to abuse short rests by forcing as many into an adventuring day as possible, to break the game's resource economy wide open and allow them to cast fifty-plus fifth-level spells per day. They're clinging to Pact Magic because they want at-will fifth-level slots, and convincing their table to just let short rests occur naturally for zero time investment whenever the party feels like it is how they get at-will fifth-level slots.
It's not about five minutes or ten minutes or an hour. It's the idea that sitting down to powder your gonads and actively do nothing to stop the enemy from enacting their Evil Plot for whatever arbitrary length of time whilst the enemy is actively in the process of enacting their Evil Plot is ******* stupid. It's a giant signal saying "we don't give a shit about this problem, we don't consider it a problem, and we don't care if the enemy succeeds at what they're doing; we'd rather powder our gonads." If there's an Evil Plot actively afoot and you stop to powder your gonads, that Evil Plot is going to progress and you're going to suffer the consequences of your actions.
Which seems to be an extremely sore point amongst people who think they're magically entitled to Time Stop-level short rests at will no matter what is actually happening in the world, "because that's the intended game design!!1!" Buddy, tell the ancient dracolich who's waited a thousand years for the confluence of the heavens that it's simply not allowed to invade the Realms with its Army of Darkness at the first light of the Blood Moon because it's intended game design that players be able to freeze time like a goddamned Joestar whenever they wish for as long as they wish. Y'all ****ed around and picked flowers, romanced bar stools, argued about crafting, picked bar fights in the town library, and so on when y'all were told that the ancient dracolich was invading the Realms at the first light of the Blood Moon. You knew the timeframe, and you acted like this was a Bethesda game where the Main Quest would sit tight and wait for you to "get around to it." You did this to yourselves and have no one but yourselves to blame when the DM does exactly what they warned you multiple times they'd do and overruns the land with an Army of Darkness.
Please do not contact or message me.
This doesn't really address the questions we raised based on your earlier post and claims. Is every session, starting at Level 1, nothing but time-sensitive, world-ending scenarios? Are your games literally nothing but the equivalent of being two steps away from the Gates of Inevitable Doom?
What prevents the party from resting at a slightly removed location? Who would actually try and take a short rest a few feet away from the gate? Is every square mile between Module City and the Gates filled with wandering undead that are deadly-level encounters?
And once the party hits Tier 2, spells like rope trick and tiny hut make taking a short rest MUCH easier and more feasible.
Nobody is arguing that short rests aren't sometimes difficult, or stupid, or deadly (or all three) to take, depending on situational specifics. A number of us are arguing that the hyperbolic claims you're making (taking either 1 rest or 12, no other options) aren't reflective of what the RAW expect from a gaming day nor do they reflect what most games are like. You keep presenting short rests as this broken mechanic because once Session 1 starts, it's breathless racing around the globe to stave off the Eruption of Hell on Earth every second of every day until the campaign is done.
Which...could be true? But as I keep saying: that sounds exhausting, from a player's (and DM's) perspective, and I simply don't accept it's what most people experience at the gaming table.
Ironically, just tried to address this with Aquil.
I subscribe to the idea that short rests are one of two things at any given point in time:
1.) Unnecessary, because there's no time pressure at that moment and thus no need to bother with a "short" rest when you could long instead, if you're in a situation where you can't endure and keep going.
2.) Actively a bad idea, because there is time pressure at that moment and stopping to powder your gonads is handing your enemy free, uninterrupted, uncontested time to progress their Evil Plot and you should not be surprised when they use it.
Short rests exist for the sole, singular use case of "we need to get as much done within this day as we possibly can for whichever weird, alien reason, but we have absolutely no time pressure whatsoever within the day working against us so we can use Hit Dice to artificially extend our endurance before we call it quits for the night." I.e. there's time pressure on the day as a whole but not any time pressure within that specific day, which is a situation that has arisen precisely never in my five-odd years of playing D&D. Again - either there's no overriding time pressure and thus no reason to sit down for an hour and powder our gonads, or there is time pressure and we need to be doing everything in our power to make effective use of time. Which precludes short rests because short rests are quite possibly the least effective use of time in all of D&D 5e.
Please do not contact or message me.
In other words, person who doesn't play at a typical table, using house rules to avoid using hit dice, complains because they don't house rule Warlocks the same way. If you can "rapid recovery" for hit points then you can "rapid recovery" for spell slots.
No wonder there's no communication here. You're not even speaking the same language.
As for the original topic.
Patron's Favor: "Warlocks gain one spell slot when initiative is rolled. This cannot take them above their starting spell slots."
Problem solved. Moving on.
So taking an hour rest says “we don't give a shit about this problem, we don't consider it a problem, and we don't care if the enemy succeeds at what they're doing; we'd rather powder our gonads.” Then you shouldn’t be taking an 8 hour long-rest either. 8 hours is way longer than 1 hour.
You know, Dming is already hard enough as is. This gatekeeping bs really doesn't help anyone. There's already a shortage of Dms in this community.
I also don't know why people think that it's just the dm creating no short rest sessions. Some players just have an irrational hatred of short rests. Sometimes things go to shit in the session and the players have to take a long rest sooner than intended. (My players once accidentally triggered 3 encounters at once and were forced to take a long rest instead of the short one I intended.) Some groups just enjoy having fewer encounters.
Rather than forcing groups to conform to an arbitrary 'adventuring day,' maybe d&d should grant more flexibility? I don't feel like that should be a controversial take.
You forget that Yurei lives in Yurei-land, where taking five minutes to most of your health means the universe exploded.
Look at what you've done. You spoiled it. You have nobody to blame but yourself. Go sit and think about your actions.
How I'm posting based on text formatting: Mod Hat Off - Mod Hat Also Off (I'm not a mod)
This explains a lot. You are very contradictory. According to you pulling back and resting one hour to recover health and resources is too much and gives the enemy too much time but doing so for 20 hours is just fine. Ticking clocks arent just "do this in 5 minutes or everyone dies". They also include "reinforcements and supploes will arrive tomorrow, once they do it will be impossible to thwart the enemies." You know what you dont have time for at that point? A long rest. You know what you cant afford? To go in low health and unprepared. You know what you can afford? A short rest.
Another thing, I don't care if the warlock players WANT 2, 3 or 7 short rests. It is mathematically full caster equivalent with 1. Except at levels 8,9 and 10. 3 entire levels of the game. Not a lot of classes can say only 3 levels suck.
"The army of Darkness is coming, we need to be ready for them lets send the adventuring party that only progresses for an hour a day and then jacks off for 23 hours for a long rest because taking a lunch break is too long."
As with most tables, we all very rarely play 5e as written or intended. We all play our own homebrew version of 5e. Yurie your homebrew version is extremely loosely based. I have played with around 6 different GM'S, a very small sample size, and none have come close to either end of your thing.
See, what we actually did was say "the Medicine skill is almost completely useless in 5e, and the Healer feat provides rules for combat medic/mundane healing that are actually really neat but basically never come up because taking Healer as a feat is actively stupid. So...what if we just make mundane healing a thing people can do if they're trained in Medicine?" As it turns out, that enables a surprising amount of mundane healing, and makes healing/first aid supplies actually useful. We don't need a constant drip feed of hundreds of healing potions because our emergency slap patches come in the form of Healer's Kit uses, and restocking the healer's kit from a local apothecary works much better than the random podunk village at the edge of the frontier just having a dozen healing potions to sell whenever we need them.
We didn't houserule away short rests; we houseruled first aid back into the game properly. I actually recommend the rule for anyone who has issues with Healing Potion Spam or who wants nonmagical characters to have a better way to contribute to group healing/CLS. It's worked very well for us and made a formerly dead skill proficiency prized and valuable.
You missed the part where I said "we admit defeat, retreat, long rest, and try to fix the problem later." If that's not viable, then yes - at my table, the players would push without long resting and do their best to stop the Evil Plot while at the edge of their HP and resources. That's what heroes do. Sometimes heroes fail, the Evil Plot resolves successfully, and we have to pursue damage control and a different means of progressing in our objectives, but that's how adventuring life works.
Please do not contact or message me.
I think you posted seconds before I did!
I just don't agree with your extreme takes on short rests, for a few reasons.
Not every gaming day of every campaign is a race against time. Some game days - some entire campaigns - are exploratory in nature, not tied to saving the earth from the 200 Foot Tall Colossus of Fire. What if you've been hired to map out a territory without a hard deadline? Taking a short rest makes eminent sense then, because you simply have no idea what might be encountered later that day. It benefits the fighter, it benefits the warlock, and even other classes. It's not about abuse; it's about wisely recollecting resources after a fight with some grippli when the next encounter might be with a T-rex. Your argument that short rests are only available when you don't need them does not at all mesh with my experiences of playing 5E since 2017.
Also, not every foe or BBG of a campaign is going to be a fiend or undead who never rests or recuperates or the like. Sometimes the BBEG is just as mortal (if far more powerful) than the party, and as someone wrote in a different thread, even the BBEG has to sleep and poop.
You rightly point out that when dungeoncrawling or some very similar activity in very hostile territory, taking a short rest can be very, very tricky (or impossible or deadly). Yes. Everyone's acknowledged this truth (though, again, once the characters hit Tier 2 and above, there are a LOT of magical helps that can be used to obtain a short rest assuming the world won't end in an hour). But there are many, many encounter economies and scenarios that fall between "never a need for a short rest" and "taking a short rest will be our certain doom." Everything you describe about your campaigns (which as I've said before, sound pretty damn cool in terms of tone and situations) seems to be far more demanding and exhausting that what seems to be the norm, if posts here are any indication.
Finally, please stop saying that anyone who likes the 2014 PHB warlock only does so to abuse short rests. This is actively offensive to me; I f**king hate that kind of approach to the rules via finding "loopholes" or unintended gamebreaking dealios - and I'm someone who really loves the 2014 warlock. I've never wanted nor tried to abuse the use of short rests - I really think the most I've ever take in a single gaming day was three (but more likely two). I've certainly never taken 6, or 10, or 12 short rests, nor would I try to abuse the rules that way.
ETA: the house rule about the Healer's feat is a neat one. Might consider incorporating that into my game.
That is one type of warlock I guess. I generally see them as focused arcanists who realized the magics cast by normal people did not go far enough so they researched deeper into knowledge mortals were not meant to know.
Pulling back to powder your gonads for an hour is "okay, this is now way harder to succeed at, hope you guys make those five extra hit points and Derrick's one whole spell slot count."
Pulling back for twenty hours is "okay, you guys failed to stop the Evil Plot entirely, and now you're going to have to deal with the consequences of your failure."
Never said pulling back to LR was "fine". I said it was an admission of defeat, and that we'd have to cope with the fallout of that failure.
A situation that arises in almost no games. I could craft a purpose-built scenario to "encourage" short rests too. Doesn't make them a good game mechanic.
You're assuming the warlocxk is casting spells perfectly, emptying their tank flawlessly and restocking at the exact optimal time to do so in service of utterly maximizing spell count per day by pre-emptively knowing when they're allowed to cast and when they're not. No warlock does this. Warlocks have so little leveled casting that they are forced to conserve resources against future need, which results in a sharp decrease in use and thus a sharp decrease in spells per day.
White room math never tells the whole story.
Is it my fault a majority of D&D players are faffing ****abouts who wouldn't know a ticking clock if you broke it over their heads in a bar fight and are outrageously wasteful with their resources? At my table, players who make egregiously poor use of time will discover that it doesn't go well for them. No, this does not mean "no downtime" or "constant rush"; it means when you know something needs to be done and you spend five sessions seducing the town's furniture instead of doing the thing what needs done because "lawl that's so funny and chaotic let's tell CritCrab about it!", you have no complaints coming when the DM says "well, y'all spent a week seducing furniture instead of forestalling the Army of Darkness, so now the Army of Darkness is here and they broke all the furniture. What do you do now?"
Please do not contact or message me.
I definitely wish they had gone into stranger invocations. It requires a lot more work though on their end. Its this spell is just easy.
Heh. Reminds me of the UA5 drop and everybody posting all at once.
In narrow circumstances sure, short rests can factor naturally into a campaign. Does that mean entire classes should be held hostage by them? This isn't just a case of "there's no undead so our cleric can't use Turn Undead"; the cleric has other uses for Channel Divinity and Turn Undead is a side gig for them at best. Warlocks in campaigns where short rests don't factor naturally into the campaign are denied effective use of their primary class resource. It's not okay, and thousands of players have complained to Wizards about it. Nobody ever seems to acknowledge that J-Craw and the company as a whole have repeatedly said that the most consistent feedback they get on warlocks is "more spells please" and "this feels bad to play I don't feel like I can ever justify using my magic."
Sure. The BBEG also tends to have hundreds if not thousands of minions, however. And even if they don't, the players have no idea how willing the BBEG is to push into exhaustion to accomplish their goals. Even if all you're doing is trying to stop a mad scientist from magineering a spellplague that will turn an entire town into disco zombies, well - how many mad scientists have you met who obey a healthy sleep schedule? Time is a resource that can never be gained, only spent, and whoever spends their time most effectively has a definitive edge towards achieving victory.
I've seen plenty of players who openly state that any DM who denies or interrupts their players' short rests - for any reason - is being an anti-player TPK-chasing jerk who should quit DMing. There are absolutely people out there who think they should be entitled to a free short rest two steps outside the Gates of Doom, and I cannot fathom why anyone thinks that makes for a good game. Talk about murdering the pacing of your tale. Yeesh.
My general play group is blessed with players who all keenly understand the impact of time on events. Nobody has a Bethesda mindset of "the story won't happen until we show up to make it happen so we can faff around seducing furniture all we want", and our games tend to reflect that. They're not always ticking clocks, no, but even when there's no obvious clock we'll often try to play efficiently anyways. After all, you never know when you're going to discover something was burbling away behind the scenes after all and now you're stuck with a clock you didn't know was there. Or, hell - play to maximize your use of time and you can just get more done.
I've played multiple warlocks, and in an older time they were one of my favorite classes. In some ways they still are. I crave the customization and responsiveness of the Invocation system, the ability to make a warlock that's actually different from other warlocks. But it's in part because I've played them and crave that part of their identity that I'm so upset by the horrid limitations of Pact Magic. We could be doing better. Warlocks don't have to be weird, janky edge-case not-really-spellcasters beholden to too many short rests...but because "The Community" raised an uproar Wizards gave up on it and now we're back to the 2014 version. No improvements for us. I can only surmise this is because people so addicted to Pact Magic that they refused to allow anything else at all are addicted to Pact Magic because they like abusing it. There's really no other reason to like it. Especially when most of those people are in this thread praising the utter destruction of any hope for the warlock to be improved in any damn way.
It is Upsetting.
It's one of our most successful house rules, to the point where it's largely assumed in any new game we play. Allowing healer's kits to actually heal people is one of those things that makes you say "why did we have to houserule this, why sin't this just the way the game works?" once you try it. Especially when you observe the once-per-day limitation, which we do. Mundane healing can only do so much, that's why potions and magical healing exist...but mundane healing is also not nothing. It's a really good balance, honestly.
Please do not contact or message me.
deleted. This is just dumb at this point. Short rests are modular in time for a reason. They are a part of the game. if you aren't using them you aren't playing 5e full stop. The warlock is effective with 1 short rest, everyone should want at least 1 short rest to spend hit dice.
Spending hit dice IS natural healing. Just make using bandages count as a short rest.
And if players were playing to maximize their time they would be taking short rests. If you aren't than you are really crappy at maximizing your time.
Time may not exist for your table. You may run on Bethesda Time, where the world doesn't exist unless you're there making it exist and the story only ever advances when the players decide it does. This is not the case for every table.
You act like we only ever deal with one fight. This is incorrect. We simply don't blow our load in every fight on the assumption we'll get constant free short rests. Every player in my group naturally tends to carefully meter resources and play as if they have no idea what the day before them holds, when we're in an area where this matters. We take multiple fights without the 'lunch break', using resources as carefully as we generally can. If the situation allows for a short rest, which it rarely does, then sure, we'll take it. But as I said to Xukuri - should entire classes be held hostage to a mechanic that only really works properly in a distinctly smaller subset of campaigns?
The difference between our core assumptions, Aquilontune, is that you assume short rests are free. That they're an expected and natural part of every adventuring day, Because The Game Book Says So. I do not. I assume short rests are a luxury afforded to you only when the world you're playing in does not deny you that luxury. Frankly, there's been times that goes for long rests, too. The Game Book does not run our games - our GMs do. And our GMs are not going to let the Game Book tell us what kind of stories we are and are not allowed to run.
Please do not contact or message me.
You had 10 fights... that is 10 minutes... what did you do with the other 23 hours and 50 minutes of your day. I am assuming LONG RESTS are expensive not that short rests are free.
Short rests are LESS expensive and highly rewarding by comparison. The clock IS ticking. There is a LOT to get done I don't have time to go back to town and screw around for 20+ hours when we could have hidden, regrouped taken a lunch break and planned our next move and kept trucking.
The DMG sets rules about adjusting long and short rests for a reason. Because your rest system should match the pace and style of play. Spending hit dice is intended by the system as a whole if your group needs to make short rests 5 minutes to match what is expected in your games and so classes like warlock, monk, fighter, druid all function than do that. Give the Warlock a Rod of the pact keeper. There are ways to do things narratively that also function mechanically with the game.
The reason people want warlock like this is because it is DIFFERENT and it is a different way of looking at spells and spell slots.
I have given a whole thing on how warlocks look at spells differently than other classes. Other classes look at spider climb and go "this is a great 2nd level spell" or will take web, hypnotic pattern, and confussion, all different level AOE control effects. The warlock looks at that and goes "why, you only need one of those for AOE control and you should probably have a different tool". Because their question is what is best in the moment rather than what is best "for this slot".
I was 100% fine with the last caster, I thought it worked too. But I also know we aren't going to get that and want to make THIS one work. This has SOME tweaks needed still to, but it is still better and I like a class that functions with just 1 short rest. I think that is fine, because I do think that an adventuring day with 0 short rests means an adjustment of short and long rest time needs to be done.
A short rest is what YOU make it. 5 minutes, 10 minutes, an hour, or 8 hours. In games where we are playing more exploratory leisure paces with a lot of wondering and exploring with 1 or 2 fights a day, the "adventuring day" becomes an adventuring WEEK and 8 hours becomes a short rest and a long becomes 3 days of down time. Make it what you will, but the 5e ruleset expects at least 1 short rest per long rest. If you didn't short rest before you long rest, you did not take advantage of your time and the plot will progress.
I've learned in other threads that Yurei has his own thing going on, and it's best to not feed him.
That is factually incorrect. Here's a chart comparing Halfcaster, Fullcaster, and Pactcaster progression. The values are in conversions based on Font of Magic.
At no point after level 2nd level do Warlocks compare to fullcasters after 1SR. Even with the new (awful imo) Magical Cunning feature they cannot compete after 5th level.
Now to be honest I don't necessarily believe that Warlocks should compete. What I find annoying is how much of a power swing Warlocks have. A Short Restless Warlock is worse at spellcasting than half-casters. Warlocks are casters!!