Regen happens only on a rage. I have 3 rage charges total on my character, which recharge on a long rest. Additionally, I can't regen past half HP, and I regen 3 health per round.
, the equivelant of crit damage on every hit
Nearly every barb subclass includes a damage rider when you rage, and there isn't a point in picking one that doesn't. Additionally, it's limited to heavy or two handed weapons, so I can't use a shield with it or unarmed strikes.
, a charm/frenzy thorns/on hit effect, and like 15 options for customization on top of that. At 3rd level.
It's a CON save, which is the most commonly resisted save, and you are immune to it for 24 hours once you succeed once. Why is having more options unbalanced..? It's not like they're all strong, totem barb gives something similar, battlemaster maneuvers give you a ton of options, and probably more I'm forgetting. If the individual features are unbalanced, tell me which ones.
And me being able to smite and heal from it 2/rest, when NO ONE IS GOING TO SHORT REST IN A DUNGEON, is "absolutely absurd?"
I'm done. I really felt really good about you yesterday, but this double standard is pissing me off. I don't care that you're a martial and I'm a caster. This is a Warlock subclass. You have outpaced every single benchmark for damage consistently and face no scrutiny, while I'm under investigation.
Because I'm not using homebrew to boost my damage. All of that is just for flavor, I could easily outpace my damage if I didn't use homebrew tbh I just didn't want to. Obviously I'm not perfect with homebrew, but those complaints you have are already addressed. And yes, people do short rests in dungeons, that's not unheard of. I'm not even the one who posted about your subclass. If you had these problems, you could have just said it in the first place.
Additionally, Chris did offer to help balance yours if you wanted it. He balanced mine when I gave him my first draft. That's just how reviewing homebrew goes, the concepts are good but the wording and execution were off.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
— δ cyno • he/him • number one paladin fanδ — making a smoothie for meta ——————| EXTENDED SIG |—————— Φ • happily married to my lovely redpelt, minmaxer, microbiology student, and lover of anything colored red • Φ
Regen happens only on a rage. I have 3 rage charges total on my character, which recharge on a long rest. Additionally, I can't regen past half HP, and I regen 3 health per round.
, the equivelant of crit damage on every hit
Nearly every barb subclass includes a damage rider when you rage, and there isn't a point in picking one that doesn't. Additionally, it's limited to heavy or two handed weapons, so I can't use a shield with it or unarmed strikes.
, a charm/frenzy thorns/on hit effect, and like 15 options for customization on top of that. At 3rd level.
It's a CON save, which is the most commonly resisted save, and you are immune to it for 24 hours once you succeed once. Why is having more options unbalanced..? It's not like they're all strong, totem barb gives something similar, battlemaster maneuvers give you a ton of options, and probably more I'm forgetting. If the individual features are unbalanced, tell me which ones.
And me being able to smite and heal from it 2/rest, when NO ONE IS GOING TO SHORT REST IN A DUNGEON, is "absolutely absurd?"
I'm done. I really felt really good about you yesterday, but this double standard is pissing me off. I don't care that you're a martial and I'm a caster. This is a Warlock subclass. You have outpaced every single benchmark for damage consistently and face no scrutiny, while I'm under investigation.
Because I'm not using homebrew to boost my damage. All of that is just for flavor, I could easily outpace my damage if I didn't use homebrew tbh I just didn't want to. Obviously I'm not perfect with homebrew, but those complaints you have are already addressed. And yes, people do short rests in dungeons, that's not unheard of. I'm not even the one who posted about your subclass. If you had these problems, you could have just said it in the first place.
*I was actually planning on implementing checkpoints for dungeons where they can rest and people can use those checkpoints to do stuff irl instead, and we can always come back to it later*
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
fellow follower of JEFF!!!! and a fan of BotW titles include:Beastmaster Extraordinaire,Wizened Beholder of the West Wind,Salvatore's Secret Archivist
Co-cult leader of the cynophobia cult
Archivist of the kingdoms and Crowns thread, Percy Jackson thread, Mechanicus and Realm of Dragons threads Admin of the Academy
Up to the mods, IDK. Just giving my perspective and view on the sub as a whole
Could you please take a look at Cyno's subclass too?
Ive looked at it, and we did some rewords and fixing to it beforehand :)) Adding durations and such, moving some of what he was originally planning at 3rd back to 6th
Alright then.
I no longer care about your opinions on balance and will leave presently.
If you want to leave comments on my subclass you can, I'm open to feedback. I made it with Chris and had it reviewed a couple times.
No, I'm done. I'm just done.
Actually, you know what, fine.
You have free Regen, the equivelant of crit damage on every hit, a charm/frenzy thorns/on hit effect, and like 15 options for customization on top of that. At 3rd level.
And me being able to smite and heal from it 2/rest, when NO ONE IS GOING TO SHORT REST IN A DUNGEON, is "absolutely absurd?"
I'm done. I really felt really good about you yesterday, but this double standard is pissing me off. I don't care that you're a martial and I'm a caster. This is a Warlock subclass. You have outpaced every single benchmark for damage consistently and face no scrutiny, while I'm under investigation.
Im sorry if the wording upset you, but the rate of healing is relevant here. 25 healing all at once is certainly better than 3 per round. I believe the subclass would have been much better written if rather than breaking the general standards of how healing works in this game, the power was spread around to a variety of effects. Halving the healing, and giving something else that isnt healing. Additionally, Im not trying to put you under any sort of 'investigation' Im giving my review of HB because I thought it was a good and informative example of things that a lot of people miss about design trends. I didnt just say 'its overpowered'. I said it is front heavy, and I would love to see it get buffed in the later features. Which is honestly the same critique I have on Hexblade
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
NNCHRIS: SOUL THIEF, MASTER OF THE ARCANE, AND KING OF NEW YORKNN Gdl Creator of Ilheia and her Knights of the Fallen Stars ldG Lesser Student of Technomancy [undergrad student in computer science] Supporter of the 2014 rules, and a MASSIVE Homebrewer. Come to me all ye who seek salvation in wording thy brews! Open to homebrew trades at any time!! Or feel free to request HB, and Ill see if I can get it done for ya! Characters (Outdated)
Regen happens only on a rage. I have 3 rage charges total on my character, which recharge on a long rest. Additionally, I can't regen past half HP, and I regen 3 health per round.
, the equivelant of crit damage on every hit
Nearly every barb subclass includes a damage rider when you rage, and there isn't a point in picking one that doesn't. Additionally, it's limited to heavy or two handed weapons, so I can't use a shield with it or unarmed strikes.
, a charm/frenzy thorns/on hit effect, and like 15 options for customization on top of that. At 3rd level.
It's a CON save, which is the most commonly resisted save, and you are immune to it for 24 hours once you succeed once. Why is having more options unbalanced..? It's not like they're all strong, totem barb gives something similar, battlemaster maneuvers give you a ton of options, and probably more I'm forgetting. If the individual features are unbalanced, tell me which ones.
And me being able to smite and heal from it 2/rest, when NO ONE IS GOING TO SHORT REST IN A DUNGEON, is "absolutely absurd?"
I'm done. I really felt really good about you yesterday, but this double standard is pissing me off. I don't care that you're a martial and I'm a caster. This is a Warlock subclass. You have outpaced every single benchmark for damage consistently and face no scrutiny, while I'm under investigation.
Because I'm not using homebrew to boost my damage. All of that is just for flavor, I could easily outpace my damage if I didn't use homebrew tbh I just didn't want to. Obviously I'm not perfect with homebrew, but those complaints you have are already addressed. And yes, people do short rests in dungeons, that's not unheard of. I'm not even the one who posted about your subclass. If you had these problems, you could have just said it in the first place.
*I was actually planning on implementing checkpoints for dungeons where they can rest and people can use those checkpoints to do stuff irl instead, and we can always come back to it later*
*Mine’s an escape room. No breaks… except when the DM needs a naptime break.*
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If I’m being annoying, tell me to shut up. Seriously. Just say “Bananer shut up.” And I will. For a few seconds!
Don’t listen to the folks down at Adohands. It’s good for me to overwork myself.
Professional idiot! Trans! Pansexual pancake! I am a minor so you will do none of that (GP) with me! I use He/They pronouns :3
Additionally, Chris did offer to help balance yours if you wanted it. He balanced mine when I gave him my first draft. That's just how reviewing homebrew goes, the concepts are good but the wording and execution were off.
It's not my subclass.
It was published in one of the most beloved 5e homebrew books ever made, Grim Hollow.
I'm not going to argue about this anymore.
I was going to rage at you, throwing a little tantrum and get myself banned, but at this point I might as well leave myself.
*XD, but it would be a good idea to include checkpoints where everyone can stop and pick it up again later*
*I think it’ll just be like a regular PBP where people pick it up and drop it. I’d ideally like to get more than one person to do my dungeon at once and hopefully working together.*
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If I’m being annoying, tell me to shut up. Seriously. Just say “Bananer shut up.” And I will. For a few seconds!
Don’t listen to the folks down at Adohands. It’s good for me to overwork myself.
Professional idiot! Trans! Pansexual pancake! I am a minor so you will do none of that (GP) with me! I use He/They pronouns :3
Additionally, Chris did offer to help balance yours if you wanted it. He balanced mine when I gave him my first draft. That's just how reviewing homebrew goes, the concepts are good but the wording and execution were off.
It's not my subclass.
It was published in one of the most beloved 5e homebrew books ever made, Grim Hollow.
I'm not going to argue about this anymore.
I was going to rage at you, throwing a little tantrum and get myself banned, but at this point I might as well leave myself.
I don't feel welcome here anymore anyway.
Bye, baal, it was fun having you on the thread, and for the record, I was not planning on banning anyone from the thread unless one of you started directly insulting the other
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
fellow follower of JEFF!!!! and a fan of BotW titles include:Beastmaster Extraordinaire,Wizened Beholder of the West Wind,Salvatore's Secret Archivist
Co-cult leader of the cynophobia cult
Archivist of the kingdoms and Crowns thread, Percy Jackson thread, Mechanicus and Realm of Dragons threads Admin of the Academy
Additionally, Chris did offer to help balance yours if you wanted it. He balanced mine when I gave him my first draft. That's just how reviewing homebrew goes, the concepts are good but the wording and execution were off.
It's not my subclass.
It was published in one of the most beloved 5e homebrew books ever made, Grim Hollow.
I'm not going to argue about this anymore.
I was going to rage at you, throwing a little tantrum and get myself banned, but at this point I might as well leave myself.
I don't feel welcome here anymore anyway.
Noooo balzeeee
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Ello friendo! I’m Aspen/ celeste, but people also call me asp, aspy, cele, and murder child!
I only murder people occasionally!
Sorlock fanatic & Arboreal Masterpiece
Any pronouns
Best friendos: Bananer, gato, and a buncha other people!
Additionally, Chris did offer to help balance yours if you wanted it. He balanced mine when I gave him my first draft. That's just how reviewing homebrew goes, the concepts are good but the wording and execution were off.
It's not my subclass.
It was published in one of the most beloved 5e homebrew books ever made, Grim Hollow.
I'm not going to argue about this anymore.
I was going to rage at you, throwing a little tantrum and get myself banned, but at this point I might as well leave myself.
I don't feel welcome here anymore anyway.
It's an edited version of the posted books. I don't know why you're upset about it if it isn't your homebrew anyway. I'm not suggesting that you're powergaming, just that the homebrew could be improved. :| I didn't even personally insult you or say anything about you.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
— δ cyno • he/him • number one paladin fanδ — making a smoothie for meta ——————| EXTENDED SIG |—————— Φ • happily married to my lovely redpelt, minmaxer, microbiology student, and lover of anything colored red • Φ
*XD, but it would be a good idea to include checkpoints where everyone can stop and pick it up again later*
*I think it’ll just be like a regular PBP where people pick it up and drop it. I’d ideally like to get more than one person to do my dungeon at once and hopefully working together.*
*The only difference is ours, you have 6 dm's and the Dm's double as players*
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
fellow follower of JEFF!!!! and a fan of BotW titles include:Beastmaster Extraordinaire,Wizened Beholder of the West Wind,Salvatore's Secret Archivist
Co-cult leader of the cynophobia cult
Archivist of the kingdoms and Crowns thread, Percy Jackson thread, Mechanicus and Realm of Dragons threads Admin of the Academy
Additionally, Chris did offer to help balance yours if you wanted it. He balanced mine when I gave him my first draft. That's just how reviewing homebrew goes, the concepts are good but the wording and execution were off.
It's not my subclass.
It was published in one of the most beloved 5e homebrew books ever made, Grim Hollow.
I'm not going to argue about this anymore.
I was going to rage at you, throwing a little tantrum and get myself banned, but at this point I might as well leave myself.
I don't feel welcome here anymore anyway.
It's an edited version of the posted books. I don't know why you're upset about it if it isn't your homebrew anyway. I'm not suggesting that you're powergaming, just that the homebrew could be improved. :| I didn't even personally insult you or say anything about you.
Additionally, Chris did offer to help balance yours if you wanted it. He balanced mine when I gave him my first draft. That's just how reviewing homebrew goes, the concepts are good but the wording and execution were off.
It's not my subclass.
It was published in one of the most beloved 5e homebrew books ever made, Grim Hollow.
I'm not going to argue about this anymore.
I was going to rage at you, throwing a little tantrum and get myself banned, but at this point I might as well leave myself.
I don't feel welcome here anymore anyway.
Bye, baal, it was fun having you on the thread, and for the record, I was not planning on banning anyone from the thread unless one of you started directly insulting the other
Additionally, Chris did offer to help balance yours if you wanted it. He balanced mine when I gave him my first draft. That's just how reviewing homebrew goes, the concepts are good but the wording and execution were off.
— δ cyno • he/him • number one paladin fan δ —
making a smoothie for meta
——————| EXTENDED SIG |——————
Φ • happily married to my lovely redpelt, minmaxer, microbiology student, and lover of anything colored red • Φ
*Sureeeeee what’s the premise?*
If I’m being annoying, tell me to shut up. Seriously. Just say “Bananer shut up.” And I will. For a few seconds!
Don’t listen to the folks down at Adohands. It’s good for me to overwork myself.
Professional idiot! Trans! Pansexual pancake! I am a minor so you will do none of that (GP) with me! I use He/They pronouns :3
Extended Signature!
*It’s gonna be either camp Jupiter or a Norse camp or like hotel Valhalla*
Ello friendo! I’m Aspen/ celeste, but people also call me asp, aspy, cele, and murder child!
I only murder people occasionally!
Sorlock fanatic & Arboreal Masterpiece
Any pronouns
Best friendos: Bananer, gato, and a buncha other people!
*I was actually planning on implementing checkpoints for dungeons where they can rest and people can use those checkpoints to do stuff irl instead, and we can always come back to it later*
fellow follower of JEFF!!!! and a fan of BotW titles include:Beastmaster Extraordinaire,Wizened Beholder of the West Wind,Salvatore's Secret Archivist
Co-cult leader of the cynophobia cult
Archivist of the kingdoms and Crowns thread, Percy Jackson thread, Mechanicus and Realm of Dragons threads Admin of the Academy
PM me the word avocado :P
*Ooh, okay. I think Himy did something like that once.*
If I’m being annoying, tell me to shut up. Seriously. Just say “Bananer shut up.” And I will. For a few seconds!
Don’t listen to the folks down at Adohands. It’s good for me to overwork myself.
Professional idiot! Trans! Pansexual pancake! I am a minor so you will do none of that (GP) with me! I use He/They pronouns :3
Extended Signature!
Bless Chris's heart <3
fellow follower of JEFF!!!! and a fan of BotW titles include:Beastmaster Extraordinaire,Wizened Beholder of the West Wind,Salvatore's Secret Archivist
Co-cult leader of the cynophobia cult
Archivist of the kingdoms and Crowns thread, Percy Jackson thread, Mechanicus and Realm of Dragons threads Admin of the Academy
PM me the word avocado :P
*which to do…*
Ello friendo! I’m Aspen/ celeste, but people also call me asp, aspy, cele, and murder child!
I only murder people occasionally!
Sorlock fanatic & Arboreal Masterpiece
Any pronouns
Best friendos: Bananer, gato, and a buncha other people!
Im sorry if the wording upset you, but the rate of healing is relevant here. 25 healing all at once is certainly better than 3 per round. I believe the subclass would have been much better written if rather than breaking the general standards of how healing works in this game, the power was spread around to a variety of effects. Halving the healing, and giving something else that isnt healing. Additionally, Im not trying to put you under any sort of 'investigation' Im giving my review of HB because I thought it was a good and informative example of things that a lot of people miss about design trends. I didnt just say 'its overpowered'. I said it is front heavy, and I would love to see it get buffed in the later features. Which is honestly the same critique I have on Hexblade
NNCHRIS: SOUL THIEF, MASTER OF THE ARCANE, AND KING OF NEW YORKNN
Gdl Creator of Ilheia and her Knights of the Fallen Stars ldG
Lesser Student of Technomancy [undergrad student in computer science]
Supporter of the 2014 rules, and a MASSIVE Homebrewer. Come to me all ye who seek salvation in wording thy brews!
Open to homebrew trades at any time!! Or feel free to request HB, and Ill see if I can get it done for ya!
Characters (Outdated)
NAME: Jackson
AGE: 15
RACE: Human
PRONOUNS:He/him
WORLD OF ORIGIN: Earth
HOUSE: Vaskar
LEVELS: 4 bard
DESCRIPTION: Pirate hat and clothes like a pirate
Other info: 2nd year, has a flut, and has 3 siblings
HOMEBREW: none
Hallo
People who aren't from here or DeviantArt might know me from various games or might know me as Dino on some of those games
I will go by these if ya wanna say something nicknames: Dinao, Diano, Or Dino
'tis all
:p
*Mine’s an escape room. No breaks… except when the DM needs a naptime break.*
If I’m being annoying, tell me to shut up. Seriously. Just say “Bananer shut up.” And I will. For a few seconds!
Don’t listen to the folks down at Adohands. It’s good for me to overwork myself.
Professional idiot! Trans! Pansexual pancake! I am a minor so you will do none of that (GP) with me! I use He/They pronouns :3
Extended Signature!
*XD, but it would be a good idea to include checkpoints where everyone can stop and pick it up again later*
fellow follower of JEFF!!!! and a fan of BotW titles include:Beastmaster Extraordinaire,Wizened Beholder of the West Wind,Salvatore's Secret Archivist
Co-cult leader of the cynophobia cult
Archivist of the kingdoms and Crowns thread, Percy Jackson thread, Mechanicus and Realm of Dragons threads Admin of the Academy
PM me the word avocado :P
It's not my subclass.
It was published in one of the most beloved 5e homebrew books ever made, Grim Hollow.
I'm not going to argue about this anymore.
I was going to rage at you, throwing a little tantrum and get myself banned, but at this point I might as well leave myself.
I don't feel welcome here anymore anyway.
Let him who is without sin cast the first stone.
Awake, impure, divine
Breathgiver of the Strugels
*I think it’ll just be like a regular PBP where people pick it up and drop it. I’d ideally like to get more than one person to do my dungeon at once and hopefully working together.*
If I’m being annoying, tell me to shut up. Seriously. Just say “Bananer shut up.” And I will. For a few seconds!
Don’t listen to the folks down at Adohands. It’s good for me to overwork myself.
Professional idiot! Trans! Pansexual pancake! I am a minor so you will do none of that (GP) with me! I use He/They pronouns :3
Extended Signature!
Bye, baal, it was fun having you on the thread, and for the record, I was not planning on banning anyone from the thread unless one of you started directly insulting the other
fellow follower of JEFF!!!! and a fan of BotW titles include:Beastmaster Extraordinaire,Wizened Beholder of the West Wind,Salvatore's Secret Archivist
Co-cult leader of the cynophobia cult
Archivist of the kingdoms and Crowns thread, Percy Jackson thread, Mechanicus and Realm of Dragons threads Admin of the Academy
PM me the word avocado :P
Noooo balzeeee
Ello friendo! I’m Aspen/ celeste, but people also call me asp, aspy, cele, and murder child!
I only murder people occasionally!
Sorlock fanatic & Arboreal Masterpiece
Any pronouns
Best friendos: Bananer, gato, and a buncha other people!
It's an edited version of the posted books. I don't know why you're upset about it if it isn't your homebrew anyway. I'm not suggesting that you're powergaming, just that the homebrew could be improved. :| I didn't even personally insult you or say anything about you.
— δ cyno • he/him • number one paladin fan δ —
making a smoothie for meta
——————| EXTENDED SIG |——————
Φ • happily married to my lovely redpelt, minmaxer, microbiology student, and lover of anything colored red • Φ
*The only difference is ours, you have 6 dm's and the Dm's double as players*
fellow follower of JEFF!!!! and a fan of BotW titles include:Beastmaster Extraordinaire,Wizened Beholder of the West Wind,Salvatore's Secret Archivist
Co-cult leader of the cynophobia cult
Archivist of the kingdoms and Crowns thread, Percy Jackson thread, Mechanicus and Realm of Dragons threads Admin of the Academy
PM me the word avocado :P
I have the 2024 version. I copy-pasted it.
Let him who is without sin cast the first stone.
Awake, impure, divine
Breathgiver of the Strugels
I meant the forums.
Let him who is without sin cast the first stone.
Awake, impure, divine
Breathgiver of the Strugels
*gtg *
fellow follower of JEFF!!!! and a fan of BotW titles include:Beastmaster Extraordinaire,Wizened Beholder of the West Wind,Salvatore's Secret Archivist
Co-cult leader of the cynophobia cult
Archivist of the kingdoms and Crowns thread, Percy Jackson thread, Mechanicus and Realm of Dragons threads Admin of the Academy
PM me the word avocado :P