Fanatics come fight here! ( 20th level gladiator arena )

Quote from iExist >>

pass. I cast spirit guardians and walk 30 feet towards you, drawing my sword in the process

also spiritual weapon. Attack: 31 Damage: 15

Also, not done with my turn.

Two saving throws are required regardless of whether you killed him or not... So you can roll those.

The exception is if you are trying to break my concentration... But I didn't see that so...

I had moved out of range of counterspell at some point, so I was 70 feet away, you cast a spell with a range of 60 feet without declaring move, so that's assumed that you moved the minimum required amount, then I moved forward 30 feet and cast spirit guardians

so no, all evidence points towards me not being dead. and that's before I factor in the high probability of cat me fleeing from you for even more distance

Quote from iExist >>

 

Quote from iExist >>

pass. I cast spirit guardians and walk 30 feet towards you, drawing my sword in the process

also spiritual weapon. Attack: 31 Damage: 15

 

 Ohhhhh... okay. Also, 

Second Attack: 18 Damage: 19 (range 40 - 120 ft.)

Yup. Not all evidance points to you being alive.

with what are you attacking? you didn't stow the luck blade that you used to polymorph me, and to stow or draw for the first time a turn is a free action, but to do it twice, it's an action

Also, move 30 ft.

and you're taking actions post-turn. provided that that last roll was directed towards cat me a round ago, and not cleric me now

Quote from iExist >>

with what are you attacking? you didn't stow the luck blade that you used to polymorph me, and to stow or draw for the first time a turn is a free action, but to do it twice, it's an action

 Also, I CAN ATTACK TWICE.

With my Laser Pistol.

Quote from iExist >>

and you're taking actions post-turn. provided that that last roll was directed towards cat me a round ago, and not cleric me now

 No, most of this is OCC, so in D&D time, I am attacking you then.

let me just run through the round of me being a cat: I was polymorphed by you, that's your action, timer starts, a charging mammoth arrives and attacks you before you can take your one round of attacks uninterrupted, spirit guardians prevents you from closing the distance well enough, you (still) have to save twice to not fall prone, and you fail to reach me.

and your round ended. I survived.

also, whenever you take the attack action. not you can attack once without using an action, but that is your action. you were holding a two handed weapon, that got transformed into a sword, you used some spells (requires a free hand), you didn't stow your newly acquired longsword, you pulled out the luck blade, and you would have to stow one of them to draw

I agree with iExist's logic on the attacking... you are doing a bit too much weapon swapping for it to be completely free... But I think that the spirit guardians actually should have gone away because there is no logical way that you can maintain concentration as a cat.

it's nowhere in the rules, nor spell description of polymorph and true polymorph (using for reference, as the closest thing to what the wish did), that concentration is dropped when polymorphed

DM should get the final say though...? Thoughts?

Quote from iExist >>

it's nowhere in the rules, nor spell description of polymorph and true polymorph (using for reference, as the closest thing to what the wish did), that concentration is dropped when polymorphed

*shrug* maybe *shrug*... But that is the way that I would rule it if I was DM. Again DM's call...