*what has my sig got to do with rangers?*

Navigator of an underground network? Sounds like a ranger thing.

*yeah, actually, it kinda does! It's a reference to one of my characters, who can often be found lurking in the sewers*

Quote from HeresJohnny1 >>

Rangers are bad.

 Entschuldi-frickin-gung?

Rangers are awesome.

Especially if you use the official Revised Ranger from that one UA document. 

Necro! Honestly, I just updated my signature and I now require immediate and obligatory validation. I’m shallow like that.

Quote from Smoke_and_Oakum >>

Quote from HeresJohnny1 >>

Rangers are bad.

 Entschuldi-frickin-gung?

 

Rangers are awesome.

Especially if you use the official Revised Ranger from that one UA document. 

Your signature is fantastic. Plain, simple, only takes up one line. I’m afraid I have to give it a 10/10, and then compensate by ruthlessly destroying the next poster’s sig.

I cant see signatures but uh I'll give you the default of 5/10

2/10 because you put in a section for listing your threads, but don’t list any of them there. Either tell us your threads, or don’t bother to put that in in! Also points deducted because you had to say “hi” twice. 

In case people can’t see signatures here’s mine:

Hey, I’m moon, i‘m aged between 3 and 300. Pronouns are She/They/It/It’s/Them/Her. I love D&D. I’m am chaotic neutral irl. I’m not afraid to punch someone. Mess with me and you’ll find out the hard way. extended sig

I am the goddess of the moon, the tides, and the axolotls

I am not a furry. 

Much appreciated.

Alright, let’s see here. “Hello!” and “Hi!” in the same line subtracts a point. Mod/Nessie/Invisible Teenager is fine.

“Don’t join Bahamut’s disco party! is just confusing. “Praise potassium!” is unnecessary. The Lord of Percussion bit is nice.

”And my threads: basically all aren't active, so not worth listing.” Then why list them? -1 point.

No interesting usage of color, fonts, or spacing. -1 point. Nothing is linked, but that’s not inherently a bad thing. I would keep things closer together instead of each detail a new line, but that’s just preference.

Total: 7/10, but since I’ll make it an arbitrary 6 since the last one I rated was 10.

NOT THE NINJA

Nothic I was 2 whole minutes ahead of you. Not a ninja…?

Quote from TheHarperMoon >>

Nothic I was 2 whole minutes ahead of you. Not a ninja…?

I was doing something else and forgot to refresh lol

Anyways.

Aged between 3 and 300 is the perfect amount of vagueness. Adding “it” to pronouns is interesting. 

“I’m not afraid to punch someone. Mess with me and you’ll find out the hard way.” is terrifying, but not an ideal threat considering the sig is online.

Impressive godly repertoire. Axolotls are cool. The furry bit is unnecessary, since there’s no reason to think you are one.

Total is 8.5/10. Nice use of bolding, italics, and color.

Quote from Nothic2SeeHere2 >>

Quote from TheHarperMoon >>

Nothic I was 2 whole minutes ahead of you. Not a ninja…?

I was doing something else and forgot to refresh lol

Anyways.

Aged between 3 and 300 is the perfect amount of vagueness. Adding “it” to pronouns is interesting. 

“I’m not afraid to punch someone. Mess with me and you’ll find out the hard way.” is terrifying, but not an ideal threat considering the sig is online.

Impressive godly repertoire. Axolotls are cool. The furry bit is unnecessary, since there’s no reason to think you are one.

Total is 8.5/10. Nice use of bolding, italics, and color.

 yay

Rate my updated one

Much better. Just noticed the “I’m am” typo, might wanna fix that. The fishie bit is better and improves the last line by a lot. 9/10.

I fixed the typo. Now rate it

10/10. The threat gives it some nice character. The spacing is also good.

ok I have finally pleased you lol. But thanks I didn’t realize I had a typo

Np :)

Now to criticize yours!

“This is what happens when you let a nothic onto the forums.” +1 point for adding the link

“My friends call me ic2Se” We don’t really, it was a just a joke. gibber wants to annoy everyone by giving them dumb nicknames. so -1 point

”My pfp is a selfie, credit here.” +0 points, because you got a -1 point for saying it’s a selfie (how!?) and +1 for crediting the image

“I hate sarcasm.” I’m confused. Are you saying this sarcastically or not? -1

“World’s most frustrating Extended Signature, here to deliver” doesn’t seem sarcastic ^^^ so I will give you a +0 for being consistent 

“Amateur mapmaker (link) and forever GM.“ this part is +1 for showing your mapmaking work

”My long-dead corpse“ why the heck is this important? -1.5

”Have a great Friday!” +1 because every day feels like the weekend on winter break!

+1 for making it unique by putting it on the opposite side

So…your overall rating is 9.5/10

Thanks for the feedback! The icSe part is just a joke, I know no one uses the names but I figured I’d play along. I’ll stop posting here for now so that other people can join the thread without having to rate the same person each time.