First of all, I mentioned the godfather because I assumed there was one, as it was mentioned in the recruitment thread. Secondly earlier I asked how many doctors there were, not wanting to reveal my role yet.
1. But why godfather in particular? If you look at the recruitment thread it's not the only role.
2. I didn't see any post, but not wanting to reveal your role yet? But asking that basically is saying you're doctor... Fishy.
Godfather just seems like it would be added, because it’s very similar to the regular mafia.
i said, “how many doctors are there?” Which doesn’t really mean I’m doctor, it just meant I was curious about how many there were. I asked because if there was only one doctor, I knew you were lying.
I know Gibber. But at the same time you don’t have a great defense, and your ignoring some of our stuff
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
First of all, I mentioned the godfather because I assumed there was one, as it was mentioned in the recruitment thread. Secondly earlier I asked how many doctors there were, not wanting to reveal my role yet.
1. But why godfather in particular? If you look at the recruitment thread it's not the only role.
2. I didn't see any post, but not wanting to reveal your role yet? But asking that basically is saying you're doctor... Fishy.
Godfather just seems like it would be added, because it’s very similar to the regular mafia.
i said, “how many doctors are there?” Which doesn’t really mean I’m doctor, it just meant I was curious about how many there were. I asked because if there was only one doctor, I knew you were lying.
Then it's common knowledge., why would you specifically mention it? Really weird.
Really, it's very obvious to tell you're doctor when you ask about said doctor. Or in this case, faking to be doctor. You were faking doctor from the beginning, and now that it's the finale you're going for me for a win.
Also, you only answer my unanswered questions when I say it's sus of you to ignore it. Why? Cause you don't want to be portrayed as sus.
And I've made several analysis on you, explaining why you are mafia/fake doctor, while you've only really made one point ("I'm doctor so clearly its gibber"). A real town would tend to analyze and think about who it is, while mafia would be less analyze more accuse or go with current susses. And the fact that PJ is joining in on this makes me pretty sure he's also mafia.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
Okay so if the 11 player set up we have added a godfather (a role which was mentioned in the recruitment thread but might not exist, I’m assuming it does) then that means there would be 3 mafia roles. Assuming half the players were townies that would round to either 5 or 6. That means there are either 3 or 4 special roles on the townie side assuming there aren’t any other mafia. Dutch is a cop, I’m a Doctor, someone (I forgot who, I’ll check after the post) was a Keebler Elf, and that means at most there is one more role, which is likely not a doctor too.
this is of course assuming there’s 5-6 townies and 3 mafia, which we aren’t sure of but are assuming based off of what Vitus said. There could be variations, which there probably are, but we don’t know that.
I sure hope I did all my math right.
But anyways: and coming back to Bear dying, I agree with PJ here. Why would I kill him? If anything it seems like an attempt to frame me. Even better, mafia could have killed you since you voted me last round, but wait! They can't kill you, you're mafia.
Not trying to offend you gibber but you seem to be saying "I dont think its them." or "I think its them" influencing the votes a bit. I dont find that too sus but ill keep my eye on you. Also if I die its prob not gibber, just a ploy to make him sus.
From earlier, day before bear died, go to page 28 (at least it's 28 for me, I hear pages are different on PC and stuff)
Here we see Bear saying it could be me (still am confused by what this theory is saying but that's irrelevant now). Then a few posts later Archfey voted for me. Now, why didn't he mention his whole doctor thing? Because back then he didn't have that excuse. He was just going with the crowd, who happened to be kinda sus of me at that point. Like what Kasrik did, just Archfey is actually mafia lol. Think about it: biggest thing in the town is information. So if you have another reason it could be the person being sussed (in this case me), you would have brought it up to contribute to the evidence. But when he needed a more convincing reason, he goes for the play of "you can't be doctor, I'm doctor" to try to vote me out and for mafia to win.
*Part of this wasn't acknowledged? He never mentioned his reasoning himself, which really is a bad idea if you're town because a big chunk of figuring out mafia is information. And he still could have mentioned the doctor thing, whether or not he had posted about claims of doctor before (even though he claims he wasn't saying he was doctor with that post anyways).*
We have seven players. Vitus said if we take out the wrong person or skip this day we will lose. So remove one townie, and we get this. (m means mafia, t means town)
M
M
M
T
T
T
Mafia win by making up 1/2 town, which is how I did this logic.
But anyways, Archfey seems to be sort of avoiding this fact, as seen by the trick of "if it's not Gibber vote me" and now this completely different way of solving. Perhaps he wants us to forget that by skipping, we lose, or he wants us to forget the risks that are at stake? Once again, not the best theory in this batch, this probably sounds like picking at straws, but I'm going off what we have.
Going over this again, could be a sort of psychological effect, you know? Not mentioning the lynch or lose so it seems less relevant? Or maybe I'm overthinking that one.
Also, I did edit the quotes to not include irrelevant information-- in the form of already answered questions.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
Though I must admit, the premise of suspicion by ignoring is kinda seeming less and less like a good theory. But these are good points that do still contribute to the case.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
First of all, I mentioned the godfather because I assumed there was one, as it was mentioned in the recruitment thread. Secondly earlier I asked how many doctors there were, not wanting to reveal my role yet.
1. But why godfather in particular? If you look at the recruitment thread it's not the only role.
2. I didn't see any post, but not wanting to reveal your role yet? But asking that basically is saying you're doctor... Fishy.
Godfather just seems like it would be added, because it’s very similar to the regular mafia.
i said, “how many doctors are there?” Which doesn’t really mean I’m doctor, it just meant I was curious about how many there were. I asked because if there was only one doctor, I knew you were lying.
Then it's common knowledge., why would you specifically mention it? Really weird.
Really, it's very obvious to tell you're doctor when you ask about said doctor. Or in this case, faking to be doctor. You were faking doctor from the beginning, and now that it's the finale you're going for me for a win.
Also, you only answer my unanswered questions when I say it's sus of you to ignore it. Why? Cause you don't want to be portrayed as sus.
And I've made several analysis on you, explaining why you are mafia/fake doctor, while you've only really made one point ("I'm doctor so clearly its gibber"). A real town would tend to analyze and think about who it is, while mafia would be less analyze more accuse or go with current susses. And the fact that PJ is joining in on this makes me pretty sure he's also mafia.
Oh, and this. You only went off the last sentence.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
Well, you don’t need every puzzle peace to gues correctly. And most of those questions aren’t that good, I know that’s sus, but dnd beyond takes so long to use
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
But then, what points does Archfey have? Basically all he's done is try to explain his way out of accusations, and stall for time by trying to figure out if there can be multiple doctors. And the fact that you two immediately jumped to vote me, with little to no explanation when you did it, that's one of the sussest things I've seen. No thinking in the game thread, so I'm pretty sure this is what went on behind the scenes in a nutshell:
IN THE MAFIA CHAT THREAD
PJ: hey, we need to frame someone, who do do we go for?
Arch: Uh, let's kill Bear and frame Gibber.
PJ: sounds good, let's frame the really cool guy (you all definitely said this)
Now that I think about it, why am I even trying to explain to a mafia? You've been on Arch's side the entire round, which basically just tells everyone you two are mafia. I'm just gonna wait for someone else to come online besides you two and hope they see sense.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
No. Why would I kill Bear? He was the next sus by me, so it doesn’t make sense for me to do that. Why kill someone who’s sus over someone’s who’s not sus?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
No. Why would I kill Bear? He was the next sus by me, so it doesn’t make sense for me to do that. Why kill someone who’s sus over someone’s who’s not sus?
Because he sussed me. Just kill him and frame me. Really simple.
I'd think with your experience you have in Mafia, you'd be able to know of a strategy like that. Perhaps you're ignoring this fact to keep the blame on me?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
No. Why would I kill Bear? He was the next sus by me, so it doesn’t make sense for me to do that. Why kill someone who’s sus over someone’s who’s not sus?
Because he sussed me. Just kill him and frame me. Really simple.
I'd think with your experience you have in Mafia, you'd be able to know of a strategy like that. Perhaps you're ignoring this fact to keep the blame on me?
He said not to vote Gibber if he died.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
No. Why would I kill Bear? He was the next sus by me, so it doesn’t make sense for me to do that. Why kill someone who’s sus over someone’s who’s not sus?
Because he sussed me. Just kill him and frame me. Really simple.
I'd think with your experience you have in Mafia, you'd be able to know of a strategy like that. Perhaps you're ignoring this fact to keep the blame on me?
He said not to vote Gibber if he died.
Maybe you killed him knowing we wouldn’t vote you!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
No. Why would I kill Bear? He was the next sus by me, so it doesn’t make sense for me to do that. Why kill someone who’s sus over someone’s who’s not sus?
Because he sussed me. Just kill him and frame me. Really simple.
I'd think with your experience you have in Mafia, you'd be able to know of a strategy like that. Perhaps you're ignoring this fact to keep the blame on me?
He said not to vote Gibber if he died.
Maybe you killed him knowing we wouldn’t vote you!
Except we are voting you and your plan failed
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
No. Why would I kill Bear? He was the next sus by me, so it doesn’t make sense for me to do that. Why kill someone who’s sus over someone’s who’s not sus?
Because he sussed me. Just kill him and frame me. Really simple.
I'd think with your experience you have in Mafia, you'd be able to know of a strategy like that. Perhaps you're ignoring this fact to keep the blame on me?
He said not to vote Gibber if he died.
Maybe you killed him knowing we wouldn’t vote you!
Except we are voting you and your plan failed
But if I did that, I would have said something like "Bear said not to vote me if he dies, so it's not me."
And once again: both of you voted me. At the same time. With no explanation. Can't be more obvious. You, Archfey and someone else are mafia 100%.
*Btw the reason I'm still explaining when I know you're mafia is so the people who read through later will have clarity as to the REAL mafia, while you're saying a bunch of lies to try to decieve them.*
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
I know Gibber. But at the same time you don’t have a great defense, and your ignoring some of our stuff
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head
Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
Then it's common knowledge., why would you specifically mention it? Really weird.
Really, it's very obvious to tell you're doctor when you ask about said doctor. Or in this case, faking to be doctor. You were faking doctor from the beginning, and now that it's the finale you're going for me for a win.
Also, you only answer my unanswered questions when I say it's sus of you to ignore it. Why? Cause you don't want to be portrayed as sus.
And I've made several analysis on you, explaining why you are mafia/fake doctor, while you've only really made one point ("I'm doctor so clearly its gibber"). A real town would tend to analyze and think about who it is, while mafia would be less analyze more accuse or go with current susses. And the fact that PJ is joining in on this makes me pretty sure he's also mafia.
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
A mysterious link of chain... (Extended signature). PRAISE JEFF THE EVIL ROOMBA! REALLY cool video.
One of the Warlock Patrons on the forums. Low, low price of your soul, your firstborn child and your liver!
Titles: The Echoing Story Spewer from Drummer, the Endless Maws from Isis, the Mad Murderer from PJ
I am not. Also Archfey has answered all your questions I’m pretty sure
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head
Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
"I am not mafia" is never a valid alibi. Games all about lying.
I made several points that have gone unnoticed.
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
A mysterious link of chain... (Extended signature). PRAISE JEFF THE EVIL ROOMBA! REALLY cool video.
One of the Warlock Patrons on the forums. Low, low price of your soul, your firstborn child and your liver!
Titles: The Echoing Story Spewer from Drummer, the Endless Maws from Isis, the Mad Murderer from PJ
Well, then by all means, quote or say these points
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head
Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
*Part of this wasn't acknowledged? He never mentioned his reasoning himself, which really is a bad idea if you're town because a big chunk of figuring out mafia is information. And he still could have mentioned the doctor thing, whether or not he had posted about claims of doctor before (even though he claims he wasn't saying he was doctor with that post anyways).*
Going over this again, could be a sort of psychological effect, you know? Not mentioning the lynch or lose so it seems less relevant? Or maybe I'm overthinking that one.
Also, I did edit the quotes to not include irrelevant information-- in the form of already answered questions.
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
A mysterious link of chain... (Extended signature). PRAISE JEFF THE EVIL ROOMBA! REALLY cool video.
One of the Warlock Patrons on the forums. Low, low price of your soul, your firstborn child and your liver!
Titles: The Echoing Story Spewer from Drummer, the Endless Maws from Isis, the Mad Murderer from PJ
Though I must admit, the premise of suspicion by ignoring is kinda seeming less and less like a good theory. But these are good points that do still contribute to the case.
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
A mysterious link of chain... (Extended signature). PRAISE JEFF THE EVIL ROOMBA! REALLY cool video.
One of the Warlock Patrons on the forums. Low, low price of your soul, your firstborn child and your liver!
Titles: The Echoing Story Spewer from Drummer, the Endless Maws from Isis, the Mad Murderer from PJ
Oh, and this. You only went off the last sentence.
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
A mysterious link of chain... (Extended signature). PRAISE JEFF THE EVIL ROOMBA! REALLY cool video.
One of the Warlock Patrons on the forums. Low, low price of your soul, your firstborn child and your liver!
Titles: The Echoing Story Spewer from Drummer, the Endless Maws from Isis, the Mad Murderer from PJ
Well, you don’t need every puzzle peace to gues correctly. And most of those questions aren’t that good, I know that’s sus, but dnd beyond takes so long to use
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head
Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
But then, what points does Archfey have? Basically all he's done is try to explain his way out of accusations, and stall for time by trying to figure out if there can be multiple doctors. And the fact that you two immediately jumped to vote me, with little to no explanation when you did it, that's one of the sussest things I've seen. No thinking in the game thread, so I'm pretty sure this is what went on behind the scenes in a nutshell:
IN THE MAFIA CHAT THREAD
PJ: hey, we need to frame someone, who do do we go for?
Arch: Uh, let's kill Bear and frame Gibber.
PJ: sounds good, let's frame the really cool guy (you all definitely said this)
Now that I think about it, why am I even trying to explain to a mafia? You've been on Arch's side the entire round, which basically just tells everyone you two are mafia. I'm just gonna wait for someone else to come online besides you two and hope they see sense.
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
A mysterious link of chain... (Extended signature). PRAISE JEFF THE EVIL ROOMBA! REALLY cool video.
One of the Warlock Patrons on the forums. Low, low price of your soul, your firstborn child and your liver!
Titles: The Echoing Story Spewer from Drummer, the Endless Maws from Isis, the Mad Murderer from PJ
No. Why would I kill Bear? He was the next sus by me, so it doesn’t make sense for me to do that. Why kill someone who’s sus over someone’s who’s not sus?
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head
Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
I already explained how I thought Bear could be right about you being mafia a little back, then he died. He said it wouldn’t be you, but i think it
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head
Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
Is*
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head
Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
Because he sussed me. Just kill him and frame me. Really simple.
I'd think with your experience you have in Mafia, you'd be able to know of a strategy like that. Perhaps you're ignoring this fact to keep the blame on me?
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
A mysterious link of chain... (Extended signature). PRAISE JEFF THE EVIL ROOMBA! REALLY cool video.
One of the Warlock Patrons on the forums. Low, low price of your soul, your firstborn child and your liver!
Titles: The Echoing Story Spewer from Drummer, the Endless Maws from Isis, the Mad Murderer from PJ
Also, you only explained after I asked. Because obviously ignoring the question would be extremely sus.
"Why'd you vote me?"
"..."
"I said why did you vote me?"
"..."
Also, you and Archfey really just sort of united to vote me. Same time, no explanations until I asked. Mafia chat.
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
A mysterious link of chain... (Extended signature). PRAISE JEFF THE EVIL ROOMBA! REALLY cool video.
One of the Warlock Patrons on the forums. Low, low price of your soul, your firstborn child and your liver!
Titles: The Echoing Story Spewer from Drummer, the Endless Maws from Isis, the Mad Murderer from PJ
He said not to vote Gibber if he died.
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head
Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
Maybe you killed him knowing we wouldn’t vote you!
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head
Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
Except we are voting you and your plan failed
Bang! Bang! Maxwell's silver hammer came down upon her head
Clang! Clang! Maxwell's silver hammer made sure that she was dead
But if I did that, I would have said something like "Bear said not to vote me if he dies, so it's not me."
And once again: both of you voted me. At the same time. With no explanation. Can't be more obvious. You, Archfey and someone else are mafia 100%.
*Btw the reason I'm still explaining when I know you're mafia is so the people who read through later will have clarity as to the REAL mafia, while you're saying a bunch of lies to try to decieve them.*
Hello! I am a perfectly sane gibberer. Hi! :D
Locations are dead, the Temple of Potassium has fallen but its ideals live on
A mysterious link of chain... (Extended signature). PRAISE JEFF THE EVIL ROOMBA! REALLY cool video.
One of the Warlock Patrons on the forums. Low, low price of your soul, your firstborn child and your liver!
Titles: The Echoing Story Spewer from Drummer, the Endless Maws from Isis, the Mad Murderer from PJ
Guys, the only way this should be settled is a dice roll!
*Smart ghost advice!*
*Just checking I’m allowed to say that.*
Characters (Links!):
Faelin Nighthollow - 7th Sojourn