Hallow's Eve At Gibburg Manor: Mafia Game Thread

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

I don't have many suspicions. I find Vitus slightly sus and kinda agree with Himy, but still:

VOTE: SKIP

 That’s weird, cause Himy and Vitus are kinda using the same theory.

 They are? Maybe i'm not reading things properly, lemme recheck.

 They’re both saying that Dragon and Plat are suspicious cause they’re against a vote that would likely benefit us

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

I don't have many suspicions. I find Vitus slightly sus and kinda agree with Himy, but still:

VOTE: SKIP

 That’s weird, cause Himy and Vitus are kinda using the same theory.

 They are? Maybe i'm not reading things properly, lemme recheck.

 They’re both saying that Dragon and Plat are suspicious cause they’re against a vote that would likely benefit us

 Ah, yes I see now. Sorry bout that, I agree with both of them. I skimmed through the first 3 pages

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

I don't have many suspicions. I find Vitus slightly sus and kinda agree with Himy, but still:

VOTE: SKIP

 That’s weird, cause Himy and Vitus are kinda using the same theory.

 They are? Maybe i'm not reading things properly, lemme recheck.

 They’re both saying that Dragon and Plat are suspicious cause they’re against a vote that would likely benefit us

 I'm not sure the vote would. Like Himy said, we only have a 42% chance at best to vote out someone harmful. I would assume that it's a 33% chance though. So a 67% chance to vote out someone helpful.

Quote from Platyboss >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

I don't have many suspicions. I find Vitus slightly sus and kinda agree with Himy, but still:

VOTE: SKIP

 That’s weird, cause Himy and Vitus are kinda using the same theory.

 They are? Maybe i'm not reading things properly, lemme recheck.

 They’re both saying that Dragon and Plat are suspicious cause they’re against a vote that would likely benefit us

 I'm not sure the vote would. Like Himy said, we only have a 42% chance at best to vote out someone harmful. I would assume that it's a 33% chance though. So a 67% chance to vote out someone helpful.

 I can see your point, but with no vote that means the mafia effectively have a free kill.

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

Quote from Platyboss >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from EJODM18604 >>

I don't have many suspicions. I find Vitus slightly sus and kinda agree with Himy, but still:

VOTE: SKIP

 That’s weird, cause Himy and Vitus are kinda using the same theory.

 They are? Maybe i'm not reading things properly, lemme recheck.

 They’re both saying that Dragon and Plat are suspicious cause they’re against a vote that would likely benefit us

 I'm not sure the vote would. Like Himy said, we only have a 42% chance at best to vote out someone harmful. I would assume that it's a 33% chance though. So a 67% chance to vote out someone helpful.

 I can see your point, but with no vote that means the mafia effectively have a free kill.

 Oh wait that actually does make sense

I'm new to this, sorry. I still might wait a little while to see if someone does something sus just in case.

Unvote: Skip

Alrighty then. Now, Dragon, do you have anything to say in your defense?

Quote from himynamesare >>

Alrighty then. Now, Dragon, do you have anything to say in your defense?

I think that voting without any information is a bad idea, but some people are acting kinda sus. Skipping the first vote makes sense since there are still a lot of townies

Also I like turtles

Quote from The_DragonTamer >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Alrighty then. Now, Dragon, do you have anything to say in your defense?

I think that voting without any information is a bad idea, but some people are acting kinda sus. Skipping the first vote makes sense since there are still a lot of townies

 

Also I like turtles

 Like said above, skipping pretty much gives the mafia a free kill, the cultist as free bind, and we need to get the poltergeist out asap, as killing six people is a lot. And plus, there are deffo some sus people. Namely you and Plat 

Quote from The_DragonTamer >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Alrighty then. Now, Dragon, do you have anything to say in your defense?

I think that voting without any information is a bad idea, but some people are acting kinda sus. Skipping the first vote makes sense since there are still a lot of townies

 

Also I like turtles

 Me too. Platypuses are better though.

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from The_DragonTamer >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Alrighty then. Now, Dragon, do you have anything to say in your defense?

I think that voting without any information is a bad idea, but some people are acting kinda sus. Skipping the first vote makes sense since there are still a lot of townies

 

Also I like turtles

 Like said above, skipping pretty much gives the mafia a free kill, the cultist as free bind, and we need to get the poltergeist out asap, as killing six people is a lot. And plus, there are deffo some sus people. Namely you and Plat 

Voting out the wrong person also gives the mafia a free kill though. And there's at least a 67% chance we vote a townie

Can everyone vote? It seems as if this day drags on without a different discussion, it would be nice to move along 

I think it’s fine to skip, most people are. But only because there’s no strong suspicions, next round we must vote off someone 

Honestly both of the arguments hold up. Not voting is a free kill for the mafia but with so little information it’s a shot in the dark to vote someone off yet.

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Honestly both of the arguments hold up. Not voting is a free kill for the mafia but with so little information it’s a shot in the dark to vote someone off yet.

 You miss every shot you don't take

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Honestly both of the arguments hold up. Not voting is a free kill for the mafia but with so little information it’s a shot in the dark to vote someone off yet.

 You miss every shot you don't take

 Well then, by all means, who should we vote?

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Honestly both of the arguments hold up. Not voting is a free kill for the mafia but with so little information it’s a shot in the dark to vote someone off yet.

 You miss every shot you don't take

 Well then, by all means, who should we vote?

 Said it once and I'll say it again. Plat and Dragon are sus. Do what you will 

Quote from The_DragonTamer >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from Platyboss >>

I'm against the first day vote. I don't think anyone has done or said anything particularly suspicious or incriminating yet. Also, like I said earlier, I'm worried we'll vote out an important person. It'd be annoying if we voted out Guardian Angel first day.

 There's also a chance we vote out a mafia or neutral, which is good for us. It's around 50/50 odds I believe. We'll be keeping an eye on you

Gibber, can we get a read on how many of each role there are at the start of the game? 

 Ah, but you see, figuring out which roles there are and aren't is half the fun! :D

But I will tell you that it's more balanced then the last time I did a mafia game, and that I used a tip that (connection terminated)-- which is (actually, if nobody's seen this, I'm gonna redact it. More fun seeing you guys try to figure the placement out. Otherwise, oh well.)

VOTES

Platyboss: VitusW

PJtheARCH3R: Nothic3SeeHere, RRRogue16

The_DragonTamer: Himynamesare

VitusW: The_DragonTamer

Skip Vote/NoLynch: FlowerField, pandalv829, PJtheARCH3R, EJO

Note: It would help if you guys put your votes in all caps, or bold if you can but you don't have to go out of your way to do that. Makes things easier to see for me.

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Honestly both of the arguments hold up. Not voting is a free kill for the mafia but with so little information it’s a shot in the dark to vote someone off yet.

 You miss every shot you don't take

 Well then, by all means, who should we vote?

 Said it once and I'll say it again. Plat and Dragon are sus. Do what you will 

 Evidence? You seem kinda sus, it’s too early to have any real evidence but you are just saying that it’s plat and dragon. So evidence?

 Like Vitus has said before, being so adamantly against a lynch is anti town behavior, as voting has around a1/3 odd of getting someone bad out, at most an almost 50/50 chance, which are decent odds. My guess is that Dragon is a neutral, as a cultist would want to keep as many people alive as possible. And then, suspecting Vitus for quote unquote “Voting blindly” is a bit odd, as we know have two suspects. And then voting someone just because they voted you is even more sus, as if you were town, you should be able to defend yourself and prove why they shouldn’t vote you. Doing otherwise makes it seem like you’re trying to scare them off your tail, which is a very mafia of neutral thing to do 

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Honestly both of the arguments hold up. Not voting is a free kill for the mafia but with so little information it’s a shot in the dark to vote someone off yet.

 You miss every shot you don't take

 Well then, by all means, who should we vote?

 Said it once and I'll say it again. Plat and Dragon are sus. Do what you will 

 Evidence? You seem kinda sus, it’s too early to have any real evidence but you are just saying that it’s plat and dragon. So evidence?

 Like Vitus has said before, being so adamantly against a lynch is anti town behavior, as voting has around a1/3 odd of getting someone bad out, at most an almost 50/50 chance, which are decent odds. My guess is that Dragon is a neutral, as a cultist would want to keep as many people alive as possible. And then, suspecting Vitus for quote unquote “Voting blindly” is a bit odd, as we know have two suspects. And then voting someone just because they voted you is even more sus, as if you were town, you should be able to defend yourself and prove why they shouldn’t vote you. Doing otherwise makes it seem like you’re trying to scare them off your tail, which is a very mafia of neutral thing to do 

 its not precisely a free kill because if the Guardian Angel (Doctor) makes the right choice, the person that they choose will not die if they are attacked.

Quote from FlowerField >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Honestly both of the arguments hold up. Not voting is a free kill for the mafia but with so little information it’s a shot in the dark to vote someone off yet.

 You miss every shot you don't take

 Well then, by all means, who should we vote?

 Said it once and I'll say it again. Plat and Dragon are sus. Do what you will 

 Evidence? You seem kinda sus, it’s too early to have any real evidence but you are just saying that it’s plat and dragon. So evidence?

 Like Vitus has said before, being so adamantly against a lynch is anti town behavior, as voting has around a1/3 odd of getting someone bad out, at most an almost 50/50 chance, which are decent odds. My guess is that Dragon is a neutral, as a cultist would want to keep as many people alive as possible. And then, suspecting Vitus for quote unquote “Voting blindly” is a bit odd, as we know have two suspects. And then voting someone just because they voted you is even more sus, as if you were town, you should be able to defend yourself and prove why they shouldn’t vote you. Doing otherwise makes it seem like you’re trying to scare them off your tail, which is a very mafia of neutral thing to do 

 its not precisely a free kill because if the Guardian Angel (Doctor) makes the right choice, the person that they choose will not die if they are attacked.

 That’s a 9% chance of working out.Those are bad odds. If you count the jailor those odds get better (up to 18%) but still not good. There’s also the chance that the mafia attack one of them, not allowing us to profit of them anymore.