UPDATE: The DM asked the new player again to use the Standard Array. The session was almost finished, so I don't know what'll happen with the next one, but the player protested that if he used the Standard Array, his character "Wouldn't be balanced at all." How should this be handled?
I'm not going to tell you the exact context for privacy reasons, but asking the player to leave the group isn't really an option.
UPDATE: The DM asked the new player again to use the Standard Array. The session was almost finished, so I don't know what'll happen with the next one, but the player protested that if he used the Standard Array, his character "Wouldn't be balanced at all." How should this be handled?
I'm not going to tell you the exact context for privacy reasons, but asking the player to leave the group isn't really an option.
It is always an option.
Standard Array is balanced the player is just being whiny because they want their OP stats. The DM just needs to stick to their guns and tell the player to grow up.
-
An option the DM can choose instead, if everyone agrees, then everyone can roll for stats but all stats must be rolled in front of the group (so the player will need to reroll their stats). Or instead of rolling they all choose Point Buy.
UPDATE: The DM asked the new player again to use the Standard Array. The session was almost finished, so I don't know what'll happen with the next one, but the player protested that if he used the Standard Array, his character "Wouldn't be balanced at all." How should this be handled?
I'm not going to tell you the exact context for privacy reasons, but asking the player to leave the group isn't really an option.
There is only one class that requires 3 stats to be good, Paladin. And the standard array forces such players to choose one of 3 gameplay options. Caster - Char is highest, Tank - Con is highest, DPR - Strength is highest.
This is a balance point, allowing a paladin to be good at all three is broken. This player sounds like they want a Max-Max character aka Jack of All trades bad at none. Or as I like to say bad player. Tell the DM openly to everyone that if they allow such a player to play, you are gone. It's better to find a new game than play with a bad player.
---
Note the 3 stat paladin problem is why a 1 level Warlock Dip is so popular with paladins.
UPDATE: The DM asked the new player again to use the Standard Array. The session was almost finished, so I don't know what'll happen with the next one, but the player protested that if he used the Standard Array, his character "Wouldn't be balanced at all." How should this be handled?
I'm not going to tell you the exact context for privacy reasons, but asking the player to leave the group isn't really an option.
Kick him. He does not want to follow the rules and is outright lying. Standard Array is balanced. There is no reason a character would need super OP scores to be playable.
'...but the player protested that if he used the Standard Array, his character "Wouldn't be balanced at all."
I'm not sure the Player understands what balanced means.
Cyb3rm1nd is right on the money. The Player is not playing by the rules which the rest of the party are adhering to and the DM allowing the Player to bend the rules 'just cuz' is not sporting at all.
D&D is a team game; your character is purposefully not supposed to be a specialist at everything.
Have the Physical Books? Confused as to why you're not allowed to redeem them for free on D&D Beyond? Questions answered here at the Hardcover Books, D&D Beyond and You FAQ
Looking to add mouse-over triggered tooltips to such things like magic items, monsters or combat actions? Then dash over to the How to Add Tooltips thread.
If it were my game and a player refused to adhere to the character generation rules I would be very tempted to kick them. Campaign just started, they're new, no big loss.
On the flip side if for some "unknown" reason the player gets to stay and keep their stats (Betting on girlfriend/boyfriend, close relative, or best friend). I would deeply consider letting the rest of the party have the same numbers. Just give the same stats for everybody to use. No bitterness, no resentment, everything on a level field again, Play On.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"Sooner or later, your Players are going to smash your railroad into a sandbox."
-Vedexent
"real life is a super high CR."
-OboeLauren
"............anybody got any potatoes? We could drop a potato in each hole an' see which ones get viciously mauled by horrible monsters?"
UPDATE: The DM asked the new player again to use the Standard Array. The session was almost finished, so I don't know what'll happen with the next one, but the player protested that if he used the Standard Array, his character "Wouldn't be balanced at all." How should this be handled?
I'm not going to tell you the exact context for privacy reasons, but asking the player to leave the group isn't really an option.
Ultimately, if you're not the GM it's not up to you to handle it. You can express your concerns (politely) to the GM if you feel the need to, but the only other option is leaving the game if it becomes too disruptive.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Find your own truth, choose your enemies carefully, and never deal with a dragon.
"Canon" is what's factual to D&D lore. "Cannon" is what you're going to be shot with if you keep getting the word wrong.
Note the 3 stat paladin problem is why a 1 level Warlock Dip is so popular with paladins.
That statement is totally confusing. Why would multiclassing solve the need for three good ability stats? It would seem it makes it worse.
simple, Pact of the Blade in 2014 allowed a Paldin to have an 8 in strength and in 5.5 Pact of the Blade allows a palidin to have a 13 in strength. This means you can put everything in Charisma for both melee attacks and spell casting, with con being high for HP.
Is this group hurting for numbers? Does this player have a relationship with the DM that is affecting the fair and balanced enforcement of the rules? If this person is asked to leave will the whole campaign fold?
I've been in two groups that had a problem player. At times I started wondering why I was sitting there putting up with the nonsense. in one case the campaign folded and I didn't miss it at all. Completely obnoxious player. In the other campaign all the other players, including the DM simply explained to the problem player that it just wasn't working out with him and it would be best if he found another table. He had been given several opportunities and we tried to teach him but it simply became time to cut him loose. It was handled politely and professionally and the group not only survived but it expanded.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
UPDATE: The DM asked the new player again to use the Standard Array. The session was almost finished, so I don't know what'll happen with the next one, but the player protested that if he used the Standard Array, his character "Wouldn't be balanced at all." How should this be handled?
I'm not going to tell you the exact context for privacy reasons, but asking the player to leave the group isn't really an option.
It is always an option.
Standard Array is balanced the player is just being whiny because they want their OP stats. The DM just needs to stick to their guns and tell the player to grow up.
-
An option the DM can choose instead, if everyone agrees, then everyone can roll for stats but all stats must be rolled in front of the group (so the player will need to reroll their stats). Or instead of rolling they all choose Point Buy.
<< USEFUL LINKS >>
Support >> Site Rules || Bugs & Support || Help Portal || Contact Support
Homebrew >> Rules & Guidelines || FAQ / Guide || How To Use Snippets || How To Use Tooltips || More Tutorials
My YouTube >> I sometimes make video guides and tutorials for D&D Beyond which you can see here.
There is only one class that requires 3 stats to be good, Paladin. And the standard array forces such players to choose one of 3 gameplay options. Caster - Char is highest, Tank - Con is highest, DPR - Strength is highest.
This is a balance point, allowing a paladin to be good at all three is broken. This player sounds like they want a Max-Max character aka Jack of All trades bad at none. Or as I like to say bad player. Tell the DM openly to everyone that if they allow such a player to play, you are gone. It's better to find a new game than play with a bad player.
---
Note the 3 stat paladin problem is why a 1 level Warlock Dip is so popular with paladins.
Kick him. He does not want to follow the rules and is outright lying. Standard Array is balanced. There is no reason a character would need super OP scores to be playable.
That statement is totally confusing. Why would multiclassing solve the need for three good ability stats? It would seem it makes it worse.
Pact of the Blade lets you attack with Charisma, and Warlocks use Charisma for their spellcasting.
I'm not sure the Player understands what balanced means.
Cyb3rm1nd is right on the money. The Player is not playing by the rules which the rest of the party are adhering to and the DM allowing the Player to bend the rules 'just cuz' is not sporting at all.
D&D is a team game; your character is purposefully not supposed to be a specialist at everything.
#Open D&D
Have the Physical Books? Confused as to why you're not allowed to redeem them for free on D&D Beyond? Questions answered here at the Hardcover Books, D&D Beyond and You FAQ
Looking to add mouse-over triggered tooltips to such things like magic items, monsters or combat actions? Then dash over to the How to Add Tooltips thread.
If it were my game and a player refused to adhere to the character generation rules I would be very tempted to kick them. Campaign just started, they're new, no big loss.
On the flip side if for some "unknown" reason the player gets to stay and keep their stats (Betting on girlfriend/boyfriend, close relative, or best friend). I would deeply consider letting the rest of the party have the same numbers. Just give the same stats for everybody to use. No bitterness, no resentment, everything on a level field again, Play On.
"Sooner or later, your Players are going to smash your railroad into a sandbox."
-Vedexent
"real life is a super high CR."
-OboeLauren
"............anybody got any potatoes? We could drop a potato in each hole an' see which ones get viciously mauled by horrible monsters?"
-Ilyara Thundertale
Ultimately, if you're not the GM it's not up to you to handle it. You can express your concerns (politely) to the GM if you feel the need to, but the only other option is leaving the game if it becomes too disruptive.
Find your own truth, choose your enemies carefully, and never deal with a dragon.
"Canon" is what's factual to D&D lore. "Cannon" is what you're going to be shot with if you keep getting the word wrong.
simple, Pact of the Blade in 2014 allowed a Paldin to have an 8 in strength and in 5.5 Pact of the Blade allows a palidin to have a 13 in strength. This means you can put everything in Charisma for both melee attacks and spell casting, with con being high for HP.
an Example Paladin as I would make it. Going with level 4... or 3 paladin 1 warlock. https://www.dndbeyond.com/characters/173731124 this would be a melee DPR powerhouse.
Is this group hurting for numbers? Does this player have a relationship with the DM that is affecting the fair and balanced enforcement of the rules? If this person is asked to leave will the whole campaign fold?
I've been in two groups that had a problem player. At times I started wondering why I was sitting there putting up with the nonsense. in one case the campaign folded and I didn't miss it at all. Completely obnoxious player. In the other campaign all the other players, including the DM simply explained to the problem player that it just wasn't working out with him and it would be best if he found another table. He had been given several opportunities and we tried to teach him but it simply became time to cut him loose. It was handled politely and professionally and the group not only survived but it expanded.