For any “wall” spell that allows you to create the wall in a “circle that has a 20-foot diameter…,” is that the inner diameter, or the outer diameter? For spells like wall of fire, wall of water, or wind wall it’s a little less important since they are only 1 foot thick, but a wall of thorns is 5 feet thick, so that makes a big difference. How do you rule it?
DM mostly, Player occasionally, He/Him/They/Them, Doctor, Published Scholar, Science and Healthcare Advocate, Reader, Critter, Trekkie, Gandalf with a Glock
Playing on a grid, I’d likely say inner. I’d count 8 squares across and put the wall on either side.
But then playing on a grid, most all my circles and spheres become squares and cubes, so I may not be the best source.
My circles get squared too during grid play so an effect creating a ringed wall or circle up to 20 feet in diameter would fill a 4 x 4 squares at the maximum, as limited by the spell.
Playing on a grid, I’d likely say inner. I’d count 8 squares across and put the wall on either side.
But then playing on a grid, most all my circles and spheres become squares and cubes, so I may not be the best source.
My circles get squared too during grid play so an effect creating a ringed wall or circle up to 20 feet in diameter would fill a 4 x 4 squares at the maximum, as limited by the spell.
Ahh, diameter, not radius, I read it wrong. So yes, a 4x4 square.
For any “wall” spell that allows you to create the wall in a “circle that has a 20-foot diameter…,” is that the inner diameter, or the outer diameter? For spells like wall of fire, wall of water, or wind wall it’s a little less important since they are only 1 foot thick, but a wall of thorns is 5 feet thick, so that makes a big difference. How do you rule it?
Creating Epic Boons on DDB
DDB Buyers' Guide
Hardcovers, DDB & You
Content Troubleshooting
The outer diameter.
I’d probably measure center to center, so neither.
Playing on a grid, I’d likely say inner. I’d count 8 squares across and put the wall on either side.
But then playing on a grid, most all my circles and spheres become squares and cubes, so I may not be the best source.
Personally, I would rule whatever way benefits the player most. But I am the crazy DM that gave everyone at my table an artifact item at level 1 so...
DM mostly, Player occasionally, He/Him/They/Them, Doctor, Published Scholar, Science and Healthcare Advocate, Reader, Critter, Trekkie, Gandalf with a Glock
Archived PCs: Barbarian: Rhoc, Bard: Ravinia, Blood Hunter: Steffen, Cleric: Belora, Mjornier, Morana, Wren, Fighter: Shri'tanabryn, Monk: Cassandra, Paladin: Eirikur, Rogue: Joy, Warlock: Arkros, Wizard: Suki
Make it so (RIP SPS)
My circles get squared too during grid play so an effect creating a ringed wall or circle up to 20 feet in diameter would fill a 4 x 4 squares at the maximum, as limited by the spell.
Ahh, diameter, not radius, I read it wrong. So yes, a 4x4 square.
Well, thank you all for your replies!! I genuinely appreciate the different takes on this situation.
Creating Epic Boons on DDB
DDB Buyers' Guide
Hardcovers, DDB & You
Content Troubleshooting
You're welcome! May i ask what is your take on this?
I’m not sure, which is why I asked. RAW I think it’s OD, but RAI I think it might be ID. I like SagaTympana’s idea of splitting the difference though.
Creating Epic Boons on DDB
DDB Buyers' Guide
Hardcovers, DDB & You
Content Troubleshooting