Hey. Hey guys. I may have had an idea. Tell it to me straight if I'm chasing faeries with this line of thought...
BUT!
Imagine this: Warlock. No longer regain spell slots on Short Rest. Instead, we're going all-in on the new Magical Cunning trait. Warlocks, after all, don't use their own inner power (as sorcerers), nor do they study complex forms to manipulate extant forces (wizards). No, warlocks steal and borrow, right? So, they only use their little minute's worth of haphazard rite to call up their sugar parent and/or dark overlord and beg for some more cake off of the big table. No need to sit down nice and tidy for a right cuppa, all of that short rest.
In this model, we're embracing symmetry and a warlock of level 1 through 5 has 1 spell slot, 6 through 10 has 2, 11 through 16 has 3, and 17+ has 4. Just like with cantrip damage upgrades. We like symmetry.
However, Magical Cunning can be used your proficiency bonus times per day, now. (which, incidentally, allows the warlock's magic power to sorta-kinda multiclass scale a tiny bit, just like other spellcasters can piggyback off of another casting class). And since it is a minute to perform, it won't provide a character with extra slots to use within a single combat encounter, as they're still limited to their maximum number of slots they can hold at a time. Basically, this model replaces the short rest discussion with a fixed number, easily accessed, out-of-combat recovery system.
So, it'd look something like this:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Warlock Level Max Slots Magical Cunning Total Daily Slots
So. Am I due to give my brain a little vacation, or am I actually having a proper idea here? :)
personally, i feel like the 1 minute downtime required to accomplish Magical Cunning is plenty cost. it cannot be cast in combat and it can be interrupted. so then, a short rest with as little mother-may-i as possible (minus the healing, but also minus the clock stop). if it also broke concentration, can anyone name a good reason to limit number of uses of Magical Cunning at all? a reason that isn't also an argument for limiting number of short rests in a day, anyway.
This doesn't qualify for your second point, but I think the second point sort of ignores that the short rest mechanic exists as a pacing mechanic. If the Warlock can regain their most powerful spells on any 1-minute rest they'll virtually never be stressed for spell resources the way that other full casters can be. Taking a breather X number of times between encounters before a long rest is one thing, but virtually unlimited magical cunning just removes that pacing mechanic from the DM's toolbox.
Can't we just go with the Channel Divinity route? At this point it really is the best compromise between the people whom like the current Pactslots and those that feel it's too restricted/punishing. It also has the added benefits of making the Warlock experience more consistent while reducing the multiclass benefits.
TBH those summoning spells shouldn't be allowed to be upcast beyond level 5 because from 6th level + those summons are more powerful than the average martial, which as a martial-loving player I find really horrid.
I think it's a poorly built martial indeed who can't keep up with an upcast Summon. More importantly, the problem is that only Warlocks are restricted in this way - Wizards, Druids, Clerics, Bards with MS, and Sorcerers like Clockwork or Aberrant Mind all have no issue with upcasting those summons to 6th or 8th level. Even if you leave the restriction in place for Warlocks, it doesn't stop those summons from existing for pretty much all of the other full casters.
Hey. Hey guys. I may have had an idea. Tell it to me straight if I'm chasing faeries with this line of thought...
BUT!
Imagine this: Warlock. No longer regain spell slots on Short Rest. Instead, we're going all-in on the new Magical Cunning trait. Warlocks, after all, don't use their own inner power (as sorcerers), nor do they study complex forms to manipulate extant forces (wizards). No, warlocks steal and borrow, right? So, they only use their little minute's worth of haphazard rite to call up their sugar parent and/or dark overlord and beg for some more cake off of the big table. No need to sit down nice and tidy for a right cuppa, all of that short rest.
In this model, we're embracing symmetry and a warlock of level 1 through 5 has 1 spell slot, 6 through 10 has 2, 11 through 16 has 3, and 17+ has 4. Just like with cantrip damage upgrades. We like symmetry.
However, Magical Cunning can be used your proficiency bonus times per day, now. (which, incidentally, allows the warlock's magic power to sorta-kinda multiclass scale a tiny bit, just like other spellcasters can piggyback off of another casting class). And since it is a minute to perform, it won't provide a character with extra slots to use within a single combat encounter, as they're still limited to their maximum number of slots they can hold at a time. Basically, this model replaces the short rest discussion with a fixed number, easily accessed, out-of-combat recovery system.
So, it'd look something like this: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Warlock Level Max Slots Magical Cunning Total Daily Slots
So. Am I due to give my brain a little vacation, or am I actually having a proper idea here? :)
THANK you! THAT'S what I've been wanting from the START! That's along the lines of what I suggested since the start of the previous Warlock playtest, and NO ONE listened to me! Thank you!!!
(I'd tie it to class level rather than proficiency bonus myself, but the principle idea is the same)
TBH those summoning spells shouldn't be allowed to be upcast beyond level 5 because from 6th level + those summons are more powerful than the average martial, which as a martial-loving player I find really horrid.
I think it's a poorly built martial indeed who can't keep up with an upcast Summon. More importantly, the problem is that only Warlocks are restricted in this way - Wizards, Druids, Clerics, Bards with MS, and Sorcerers like Clockwork or Aberrant Mind all have no issue with upcasting those summons to 6th or 8th level. Even if you leave the restriction in place for Warlocks, it doesn't stop those summons from existing for pretty much all of the other full casters.
Agile's got a point.
I love the ideas of a summoned monster, but it's still adding another body on the field and equivalent to getting and equal or higher level PC come in to help.
I think his concern is reasonable as spellcasters tend to outstrip martials too easily, (I don't mind a SMALL power imbalance, but it's a bit crazy with some of the spell list), but instead of banning up casting, lowering the level of what gets summoned would be better and,l if that sucks too much, there's other mechanics that can be tweaked than just power level to hit the right sweet spot
THANK you! THAT'S what I've been wanting from the START! That's along the lines of what I suggested since the start of the previous Warlock playtest, and NO ONE listened to me! Thank you!!!
(I'd tie it to class level rather than proficiency bonus myself, but the principle idea is the same)
I only became forum-active recently, so I didn't see your (obviously brilliant) suggestion back then. Otherwise I'd have credited you for inspiration, Mezzie! But we can share in this clear and overflowing genius (while also being perplexingly humble)!
I love the ideas of a summoned monster, but it's still adding another body on the field and equivalent to getting and equal or higher level PC come in to help.
I think his concern is reasonable as spellcasters tend to outstrip martials too easily, (I don't mind a SMALL power imbalance, but it's a bit crazy with some of the spell list), but instead of banning up casting, lowering the level of what gets summoned would be better and,l if that sucks too much, there's other mechanics that can be tweaked than just power level to hit the right sweet spot
Tasha Summons are useful, but they're hardly outstripping martials. Conjure X can do so, especially on a Shepherd Druid, but that's a problem with those spells specifically (and remember that the DM controls exactly what you get from those anyway) rather than with the concept of summoning as a whole.
I love the ideas of a summoned monster, but it's still adding another body on the field and equivalent to getting and equal or higher level PC come in to help.
I think his concern is reasonable as spellcasters tend to outstrip martials too easily, (I don't mind a SMALL power imbalance, but it's a bit crazy with some of the spell list), but instead of banning up casting, lowering the level of what gets summoned would be better and,l if that sucks too much, there's other mechanics that can be tweaked than just power level to hit the right sweet spot
Tasha Summons are useful, but they're hardly outstripping martials. Conjure X can do so, especially on a Shepherd Druid, but that's a problem with those spells specifically (and remember that the DM controls exactly what you get from those anyway) rather than with the concept of summoning as a whole.
Yeah I didn't look at them specifically when I responded. I was more or less trying to point out that if it's a valid concern, then there's ways of fixing it. Martials do tend to get the short end.
Hey. Hey guys. I may have had an idea. Tell it to me straight if I'm chasing faeries with this line of thought...
BUT!
Imagine this: Warlock. No longer regain spell slots on Short Rest. Instead, we're going all-in on the new Magical Cunning trait. Warlocks, after all, don't use their own inner power (as sorcerers), nor do they study complex forms to manipulate extant forces (wizards). No, warlocks steal and borrow, right? So, they only use their little minute's worth of haphazard rite to call up their sugar parent and/or dark overlord and beg for some more cake off of the big table. No need to sit down nice and tidy for a right cuppa, all of that short rest.
In this model, we're embracing symmetry and a warlock of level 1 through 5 has 1 spell slot, 6 through 10 has 2, 11 through 16 has 3, and 17+ has 4. Just like with cantrip damage upgrades. We like symmetry.
However, Magical Cunning can be used your proficiency bonus times per day, now. (which, incidentally, allows the warlock's magic power to sorta-kinda multiclass scale a tiny bit, just like other spellcasters can piggyback off of another casting class). And since it is a minute to perform, it won't provide a character with extra slots to use within a single combat encounter, as they're still limited to their maximum number of slots they can hold at a time. Basically, this model replaces the short rest discussion with a fixed number, easily accessed, out-of-combat recovery system.
So, it'd look something like this:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Warlock Level Max Slots Magical Cunning Total Daily Slots
So. Am I due to give my brain a little vacation, or am I actually having a proper idea here? :)
personally, i feel like the 1 minute downtime required to accomplish Magical Cunning is plenty cost. it cannot be cast in combat and it can be interrupted. so then, a short rest with as little mother-may-i as possible (minus the healing, but also minus the clock stop). if it also broke concentration, can anyone name a good reason to limit number of uses of Magical Cunning at all? a reason that isn't also an argument for limiting number of short rests in a day, anyway.
This doesn't qualify for your second point, but I think the second point sort of ignores that the short rest mechanic exists as a pacing mechanic. If the Warlock can regain their most powerful spells on any 1-minute rest they'll virtually never be stressed for spell resources the way that other full casters can be. Taking a breather X number of times between encounters before a long rest is one thing, but virtually unlimited magical cunning just removes that pacing mechanic from the DM's toolbox.
Magical Cunning (UA7) only recharges half the [empty!] pact slots which for most of the warlock's career means one. if you don't want them to go into battle with one pact slot, then break their concentration. if we can't trust a dm to curb [potential] abuse with environmental hazards, narrative pressure, and/or enemy patrols (the same reasons we're told the warlock cannot have an hour to short rest right now anyway), then bake in a 40% 'sub-par outcome' rate for attempting to recharge again within 30yds of the first recharge ritual site: failure means you get the spell slot(s) back, but also take 1d4 patron-flavored blow-back damage and add 1 level of exhaustion (-1 to d20 tests & spell DCs, long rest removes 1 exhaustion (UA4)) or poisoned (disadvantage, doesn't stack & cured more easily).
additionally, why require zero pact slots to attempt the refresh? let the player decide when to recoup their pact slot.
16 5th level spell slots might be a little strong.
In a single go? Oh, I absolutely agree with that, Ain! Just like a current level 17 warlock would have after three short rests, right? Or 20 after four short rests. See where I'm going? :)
But in this model, you don't have 16 at any time. You're limited to your total slots. So, most of the time, you would go into a situation with two slots, maybe three, before level 17. The difference lies in when you can regain slots - can you do it by asking everyone to stop for lunch, or can you do it while the rogue checks for traps and the fighter tells the long-suffering cleric about this racing horse she saw down in the village earlier?
So, IS it 16 5th level spell slots? Yes, but no. Maybe. Potentially.
Or, the warlock would feel freed to use these slots on smaller things, like casting Expeditious Retreat to win a footrace back in town, or Enthrall to put a group of hobgoblins in a stupor while the rogue planted evidence in their camp, or any other situation where where a warlock would have spells with no upcast option that they really wanted to use but felt they shouldn't, before.
They're not 5th level slots. They're 1st to 5th level slots, yeah? :)
Hey. Hey guys. I may have had an idea. Tell it to me straight if I'm chasing faeries with this line of thought...
BUT!
Imagine this: Warlock. No longer regain spell slots on Short Rest. Instead, we're going all-in on the new Magical Cunning trait. Warlocks, after all, don't use their own inner power (as sorcerers), nor do they study complex forms to manipulate extant forces (wizards). No, warlocks steal and borrow, right? So, they only use their little minute's worth of haphazard rite to call up their sugar parent and/or dark overlord and beg for some more cake off of the big table. No need to sit down nice and tidy for a right cuppa, all of that short rest.
In this model, we're embracing symmetry and a warlock of level 1 through 5 has 1 spell slot, 6 through 10 has 2, 11 through 16 has 3, and 17+ has 4. Just like with cantrip damage upgrades. We like symmetry.
However, Magical Cunning can be used your proficiency bonus times per day, now. (which, incidentally, allows the warlock's magic power to sorta-kinda multiclass scale a tiny bit, just like other spellcasters can piggyback off of another casting class). And since it is a minute to perform, it won't provide a character with extra slots to use within a single combat encounter, as they're still limited to their maximum number of slots they can hold at a time. Basically, this model replaces the short rest discussion with a fixed number, easily accessed, out-of-combat recovery system.
So, it'd look something like this: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Warlock Level Max Slots Magical Cunning Total Daily Slots
Warlocks of level 1-5 have one(1) spell slot per encounter? How about no.
Otherwise sure.
Hey, it's not my fault if your patron doesn't trust you with any more arcane credit than that in one go, Gabe! They remember what you did last time you accidentally were given extra slots. They'll bring it up at your quarterly performance review, too.
16 5th level spell slots might be a little strong.
In a single go? Oh, I absolutely agree with that, Ain! Just like a current level 17 warlock would have after three short rests, right? Or 20 after four short rests. See where I'm going? :)
But in this model, you don't have 16 at any time. You're limited to your total slots. So, most of the time, you would go into a situation with two slots, maybe three, before level 17. The difference lies in when you can regain slots - can you do it by asking everyone to stop for lunch, or can you do it while the rogue checks for traps and the fighter tells the long-suffering cleric about this racing horse she saw down in the village earlier?
So, IS it 16 5th level spell slots? Yes, but no. Maybe. Potentially.
Or, the warlock would feel freed to use these slots on smaller things, like casting Expeditious Retreat to win a footrace back in town, or Enthrall to put a group of hobgoblins in a stupor while the rogue planted evidence in their camp, or any other situation where where a warlock would have spells with no upcast option that they really wanted to use but felt they shouldn't, before.
They're not 5th level slots. They're 1st to 5th level slots, yeah? :)
Well it would still mean that at level 9 you get to cast 6 level 5 spells in the span of 5 minutes.
That would also mean that Sorcerers multiclassing into Warlock would get to refill their Sorcery points ridiculously fast.
16 5th level spell slots might be a little strong.
but crucially not all in the same encounter.
16 5th spell slots throughout an adventuring day is a lot. The Warlock list isn’t as shenanigan friendly as the wizard list, but with this many easy access 5th level spells per day I’m sure many will find something exploitive to do. In most dungeons you could keep Armor of Agathys up in between battles and still start any combat with full slots. You could also keep a party of four under the invisibility spell for the majority of a dungeon.
I haven't voted because what I want isn't an option. Which is for the designers to get over 2 irrational fears that they seem to have. The first is giving the Warlock thier 3rd spell pact slot much earlier, like 5th or 6th level. The second is to erase all mentions of "when there are none remaining" on recharge mechanics and replace it with the words " this cannot allow the character to go above the maximum as shown on their class chart". In my experience, hoarding happens not because players feel they don't have enough, but because they are afraid to be caught with zero. It's an important distinction that needs to be understood, since the current recharge mechanics require players to go to that point they want to avoid at all costs, which means a lot of them might never use thier recharge mechanic at all.
Well it would still mean that at level 9 you get to cast 6 level 5 spells in the span of 5 minutes.
That would also mean that Sorcerers multiclassing into Warlock would get to refill their Sorcery points ridiculously fast.
Hmm. Yeah, that IS a pickle. Those sorcerers always throws a monkey into the gears...
Easiest solution? The one that sorcerers will hate? Have pact magic be "special" and not mix with other sources of magic power. Oil and water. Cats and dogs. Tomatoes and whipped cream. It would completely gut the Coffeelock meta. But, uhm, how do I put this diplomatically? I might not be very upset to see it go? :)
But yeah, you're right. Poke one piece of the jenga tower, and everything starts to wobble.
Game design is hard, you guys! Can't we have someone else do it? :)
16 5th level spell slots might be a little strong.
In a single go? Oh, I absolutely agree with that, Ain! Just like a current level 17 warlock would have after three short rests, right? Or 20 after four short rests. See where I'm going? :)
But in this model, you don't have 16 at any time. You're limited to your total slots. So, most of the time, you would go into a situation with two slots, maybe three, before level 17. The difference lies in when you can regain slots - can you do it by asking everyone to stop for lunch, or can you do it while the rogue checks for traps and the fighter tells the long-suffering cleric about this racing horse she saw down in the village earlier?
So, IS it 16 5th level spell slots? Yes, but no. Maybe. Potentially.
Or, the warlock would feel freed to use these slots on smaller things, like casting Expeditious Retreat to win a footrace back in town, or Enthrall to put a group of hobgoblins in a stupor while the rogue planted evidence in their camp, or any other situation where where a warlock would have spells with no upcast option that they really wanted to use but felt they shouldn't, before.
They're not 5th level slots. They're 1st to 5th level slots, yeah? :)
Well it would still mean that at level 9 you get to cast 6 level 5 spells in the span of 5 minutes.
That would also mean that Sorcerers multiclassing into Warlock would get to refill their Sorcery points ridiculously fast.
I'm not a fan of fast refills on slots.
This is why I elect for just more variety of spammables with invocations and more variety in upgrading pacts as you level up.
Because what is a warlock? It's not a spellcaster. At least not a naturally gifted spellcaster. It doesn't have in innate connection to God. It does not have magic coursing through it's veins. It's not paid through years of study.
It's a CONTRACT. With very specific terms and conditions. You do X or give up Y you get Z.
The more you do your patron's bidding , the more likely your patron will reward you.
As such, your powers are generally associated with their terms of your CONTRACT (pact) and that is flavored by the type of PATRON you have.
More and more spell slots being given is weird within the terms of a contract.
I want the warlock to have spells and variation, but the archetype would say you get some very specific and powerful abilities that were outlined in clause 7:2 paragraph E. and are strictly limited to ONLY the power in clause....
I haven't voted because what I want isn't an option. Which is for the designers to get over 2 irrational fears that they seem to have. The first is giving the Warlock thier 3rd spell pact slot much earlier, like 5th or 6th level. The second is to erase all mentions of "when there are none remaining" on recharge mechanics and replace it with the words " this cannot allow the character to go above the maximum as shown on their class chart". In my experience, hoarding happens not because players feel they don't have enough, but because they are afraid to be caught with zero. It's an important distinction that needs to be understood, since the current recharge mechanics require players to go to that point they want to avoid at all costs, which means a lot of them might never use thier recharge mechanic at all.
In fairness to them, part of why it feels like the 3rd slot comes so late is because we get the 2nd slot earlier than their formula would dictate. If they stuck to cantrip scaling we wouldn't get that 2nd slot until 5th. I think 5th is probably too early for the 3rd slot, 7th or 9th seems more reasonable. And then move the 4th slot down to 15th level.
I would definitely agree with removing the restriction on only using Magical Cunning when you're out of Pact Magic slots. It should be more like Arcane Recovery or Natural Recovery, you just can't use it to exceed your normal max. And can we please come up with a better name than Magical Cunning? Something with "Eldritch" in it seems appropriate, yes?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
This doesn't qualify for your second point, but I think the second point sort of ignores that the short rest mechanic exists as a pacing mechanic. If the Warlock can regain their most powerful spells on any 1-minute rest they'll virtually never be stressed for spell resources the way that other full casters can be. Taking a breather X number of times between encounters before a long rest is one thing, but virtually unlimited magical cunning just removes that pacing mechanic from the DM's toolbox.
Can't we just go with the Channel Divinity route? At this point it really is the best compromise between the people whom like the current Pactslots and those that feel it's too restricted/punishing. It also has the added benefits of making the Warlock experience more consistent while reducing the multiclass benefits.
The Channel Divinity route would be, "recover all uses on long rest, and 1 use on short rest?"
How many base slots do you feel the warlock would need to sustain a vaguely-defined adventuring day, with that model of spell-slot recovery?
I think it's a poorly built martial indeed who can't keep up with an upcast Summon. More importantly, the problem is that only Warlocks are restricted in this way - Wizards, Druids, Clerics, Bards with MS, and Sorcerers like Clockwork or Aberrant Mind all have no issue with upcasting those summons to 6th or 8th level. Even if you leave the restriction in place for Warlocks, it doesn't stop those summons from existing for pretty much all of the other full casters.
THANK you! THAT'S what I've been wanting from the START! That's along the lines of what I suggested since the start of the previous Warlock playtest, and NO ONE listened to me! Thank you!!!
(I'd tie it to class level rather than proficiency bonus myself, but the principle idea is the same)
Agile's got a point.
I love the ideas of a summoned monster, but it's still adding another body on the field and equivalent to getting and equal or higher level PC come in to help.
I think his concern is reasonable as spellcasters tend to outstrip martials too easily, (I don't mind a SMALL power imbalance, but it's a bit crazy with some of the spell list), but instead of banning up casting, lowering the level of what gets summoned would be better and,l if that sucks too much, there's other mechanics that can be tweaked than just power level to hit the right sweet spot
I only became forum-active recently, so I didn't see your (obviously brilliant) suggestion back then. Otherwise I'd have credited you for inspiration, Mezzie! But we can share in this clear and overflowing genius (while also being perplexingly humble)!
Now, praise us. Praise, please! *grabby-hands*
16 5th level spell slots might be a little strong.
Tasha Summons are useful, but they're hardly outstripping martials. Conjure X can do so, especially on a Shepherd Druid, but that's a problem with those spells specifically (and remember that the DM controls exactly what you get from those anyway) rather than with the concept of summoning as a whole.
Yeah I didn't look at them specifically when I responded. I was more or less trying to point out that if it's a valid concern, then there's ways of fixing it. Martials do tend to get the short end.
Magical Cunning (UA7) only recharges half the [empty!] pact slots which for most of the warlock's career means one. if you don't want them to go into battle with one pact slot, then break their concentration. if we can't trust a dm to curb [potential] abuse with environmental hazards, narrative pressure, and/or enemy patrols (the same reasons we're told the warlock cannot have an hour to short rest right now anyway), then bake in a 40% 'sub-par outcome' rate for attempting to recharge again within 30yds of the first recharge ritual site: failure means you get the spell slot(s) back, but also take 1d4 patron-flavored blow-back damage and add 1 level of exhaustion (-1 to d20 tests & spell DCs, long rest removes 1 exhaustion (UA4)) or poisoned (disadvantage, doesn't stack & cured more easily).
additionally, why require zero pact slots to attempt the refresh? let the player decide when to recoup their pact slot.
but crucially not all in the same encounter.
unhappy at the way in which we lost individual purchases for one-off subclasses, magic items, and monsters?
tell them you don't like features disappeared quietly in the night: provide feedback!
In a single go? Oh, I absolutely agree with that, Ain! Just like a current level 17 warlock would have after three short rests, right? Or 20 after four short rests. See where I'm going? :)
But in this model, you don't have 16 at any time. You're limited to your total slots. So, most of the time, you would go into a situation with two slots, maybe three, before level 17. The difference lies in when you can regain slots - can you do it by asking everyone to stop for lunch, or can you do it while the rogue checks for traps and the fighter tells the long-suffering cleric about this racing horse she saw down in the village earlier?
So, IS it 16 5th level spell slots? Yes, but no. Maybe. Potentially.
Or, the warlock would feel freed to use these slots on smaller things, like casting Expeditious Retreat to win a footrace back in town, or Enthrall to put a group of hobgoblins in a stupor while the rogue planted evidence in their camp, or any other situation where where a warlock would have spells with no upcast option that they really wanted to use but felt they shouldn't, before.
They're not 5th level slots. They're 1st to 5th level slots, yeah? :)
Warlocks of level 1-5 have one(1) spell slot per encounter? How about no.
Otherwise sure.
Hey, it's not my fault if your patron doesn't trust you with any more arcane credit than that in one go, Gabe! They remember what you did last time you accidentally were given extra slots. They'll bring it up at your quarterly performance review, too.
:)
Well it would still mean that at level 9 you get to cast 6 level 5 spells in the span of 5 minutes.
That would also mean that Sorcerers multiclassing into Warlock would get to refill their Sorcery points ridiculously fast.
16 5th spell slots throughout an adventuring day is a lot. The Warlock list isn’t as shenanigan friendly as the wizard list, but with this many easy access 5th level spells per day I’m sure many will find something exploitive to do. In most dungeons you could keep Armor of Agathys up in between battles and still start any combat with full slots. You could also keep a party of four under the invisibility spell for the majority of a dungeon.
I haven't voted because what I want isn't an option. Which is for the designers to get over 2 irrational fears that they seem to have. The first is giving the Warlock thier 3rd spell pact slot much earlier, like 5th or 6th level. The second is to erase all mentions of "when there are none remaining" on recharge mechanics and replace it with the words " this cannot allow the character to go above the maximum as shown on their class chart". In my experience, hoarding happens not because players feel they don't have enough, but because they are afraid to be caught with zero. It's an important distinction that needs to be understood, since the current recharge mechanics require players to go to that point they want to avoid at all costs, which means a lot of them might never use thier recharge mechanic at all.
Hmm. Yeah, that IS a pickle. Those sorcerers always throws a monkey into the gears...
Easiest solution? The one that sorcerers will hate? Have pact magic be "special" and not mix with other sources of magic power. Oil and water. Cats and dogs. Tomatoes and whipped cream. It would completely gut the Coffeelock meta. But, uhm, how do I put this diplomatically? I might not be very upset to see it go? :)
But yeah, you're right. Poke one piece of the jenga tower, and everything starts to wobble.
Game design is hard, you guys! Can't we have someone else do it? :)
I'm not a fan of fast refills on slots.
This is why I elect for just more variety of spammables with invocations and more variety in upgrading pacts as you level up.
Because what is a warlock? It's not a spellcaster. At least not a naturally gifted spellcaster. It doesn't have in innate connection to God. It does not have magic coursing through it's veins. It's not paid through years of study.
It's a CONTRACT. With very specific terms and conditions. You do X or give up Y you get Z.
The more you do your patron's bidding , the more likely your patron will reward you.
As such, your powers are generally associated with their terms of your CONTRACT (pact) and that is flavored by the type of PATRON you have.
More and more spell slots being given is weird within the terms of a contract.
I want the warlock to have spells and variation, but the archetype would say you get some very specific and powerful abilities that were outlined in clause 7:2 paragraph E. and are strictly limited to ONLY the power in clause....
In fairness to them, part of why it feels like the 3rd slot comes so late is because we get the 2nd slot earlier than their formula would dictate. If they stuck to cantrip scaling we wouldn't get that 2nd slot until 5th. I think 5th is probably too early for the 3rd slot, 7th or 9th seems more reasonable. And then move the 4th slot down to 15th level.
I would definitely agree with removing the restriction on only using Magical Cunning when you're out of Pact Magic slots. It should be more like Arcane Recovery or Natural Recovery, you just can't use it to exceed your normal max. And can we please come up with a better name than Magical Cunning? Something with "Eldritch" in it seems appropriate, yes?