Hallow's Eve At Gibburg Manor: Mafia Game Thread

VOTE: Platyboss

My reasoning? As admitted above, Platy made accusations against me and Vitus without any real proof. The reasoning he provided full of holes, as well as hypocritical as he accused me of making a lot of accusations, while he has made more than I have. I believe he attempted to sway others against me and Vitus not because he found us suspicious, but being we found him suspicious, which he saw as a threat. Killing us would have been too suspicious, so he instead opted to voting us out, which he failed at

Kinda forgot I joined this. Am I dead yet?

*Sad trumpet sounds*

So I am sus due to me making theories/voting with little to no evidence, which is exactly what you wanted us to do at the beginning of Mafia.

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

VOTE: Platyboss

My reasoning? As admitted above, Platy made accusations against me and Vitus without any real proof. The reasoning he provided full of holes, as well as hypocritical as he accused me of making a lot of accusations, while he has made more than I have. I believe he attempted to sway others against me and Vitus not because he found us suspicious, but being we found him suspicious, which he saw as a threat. Killing us would have been too suspicious, so he instead opted to voting us out, which he failed at

 Isn’t that what he said about you and u just rreplied with “it’s the game”?

 No. The point I’m making is not that Platy has been making too many accusations, I’m saying that he’s making claims he knows have nothing to stand on, as well as being a hypocrite by accusing me of making to many accusations when he’s made even more than me. Not sure you understand my argument fully 

A large spider moves at unbelievable speed through the manor. Nobody can tell where it came from or where it went. 

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

VOTE: Platyboss

My reasoning? As admitted above, Platy made accusations against me and Vitus without any real proof. The reasoning he provided full of holes, as well as hypocritical as he accused me of making a lot of accusations, while he has made more than I have. I believe he attempted to sway others against me and Vitus not because he found us suspicious, but being we found him suspicious, which he saw as a threat. Killing us would have been too suspicious, so he instead opted to voting us out, which he failed at

 Isn’t that what he said about you and u just rreplied with “it’s the game”?

 No. The point I’m making is not that Platy has been making too many accusations, I’m saying that he’s making claims he knows have nothing to stand on, as well as being a hypocrite by accusing me of making to many accusations when he’s made even more than me. Not sure you understand my argument fully 

 Um you're kind of being redundant here.

Also the difference between what I said and he said is that I owned up to the mistakes I made. He did not.

(Also, legitimate question, how is being a hypocrite sus?)

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

VOTE: Platyboss

My reasoning? As admitted above, Platy made accusations against me and Vitus without any real proof. The reasoning he provided full of holes, as well as hypocritical as he accused me of making a lot of accusations, while he has made more than I have. I believe he attempted to sway others against me and Vitus not because he found us suspicious, but being we found him suspicious, which he saw as a threat. Killing us would have been too suspicious, so he instead opted to voting us out, which he failed at

 Isn’t that what he said about you and u just rreplied with “it’s the game”?

 No. The point I’m making is not that Platy has been making too many accusations, I’m saying that he’s making claims he knows have nothing to stand on, as well as being a hypocrite by accusing me of making to many accusations when he’s made even more than me. Not sure you understand my argument fully 

 I understand that he called u up for making a lot of accusations and u stated that it’s the entire point of the game now you’re pulling him up for doing the exact same…

 No, I’m not. I’m accusing him for making accusations with no basis. At this point you’re just ignoring something I’ve repeated. If you’re confused, I’m also calling him out for his hypocrisy. He first accused me of making a lot of accusations when he’s made more than I have. I am not accusing him for the amount. I’m accusing him of making a hypocritical claim 

Quote from Platyboss >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

VOTE: Platyboss

My reasoning? As admitted above, Platy made accusations against me and Vitus without any real proof. The reasoning he provided full of holes, as well as hypocritical as he accused me of making a lot of accusations, while he has made more than I have. I believe he attempted to sway others against me and Vitus not because he found us suspicious, but being we found him suspicious, which he saw as a threat. Killing us would have been too suspicious, so he instead opted to voting us out, which he failed at

 Isn’t that what he said about you and u just rreplied with “it’s the game”?

 No. The point I’m making is not that Platy has been making too many accusations, I’m saying that he’s making claims he knows have nothing to stand on, as well as being a hypocrite by accusing me of making to many accusations when he’s made even more than me. Not sure you understand my argument fully 

 Um you're kind of being redundant here.

Also the difference between what I said and he said is that I owned up to the mistakes I made. He did not.

(Also, legitimate question, how is being a hypocrite sus?)

 That second one is calling you out for your hypocrisy, not calling you out for the amount you made. And I have made no mistakes that I am yet to own up for. Being a hypocrite is suspicious because you were attempting to call me sus for something that you also participated in, even more than I have. That would make you even more sus by your own logic. Plus, just making claims with a bad argument makes it seem like you’re making the claims for the sake of it, or of some ulterior motive.

In my opinion, I think you should vote out Himy if (when) I get voted out. That is, if I am a Normal Townsfolk.

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from Nothic3SeeHere >>

Kinda forgot I joined this. Am I dead yet?

 No :D

Hooray!

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from The_DragonTamer >>

A large spider moves at unbelievable speed through the manor. Nobody can tell where it came from or where it went. 

 I squash it under my foot

It blocks your foot, looks up at you in disgust, similar to the way that a shark might look at a tuna,  then disappears, leaving nothing but a web saying "updog".

Quote from The_DragonTamer >>

Quote from BlackBear_ >>

Quote from The_DragonTamer >>

A large spider moves at unbelievable speed through the manor. Nobody can tell where it came from or where it went. 

 I squash it under my foot

It blocks your foot, looks up at you in disgust, similar to the way that a shark might look at a tuna,  then disappears, leaving nothing but a web saying "updog".

 I chase after it and eat it 😋

VOTES

Platyboss: VitusW, 49t, himynamesare

Himynamesare: BlackBear_, Platyboss

After an intense debate, with multiple individuals on different sides, the town just barely decides Platyboss has been too suspicious to be allowed to continue to live. So, they put him at the altar and begin to chant. Once more, the candles go out as a fleshy tendril drags him into an unfathomable realm. When they magically reignite, he's gone. And he left behind...

Nothing.

Platyboss was ALSO a Regular Townsfolk.

Night begins, and will end at 9 PM EST on November 5th. PM me night actions if you have any. That's all. Bye! *Vanishes*

*You hear a whisper echo through the hall*

"That's two in a row... better find the mafia quick..."

Also, sorry to bother you this late on your birthday Gibber, but could you add me to the graveyard PM?

Quote from Platyboss >>

Also, sorry to bother you this late on your birthday Gibber, but could you add me to the graveyard PM?

 Oh, yeah, my bad! Don't worry, it's fine.

A quiet whisper can be heard in the distance.. 

Too many have died, always the innocent they choose,    The Town shall lose. 

And not so quietly in the distance.. 

Seriously though guys this is painful to watch, get it together! I may not be able to rhyme but I sure can distantly yell! 

*To add to you guy's dread further, the town is 3-4 mafia-townies. So one kill evens it out, which means mafia win. Unless something happens with the special roles remaining, things aren't looking too good for y'all. I really should have said this before, but oh well. Bye! (Vanishes)*

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

*To add to you guy's dread further, the town is 3-4 mafia-townies. So one kill evens it out, which means mafia win. Unless something happens with the special roles remaining, things aren't looking too good for y'all. I really should have said this before, but oh well. Bye! (Vanishes)*

 I thought we started with 12? We lost 4 people (Pj, Dragon, Flower and now Platy) which brings us down to 8. If there are 3 mafia, even after one kill, that would leave us with 7, which is still more than the amount of mafia 

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

*To add to you guy's dread further, the town is 3-4 mafia-townies. So one kill evens it out, which means mafia win. Unless something happens with the special roles remaining, things aren't looking too good for y'all. I really should have said this before, but oh well. Bye! (Vanishes)*

 I thought we started with 12? We lost 4 people (Pj, Dragon, Flower and now Platy) which brings us down to 8. If there are 3 mafia, even after one kill, that would leave us with 7, which is still more than the amount of mafia 

 Wait, that actually is correct. My bad, I saw I crossed out Rogue's name and thought that meant they were dead. Sorry, the NEXT day/night is when one wrong kill means mafia win.