No, I'm taking about all the content from those sources you mentioned and others produced by WoC. I'd like it all to be in one place, and all official.
Why? I'm in two different groups, and each DM picks and chooses what they will allow from the various sources. If all the content is in one official book, they are likely to accept it as is.
No, I'm taking about all the content from those sources you mentioned and others produced by WoC. I'd like it all to be in one place, and all official.
Why? I'm in two different groups, and each DM picks and chooses what they will allow from the various sources. If all the content is in one official book, they are likely to accept it as is.
If they are in a book published by WotC (Such as XGTE, SCAG, VGTM) then they are already official. There is no need to include them in a PHB2, as these are supplements to the PHB as is. Whether or not your DM chooses to allow them doesn't make them any less official.
The problem with what you ask is that it would ruin adventurers league format. In adventurers league you get to have phb and plus 1 book and thats all. Which makes players have to choose carefully what they want source wise. If they create the phb2 as you mention... This whole thing they been doing for years wont work anymore. Imagine 3e if they did a phb with everything in it. It would of been a 3000 pages book. Not to mention how whack adventurers league would of been if players had access to everything at once.
So yeah it wont happen. On the bright side this is exactly what ddb is trying to do. Have everything in the same place.
DM of two gaming groups. Likes to create stuff. Check out my homebrew --> Monsters --> Magical Items --> Races --> Subclasses If you like --> Upvote, If you wanna comment --> Comment
Play by Post Games --> One Shot Adventure - House of Artwood (DM) (Completed)
No, I'm taking about all the content from those sources you mentioned and others produced by WoC. I'd like it all to be in one place, and all official.
Why? I'm in two different groups, and each DM picks and chooses what they will allow from the various sources. If all the content is in one official book, they are likely to accept it as is.
If they are in a book published by WotC (Such as XGTE, SCAG, VGTM) then they are already official. There is no need to include them in a PHB2, as these are supplements to the PHB as is. Whether or not your DM chooses to allow them doesn't make them any less official.
I understand what you're saying, however both DM's treat the PHB as the Word of God, and will follow rules in it even if they don't like those rules...but they don't view the other books that way.
In any case, one book with all of the content would be convenient, if nothing else.
In any case, one book with all of the content would be convenient, if nothing else.
If only there was a website that would gather all the official books in one place and let you access it conveniently......
Also, I suspect a couple of people might complain about paying twice for material they already own if the PHB were reprinted with new material.....and in this case I would be inclined to agree with them.
In any case, one book with all of the content would be convenient, if nothing else.
If only there was a website that would gather all the official books in one place and let you access it conveniently......
Also, I suspect a couple of people might complain about paying twice for material they already own if the PHB were reprinted with new material.....and in this case I would be inclined to agree with them.
I've already purchased all of the books. Do we really need to get into that argument about paying for content twice...whether physical or digital?
No, I'm taking about all the content from those sources you mentioned and others produced by WoC. I'd like it all to be in one place, and all official.
Why? I'm in two different groups, and each DM picks and chooses what they will allow from the various sources. If all the content is in one official book, they are likely to accept it as is.
If they are in a book published by WotC (Such as XGTE, SCAG, VGTM) then they are already official. There is no need to include them in a PHB2, as these are supplements to the PHB as is. Whether or not your DM chooses to allow them doesn't make them any less official.
I understand what you're saying, however both DM's treat the PHB as the Word of God, and will follow rules in it even if they don't like those rules...but they don't view the other books that way.
In any case, one book with all of the content would be convenient, if nothing else.
I think what DNDpaladin said @ me was meant to be directed @ you and kind of explains the reason why it isn't all in one book, as I'm in agreement with him on this:
The problem with what you ask is that it would ruin adventurers league format. In adventurers league you get to have phb and plus 1 book and thats all. Which makes players have to choose carefully what they want source wise. If they create the phb2 as you mention... This whole thing they been doing for years wont work anymore. Imagine 3e if they did a phb with everything in it. It would of been a 3000 pages book. Not to mention how whack adventurers league would of been if players had access to everything at once.
So yeah it wont happen. On the bright side this is exactly what ddb is trying to do. Have everything in the same place.
I want druids to officially have animal companions in one way or another.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"I want to pull out it's tongue so Timbity can use it as a whip."- W
Scarlet is a red haired wood elf. She is wearing a semi-formal red dress and her green cloak with silver lining. She has a beat up old scimitar at her side. She has dark green eyes and a feather in her hair. Her skin is well tanned.
Not that I'm trying to talk you out of wanting another method of animal companionship, but there are already some that are available that won't take the form of not getting other sub-class features because the animal is your sub-class feature.
"I want to pull out it's tongue so Timbity can use it as a whip."- W
Scarlet is a red haired wood elf. She is wearing a semi-formal red dress and her green cloak with silver lining. She has a beat up old scimitar at her side. She has dark green eyes and a feather in her hair. Her skin is well tanned.
I'd love to see an official new campaign built around Greek/Roman mythology. It would have plenty of adventure, treasure, interaction, and lore for everyone and all classes. It may even be a chance for WoTC to release new content such as making a satyr as a new race!
No, I'm taking about all the content from those sources you mentioned and others produced by WoC. I'd like it all to be in one place, and all official.
Why? I'm in two different groups, and each DM picks and chooses what they will allow from the various sources. If all the content is in one official book, they are likely to accept it as is.
How do you get a one-armed goblin out of a tree?
Wave!
@mehetmet
The problem with what you ask is that it would ruin adventurers league format. In adventurers league you get to have phb and plus 1 book and thats all. Which makes players have to choose carefully what they want source wise. If they create the phb2 as you mention... This whole thing they been doing for years wont work anymore. Imagine 3e if they did a phb with everything in it. It would of been a 3000 pages book. Not to mention how whack adventurers league would of been if players had access to everything at once.
So yeah it wont happen. On the bright side this is exactly what ddb is trying to do. Have everything in the same place.
DM of two gaming groups.
Likes to create stuff.
Check out my homebrew --> Monsters --> Magical Items --> Races --> Subclasses
If you like --> Upvote, If you wanna comment --> Comment
Play by Post Games
--> One Shot Adventure - House of Artwood (DM) (Completed)
Please remember that use of these forums is a privilege and not a right.
This is a privilege that can be lost by failing to follow the rules & guidelines, especially arguing and flaming other users.
Please calm this down. You may disagree on your opinions without insulting each other.
Pun-loving nerd | She/Her/Hers | Profile art by Becca Golins
If you need help with homebrew, please post on the homebrew forums, where multiple staff and moderators can read your post and help you!
"We got this, no problem! I'll take the twenty on the left - you guys handle the one on the right!"🔊
Roleplaying since Runequest.
They should totally add more weapons, tons of ranged that they don't have!
How do you get a one-armed goblin out of a tree?
Wave!
Always looking forward to more magical items and monsters to go toe to toe with! Hopefully some epic level content as well.
Dungeon Master - Content Creator - Software Engineer - Fitness Enthusiast
Maybe a way for wizards to manipulate their spells in unique ways.
Example: casting gust of wind through a hallway but it doesn't come from you
I want druids to officially have animal companions in one way or another.
"I want to pull out it's tongue so Timbity can use it as a whip."- W
Scarlet is a red haired wood elf. She is wearing a semi-formal red dress and her green cloak with silver lining. She has a beat up old scimitar at her side. She has dark green eyes and a feather in her hair. Her skin is well tanned.
Yes I don't want to force it.
"I want to pull out it's tongue so Timbity can use it as a whip."- W
Scarlet is a red haired wood elf. She is wearing a semi-formal red dress and her green cloak with silver lining. She has a beat up old scimitar at her side. She has dark green eyes and a feather in her hair. Her skin is well tanned.
Dragonlance setting and campaign content. Just re-read the Chronicles and Legends books. Such a wonderful setting.
I'd love to see an official new campaign built around Greek/Roman mythology. It would have plenty of adventure, treasure, interaction, and lore for everyone and all classes. It may even be a chance for WoTC to release new content such as making a satyr as a new race!
Revive the Modern line.
Yes, please.
I would like to see the Ravenloft campaign setting fleshed out fully for 5e. Conversion from 3.5 has proven to be a daunting and time consuming task.
Its about time to rename this thread to "See In 2019" wouldn't y'all say?