So it's an either OR I didn't consider that one. Thank you Pantagruel and wagnarokkr! That helps me a great deal, and makes alot of sense.
Yeah, in case it's not obvious, being able to do it as either an action or as a bonus action means that you're never prevented from doing it and some other thing in the same turn. For instance, if you could only do it as a bonus action, you couldn't do that and cast Hunter's Mark on the same turn; if you could only do it as an Attack action, you couldn't do that and cast Entangle on the same turn.
My question is about the 2024 Beast Master Ranger Subclass. The stat blocks for the different beast types only show one type of attack. The Beast Strike, which requires the Ranger character to give up one of their attacks. Was there supposed to be a basic attack in the stat block for a bonus action attack, or is the creature not useful in combat until at least level 5? Or is this more what kind of creature your Beast is based off of. Like a beast of the land that looks like a wolf, would use the wolf's attacks?
If it's useful for you, there's thread about the Beast Master subclass and the Primal Companion feature in the Rules & Game Mechanics subforum: Ranger, Beast Master's Primal Companion Actions
The actions with companions is such a mess. Clearly the rules they've written arent sufficient and havent been for a long time, and yet WotC do nothing to clarify.
Whats the point of having the sage advice section if they dont actually offer a way to submit questions, and dont clarify the problems that have been discussed for YEARS at this point.
I'd like to request clarification on the 2024 version of Hunger of Hadar.
There seems to be an inconsistency between the spell's original design intent and its 2024 mechanics.
1. Jeremy Crawford (March 2, 2016) explained that Devil's Sight was intended to penetrate magical darkness, but not the otherworldly void created by Hunger of Hadar.
2. The 2024 Sage Advice Compendium clarifies that magical Darkness blocks Darkvision only when the specific effect explicitly says so.
3. The 2024 Hunger of Hadar creates a sphere of Darkness that cannot be illuminated and gives creatures fully within it the Blinded condition. However, it does not explicitly prevent Darkvision from penetrating the sphere.
This produces a strange RAW interaction:
A creature with Darkvision standing outside Hunger of Hadar appears able to see creatures inside it. But when that same creature moves fully into the sphere, it immediately becomes Blinded.
Likewise, Devil's Sight and Truesight appear unable to overcome the Blinded condition inside the sphere, even though they can see through magical Darkness.
Questions for the rules designers:
1. Is Darkvision intentionally able to see into and through the 2024 Hunger of Hadar from outside?
2. Was the 2024 revision intended to change Jeremy Crawford's earlier explanation that the spell creates an otherworldly void impervious to Devil's Sight?
3. Is the distinction between being fully inside and outside the sphere intentional?
4. Should the sphere be treated as opaque supernatural blackness, or as ordinary magical Darkness with an additional Blinded effect?
I think an official Sage Advice clarification would be valuable, especially for Warlocks using Devil's Sight.
Yes, I've read through a few threads, and I understand it now. Still, why would creatures become blind narratively despite having darkvision? Because of strange whispers and slurping noises? And why doesn't Devil's Sight help to see in this Darkness even though it allows to "see normally in Darkness—both magical and nonmagical"?
Without a narrative explanation, the mechanics stop feeling intuitive. That's what makes this spell confusing at the table. When a player spends 5–10 seconds double-checking a spell's description, the narrative explanation helps them understand how it works mechanically without losing momentum in combat.
Nobody wants to get into long discussions about why a spell works the way it does in the middle of a game.
Still, why would creatures become blind narratively despite having darkvision?
Because it's 'opening a gateway to the Far Realm', narratively you can describe it as people's brains being unable to process what they're seeing within the AoE
Mechanically it's Blinded, but narratively it's being in an area of pure chaos where nothing makes sense visually
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Active characters:
Edoumiaond Willegume "Eddie" Podslee, Vegetanian scholar (College of Spirits bard) Lan Kidogo, mapach archaeologist and treasure hunter (Knowledge cleric) Peter "the Pied Piper" Hausler, human con artist/remover of vermin (Circle of the Shepherd druid) PIPA - Planar Interception/Protection Aeormaton, warforged bodyguard and ex-wizard hunter (Warrior of the Elements monk/Cartographer artificer) Xhekhetiel, halfling survivor of a Betrayer Gods cult (Runechild sorcerer/fighter)
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
So it's an either OR I didn't consider that one. Thank you Pantagruel and wagnarokkr! That helps me a great deal, and makes alot of sense.
Yeah, in case it's not obvious, being able to do it as either an action or as a bonus action means that you're never prevented from doing it and some other thing in the same turn. For instance, if you could only do it as a bonus action, you couldn't do that and cast Hunter's Mark on the same turn; if you could only do it as an Attack action, you couldn't do that and cast Entangle on the same turn.
pronouns: he/she/they
If it's useful for you, there's thread about the Beast Master subclass and the Primal Companion feature in the Rules & Game Mechanics subforum: Ranger, Beast Master's Primal Companion Actions
I'll check it out, once again, thanks, guys. I appreciate the assist!
The actions with companions is such a mess. Clearly the rules they've written arent sufficient and havent been for a long time, and yet WotC do nothing to clarify.
Whats the point of having the sage advice section if they dont actually offer a way to submit questions, and dont clarify the problems that have been discussed for YEARS at this point.
I'd like to request clarification on the 2024 version of Hunger of Hadar.
There seems to be an inconsistency between the spell's original design intent and its 2024 mechanics.
1. Jeremy Crawford (March 2, 2016) explained that Devil's Sight was intended to penetrate magical darkness, but not the otherworldly void created by Hunger of Hadar.
2. The 2024 Sage Advice Compendium clarifies that magical Darkness blocks Darkvision only when the specific effect explicitly says so.
3. The 2024 Hunger of Hadar creates a sphere of Darkness that cannot be illuminated and gives creatures fully within it the Blinded condition. However, it does not explicitly prevent Darkvision from penetrating the sphere.
This produces a strange RAW interaction:
A creature with Darkvision standing outside Hunger of Hadar appears able to see creatures inside it. But when that same creature moves fully into the sphere, it immediately becomes Blinded.
Likewise, Devil's Sight and Truesight appear unable to overcome the Blinded condition inside the sphere, even though they can see through magical Darkness.
Questions for the rules designers:
1. Is Darkvision intentionally able to see into and through the 2024 Hunger of Hadar from outside?
2. Was the 2024 revision intended to change Jeremy Crawford's earlier explanation that the spell creates an otherworldly void impervious to Devil's Sight?
3. Is the distinction between being fully inside and outside the sphere intentional?
4. Should the sphere be treated as opaque supernatural blackness, or as ordinary magical Darkness with an additional Blinded effect?
I think an official Sage Advice clarification would be valuable, especially for Warlocks using Devil's Sight.
Thank you!
Bring back Sage Advice, & make it once a month at least, please.
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
Seconded! It *might* (highly doubt it but we can dream) put an end to the monthly cycle of questions you see online 😂
That clarification is also found in the 5e SAC: Does all magical darkness block darkvision?
IMO, based on the SAC, Darkvision is not blocked if you're outside the Hunger of Hadar spell, so you could for example target enemies inside using Devil’s Sight, Darkvision, or Truesight without penalty.
But if you are fully within it, you have the Blinded condition regardless Devil’s Sight, Darkvision, or Truesight or something similar.
There's a thread about this spell in the Rules & Game Mechanics subforum, Hunger of Hadar darkness rules, if it might be useful for you.
Yes, I've read through a few threads, and I understand it now. Still, why would creatures become blind narratively despite having darkvision? Because of strange whispers and slurping noises? And why doesn't Devil's Sight help to see in this Darkness even though it allows to "see normally in Darkness—both magical and nonmagical"?
Without a narrative explanation, the mechanics stop feeling intuitive. That's what makes this spell confusing at the table. When a player spends 5–10 seconds double-checking a spell's description, the narrative explanation helps them understand how it works mechanically without losing momentum in combat.
Nobody wants to get into long discussions about why a spell works the way it does in the middle of a game.
While I agree with you, specially with your last paragraph, you can always fall back on the classic "spells do what they say they do".
Because it's 'opening a gateway to the Far Realm', narratively you can describe it as people's brains being unable to process what they're seeing within the AoE
Mechanically it's Blinded, but narratively it's being in an area of pure chaos where nothing makes sense visually
Active characters:
Edoumiaond Willegume "Eddie" Podslee, Vegetanian scholar (College of Spirits bard)
Lan Kidogo, mapach archaeologist and treasure hunter (Knowledge cleric)
Peter "the Pied Piper" Hausler, human con artist/remover of vermin (Circle of the Shepherd druid)
PIPA - Planar Interception/Protection Aeormaton, warforged bodyguard and ex-wizard hunter (Warrior of the Elements monk/Cartographer artificer)
Xhekhetiel, halfling survivor of a Betrayer Gods cult (Runechild sorcerer/fighter)