I can't take responsibility for everyone's understanding and ability to apply logically and rationally to all situations. I have explained it sufficiently. If you don't understand there is plenty of explanations and re-explanations over the course of 28 pages I suggest you re-read if your goal is to understand. I also suggest you answer your own questions as to the comparisons you've made. Compare and contrast your examples against DDB's policy of buying an individual feat for $1.99 in the PHB and then later buying the PHB at a discount of $1.99. DDB doing that instills in me a sense of confidence in my purchases. Doesn't it do the same for you? Unfortunately there is a bigger umbrella covering the entire edition that negates that confidence for me.
But the Feat/Book relationship isn't the same as the Book/Platform relationship.
Individual Feat Purchase = DDB Discounted Book Purchase = DDB
Digital Book Purchase = DDB Physical Book Purchase = A number of different 3rd parties
By this logic, if I am understanding correctly, If I were to buy just one feat for $1.99 on DDB, I should then also be entitled (not meant pejoratively btw) to a $1.99 discount on a physical book purchase?
Why does a random 3rd party owe me $1.99 for choosing to purchase content from another seller?
We can point the finger back to WotC, but WotC isn't a seller.
I know it seems like pro-DDB people gang up on anti-DDB (or at least anti-DDB business model) people, but it's just that the fact that DDB is a separate product from a physical book is absolutely clear common sense to us, and we can't understand how others can just keep refusing to acknowledge this. If some of us get an angry tone, it's out of frustration of trying to explain something so simple to a brick wall.
They are different products. They just are. DDB is fair. WotC is fair. If you disagree, you are free to feel that way, but feelings aren't facts. I'm sorry if this seems rude, but it's frustrating. I really do mean all due respect, but the market has spoken on this issue. DDB has been out for some time now and business is booming. I don't know what else to tell you.
But the Feat/Book relationship isn't the same as the Book/Platform relationship.
Individual Feat Purchase = DDB Discounted Book Purchase = DDB
Digital Book Purchase = DDB Physical Book Purchase = A number of different 3rd parties
By this logic, if I am understanding correctly, If I were to buy just one feat for $1.99 on DDB, I should then also be entitled (not meant pejoratively btw) to a $1.99 discount on a physical book purchase?
Why does a random 3rd party owe me $1.99 for choosing to purchase content from another seller?
We can point the finger back to WotC, but WotC isn't a seller.
I know it seems like pro-DDB people gang up on anti-DDB (or at least anti-DDB business model) people, but it's just that the fact that DDB is a separate product from a physical book is absolutely clear common sense to us, and we can't understand how others can just keep refusing to acknowledge this. If some of us get an angry tone, it's out of frustration of trying to explain something so simple to a brick wall.
They are different products. They just are. DDB is fair. WotC is fair. If you disagree, you are free to feel that way, but feelings aren't facts. I'm sorry if this seems rude, but it's frustrating. I really do mean all due respect on this issue, but the market has spoken on this issue. DDB has been out for some time now and business is booming. I don't know what else to tell you.
Different vendors all under the same WotC 5e d&d umbrella. Again, It's not a lack of understanding on my part. Your explanation goes back to that assumption that if you could just teach me, the brick wall, then I would be fixed.
If them being different products is a fact then I guess I'm playing a different game when I have the physical book open at the table vs when I have the compendium content open on my phone.
I'd posit this discussion has reached an impasse and will only spiral round in circles. Perhaps it best to end it here before this becomes a nonsensical farce of repetition and a derailment of the thread into pointless arguing. Both sides have said their piece and neither side will move from their stance, the only conclusion is an end.
"The umbrella of WotC" only matters if they are the vendors.
Lots of companies push their products out to different vendors, who then operate completely independently of each other. That's a hugely common and accepted economic model.
Like in my T-shirt example. You can get the same Spider-Man prints at Target that you do at Wal-Mart, however you'll find they are of different quality. That's because even though it's the same design used for the same purpose, they are printed on different fabrics. Both are cool shirts with the exact same image, but they are different products and will feel different to the wearer. Both under the "umbrella" of Marvel, but Marvel isn't expected to make up the difference to a person who wants both shirts. Neither is the other vendor. If you want two different shirts, even if they have the same image, you pay for two different shirts.
Similarly, the player wouldn't know the difference between a game run by a DM with a physical book vs one run by a DM with DDB. But the DM definitely knows the difference. They are different products. Same game. Different "units" with different feels to them.
Sorry to keep this going, but yes, I do feel like if I explain it plainly enough, eventually you'll get it. Or you're trolling. Or you're just dense. I doubt it's the 3rd one, but just saying.
"The umbrella of WotC" only matters if they are the vendors.
Lots of companies push their products out to different vendors, who then operate completely independently of each other. That's a hugely common and accepted economic model.
Like in my T-shirt example. You can get the same Spider-Man prints at Target that you do at Wal-Mart, however you'll find they are of different quality. That's because even though it's the same design used for the same purpose, they are printed on different fabrics. Both are cool shirts with the exact same image, but they are different products and will feel different to the wearer. Both under the "umbrella" of Marvel, but Marvel isn't expected to make up the difference to a person who wants both shirts. Neither is the other vendor. If you want two different shirts, even if they have the same image, you pay for two different shirts.
Similarly, the player wouldn't know the difference between a game run by a DM with a physical book vs one run by a DM with DDB. But the DM definitely knows the difference. They are different products. Same game. Different "units" with different feels to them.
Sorry to keep this going, but yes, I do feel like if I explain it plainly enough, eventually you'll get it. Or you're trolling. Or you're just dense. I doubt it's the 3rd one, but just saying.
If I have to explain to you the difference between your t-shirt example and 5e then, imo, you are completely incapable of being rational and I don't think there's anything I can do to end this in a good way for you. Also you're being pretty rude. Sorry I refuse to go on with you when you're like this.
This is a quick reminder to please keep this discussion civil.
If another user of these forums disagrees with your views, it doesn't make them stupid/dense or any other derogatory term - you just have an intrinsically different view.
If you should find yourself in a position where you feel you have explained your thoughts on this topic and further discussion is frustrating you - please move on, leave the conversation and contribute elsewhere on the forums.
I tried to search this thread for any mention of the word "Errata ". I have a simple question: does D&D Beyond keep all material up-to-date with errata? If so, that alone is a good reason to consider the digital versions. My only fear was the (hopefully) far-future possibility of it all getting shut down, and thus my access to books is gone, but I'm willing to take the risk because this service is so damn good.
I tried to search this thread for any mention of the word "Errata ". I have a simple question: does D&D Beyond keep all material up-to-date with errata? If so, that alone is a good reason to consider the digital versions. My only fear was the (hopefully) far-future possibility of it all getting shut down, and thus my access to books is gone, but I'm willing to take the risk because this service is so damn good.
Yes, all DDB content is updated by WotC errata. This is the first verification of that I could find from a search (BadEye is Adam Bradford, DDB bigwig):
I think that's just awesome (and I'd be surprised if it weren't the case, frankly). I know, practically speaking, it shouldn't be a huge deal to print out some errata, but I have re-purchased books just so I could have the most up-to-date rules (I miss those days I had some money to burn!). The D&D rules are sort of a living document in this way and D&DBeyond has an advantage in terms of easy quick reference that never has to be checked against errata. Of course, I know mistakes can still be made in conversion, as it's still humans providing the service, but...that's the case in all things.
You're right. On the bright side, if you find mistakes, they have a subforum (Feedback or Bugs & Support) where you can point them out and from what I have seen response is pretty positive and quick, though perhaps not always the fix itself.
People forget how many haters there were for “invalidated” dead tree products due to errata! lol. I was never that harsh, but those people should LOVE this as much as I do.!
Kreakdude, when you buy a PHB, and later WotC comes out with a special edition cover, do you complain you can't get a free/discounted copy of the special edition for already owning a regular copy? This is the same scenario... same content, different containers. If you want another copy of the material, because the container is different, more pleasing, or more convenient to you, then you should have to pay for the product in full a second time. Although, in this instance, you're already getting a discount on the full price and you've had multiple opportunities to get a discount code on top of that. If it's just about the up front cost, you can buy it piecemeal. If you can't justify even that much discount, then sell the physical copy. They've given you multiple inches, but you won't be satisfied until you get the full mile. This sounds like your problem, not Curse's or WotC's.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
How I'm posting based on text formatting: Mod Hat On - Mod Hat Off
Kreakdude, when you buy a PHB, and later WotC comes out with a special edition cover, do you complain you can't get a free/discounted copy of the special edition for already owning a regular copy? This is the same scenario... same content, different containers. If you want another copy of the material, because the container is different, more pleasing, or more convenient to you, then you should have to pay for the product in full a second time. Although, in this instance, you're already getting a discount on the full price and you've had multiple opportunities to get a discount code on top of that. If it's just about the up front cost, you can buy it piecemeal. If you can't justify even that much discount, then sell the physical copy. They've given you multiple inches, but you won't be satisfied until you get the full mile. This sounds like your problem, not Curse's or WotC's.
I made the exact same question/point in the previous page of this thread, alas I have been utterly ignored by Kreakdude (as many other times I tried to point out fallacies in someone's logic)... Hope you will have better luck than me.
In any case, the problem itself is more the size and shape of a simple "wall-against-wall" situation, and I am afraid we are not getting anywhere anytime soon...
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Born in Italy, moved a bunch, living in Spain, my heart always belonged to Roleplaying Games
Guys, calling someone out for a different point of view is not the best way to go about this. I don't work for DNDBeyond, but I can tell you that most places want to be inclusive, and welcoming of viewpoints. Singling someone out for an opinion is neither welcoming nor kind. Let's not make someone feel ganged up on, or singled out.
I am not interested at all about paper books. I prefer digital much more than paper. But others feel differently. Even if DNDBeyond has a different roadmap then someone else plans to travel, anyone should be welcome to ask why DNDBeyond is choosing that path. You never know if other alternatives were considered until asked.
I personally was surprised this thread has been left open this long as it feels like we are beating a dead horse at this time. But again, others may have a different point of view of the thread.
By way of an explanation of why this thread is still open, it is the experience of the moderator team that locking such threads will result in a new thread starting, or multiple new threads.
We are also not in the business of censoring the forums, as long as everyone involved is being civil and not breaking the site rules/ToS.
Everyone is welcome to express their thoughts and opinions (again, as long as they don't break site rules/ToS).
I do urge people though that, if you feel a conversation is going nowhere and you're getting frustrated, it is a much better plan to just leave the thread, rather than start insulting other people or their viewpoints.
Kreakdude, when you buy a PHB, and later WotC comes out with a special edition cover, do you complain you can't get a free/discounted copy of the special edition for already owning a regular copy? This is the same scenario... same content, different containers. If you want another copy of the material, because the container is different, more pleasing, or more convenient to you, then you should have to pay for the product in full a second time. Although, in this instance, you're already getting a discount on the full price and you've had multiple opportunities to get a discount code on top of that. If it's just about the up front cost, you can buy it piecemeal. If you can't justify even that much discount, then sell the physical copy. They've given you multiple inches, but you won't be satisfied until you get the full mile. This sounds like your problem, not Curse's or WotC's.
I made the exact same question/point in the previous page of this thread, alas I have been utterly ignored by Kreakdude (as many other times I tried to point out fallacies in someone's logic)... Hope you will have better luck than me.
In any case, the problem itself is more the size and shape of a simple "wall-against-wall" situation, and I am afraid we are not getting anywhere anytime soon...
I didn't ignore. I stand by what I said before. The logic applies. I invite you to use common sense and rational thinking to compare your example to the 1.99 feat example I've set forth and entertain why one is offered and one isn't. Then apply what you've come up with against PHB physical copy vs DDB PHB with digital benefits. To me it's obvious, but even if I could explain it to you in a way that you understood you won't be swayed or empathetic unless you come up with it yourself.
EDIT: I'm not sure if what you meant by "size and shape of a simple 'wall against wall' situation" is relevant to what I'm about to say, but yes I think this comes down to whether you see each product as totally totally separate products or do you see them all as parts to a single product which is D&D 5e. I see the latter.
Kreakdude, when you buy a PHB, and later WotC comes out with a special edition cover, do you complain you can't get a free/discounted copy of the special edition for already owning a regular copy? This is the same scenario... same content, different containers. If you want another copy of the material, because the container is different, more pleasing, or more convenient to you, then you should have to pay for the product in full a second time. Although, in this instance, you're already getting a discount on the full price and you've had multiple opportunities to get a discount code on top of that. If it's just about the up front cost, you can buy it piecemeal. If you can't justify even that much discount, then sell the physical copy. They've given you multiple inches, but you won't be satisfied until you get the full mile. This sounds like your problem, not Curse's or WotC's.
I made the exact same question/point in the previous page of this thread, alas I have been utterly ignored by Kreakdude (as many other times I tried to point out fallacies in someone's logic)... Hope you will have better luck than me.
In any case, the problem itself is more the size and shape of a simple "wall-against-wall" situation, and I am afraid we are not getting anywhere anytime soon...
I didn't ignore. I stand by what I said before. The logic applies. I invite you to use common sense and rational thinking to compare your example to the 1.99 feat example I've set forth and entertain why one is offered and one isn't. Then apply what you've come up with against PHB physical copy vs DDB PHB with digital benefits. To me it's obvious, but even if I could explain it to you in a way that you understood you won't be swayed or empathetic unless you come up with it yourself.
EDIT: I'm not sure if what you meant by "size and shape of a simple 'wall against wall' situation" is relevant to what I'm about to say, but yes I think this comes down to whether you see each product as totally totally separate products or do you see them all as parts to a single product which is D&D 5e. I see the latter.
Your 1.99 feat example, unless I missed it in a previous page, comes after my question, and the post I was basing my question on also does not have any mention of such example.
I am not un-empathetic, I can perfectly see a case being made for future copies of the physical books to be sold with a discount/coupon for the digital version of it, a one-time code applicable only once in one of the partnered digital distributors of D&D 5ed content, I'd be all up for it, since I love both physical and digital formats. What I do not understand is how this can be asked for retroactively, because that is what most people are asking for. You said it yourself several times "I already own the physiscal book, I should be given a discount/access to the digital content for it".
I also feel the feat example is not really fitting, as you are comparing a same-medium option with a cross-medium option. If I buy an episode of a series on a digital platform I am not entitled to a discount on the boxed, DVD version of it. This is the same thing, with the difference that most boxed versions of movies/series nowadays come with a code to redeem a digital version of the product. But before that started happening we were in the same situation you are depicting now with DDB, but I do not think (I might be wrong) someone would claim "I have bought the DVD for this series before redeem codes for the digital version were a thing, I should be given access to/a discount on the digital version of it". It is entirely up to Wizards of the Coast to include codes for digital content redemption in their books, but believe me when I say that even if they do, there is no economically logical explanation as to why it should apply retroactively, nor a real way to do so (and here we go back to the point that there is no way to validate a single copy of any manual at this point in time, as any code appearing on nay manual is the same across all copies of that same edition of the manual).
So, I ask again: how is what you are asking any different than pretending to have a discount/be given a special edition of a D&D 5ed manual, given the only thing changing is aesthetic and possible quality of the materials involved (and I am applying your own logic from your message I posed this same question on from last page)?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Born in Italy, moved a bunch, living in Spain, my heart always belonged to Roleplaying Games
Just for developer feedback, I am happy with the model and understand that whilst the content is the same, the product is different.
I liken it to a movie, I can stream on Netflix or buy the DVD. Same content, but the delivery methods comes form 2 different sources with their own pros and cons.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
I can't take responsibility for everyone's understanding and ability to apply logically and rationally to all situations. I have explained it sufficiently. If you don't understand there is plenty of explanations and re-explanations over the course of 28 pages I suggest you re-read if your goal is to understand. I also suggest you answer your own questions as to the comparisons you've made. Compare and contrast your examples against DDB's policy of buying an individual feat for $1.99 in the PHB and then later buying the PHB at a discount of $1.99. DDB doing that instills in me a sense of confidence in my purchases. Doesn't it do the same for you? Unfortunately there is a bigger umbrella covering the entire edition that negates that confidence for me.
But the Feat/Book relationship isn't the same as the Book/Platform relationship.
Individual Feat Purchase = DDB
Discounted Book Purchase = DDB
Digital Book Purchase = DDB
Physical Book Purchase = A number of different 3rd parties
By this logic, if I am understanding correctly, If I were to buy just one feat for $1.99 on DDB, I should then also be entitled (not meant pejoratively btw) to a $1.99 discount on a physical book purchase?
Why does a random 3rd party owe me $1.99 for choosing to purchase content from another seller?
We can point the finger back to WotC, but WotC isn't a seller.
I know it seems like pro-DDB people gang up on anti-DDB (or at least anti-DDB business model) people, but it's just that the fact that DDB is a separate product from a physical book is absolutely clear common sense to us, and we can't understand how others can just keep refusing to acknowledge this. If some of us get an angry tone, it's out of frustration of trying to explain something so simple to a brick wall.
They are different products. They just are. DDB is fair. WotC is fair. If you disagree, you are free to feel that way, but feelings aren't facts. I'm sorry if this seems rude, but it's frustrating. I really do mean all due respect, but the market has spoken on this issue. DDB has been out for some time now and business is booming. I don't know what else to tell you.
Different vendors all under the same WotC 5e d&d umbrella. Again, It's not a lack of understanding on my part. Your explanation goes back to that assumption that if you could just teach me, the brick wall, then I would be fixed.
If them being different products is a fact then I guess I'm playing a different game when I have the physical book open at the table vs when I have the compendium content open on my phone.
I'd posit this discussion has reached an impasse and will only spiral round in circles. Perhaps it best to end it here before this becomes a nonsensical farce of repetition and a derailment of the thread into pointless arguing. Both sides have said their piece and neither side will move from their stance, the only conclusion is an end.
My Homebrew: Races | Subclasses | Backgrounds | Spells | Magic Items | Feats
Need help with Homebrew? Check out this FAQ/Guide thread by IamSposta
See My Youtube Videos for Tips & Tricks using D&D Beyond
"The umbrella of WotC" only matters if they are the vendors.
Lots of companies push their products out to different vendors, who then operate completely independently of each other. That's a hugely common and accepted economic model.
Like in my T-shirt example. You can get the same Spider-Man prints at Target that you do at Wal-Mart, however you'll find they are of different quality. That's because even though it's the same design used for the same purpose, they are printed on different fabrics. Both are cool shirts with the exact same image, but they are different products and will feel different to the wearer. Both under the "umbrella" of Marvel, but Marvel isn't expected to make up the difference to a person who wants both shirts. Neither is the other vendor. If you want two different shirts, even if they have the same image, you pay for two different shirts.
Similarly, the player wouldn't know the difference between a game run by a DM with a physical book vs one run by a DM with DDB. But the DM definitely knows the difference. They are different products. Same game. Different "units" with different feels to them.
Sorry to keep this going, but yes, I do feel like if I explain it plainly enough, eventually you'll get it. Or you're trolling. Or you're just dense. I doubt it's the 3rd one, but just saying.
If I have to explain to you the difference between your t-shirt example and 5e then, imo, you are completely incapable of being rational and I don't think there's anything I can do to end this in a good way for you. Also you're being pretty rude. Sorry I refuse to go on with you when you're like this.
This is a quick reminder to please keep this discussion civil.
If another user of these forums disagrees with your views, it doesn't make them stupid/dense or any other derogatory term - you just have an intrinsically different view.
If you should find yourself in a position where you feel you have explained your thoughts on this topic and further discussion is frustrating you - please move on, leave the conversation and contribute elsewhere on the forums.
Thank you. :)
Pun-loving nerd | She/Her/Hers | Profile art by Becca Golins
If you need help with homebrew, please post on the homebrew forums, where multiple staff and moderators can read your post and help you!
"We got this, no problem! I'll take the twenty on the left - you guys handle the one on the right!"🔊
I tried to search this thread for any mention of the word "Errata ". I have a simple question: does D&D Beyond keep all material up-to-date with errata? If so, that alone is a good reason to consider the digital versions. My only fear was the (hopefully) far-future possibility of it all getting shut down, and thus my access to books is gone, but I'm willing to take the risk because this service is so damn good.
Yes, all DDB content is updated by WotC errata. This is the first verification of that I could find from a search (BadEye is Adam Bradford, DDB bigwig):
I think that's just awesome (and I'd be surprised if it weren't the case, frankly). I know, practically speaking, it shouldn't be a huge deal to print out some errata, but I have re-purchased books just so I could have the most up-to-date rules (I miss those days I had some money to burn!). The D&D rules are sort of a living document in this way and D&DBeyond has an advantage in terms of easy quick reference that never has to be checked against errata. Of course, I know mistakes can still be made in conversion, as it's still humans providing the service, but...that's the case in all things.
You're right. On the bright side, if you find mistakes, they have a subforum (Feedback or Bugs & Support) where you can point them out and from what I have seen response is pretty positive and quick, though perhaps not always the fix itself.
Just confirming that we 100% update with any errata issued. There's a thread here where we have also collated what that errata is:
https://www.dndbeyond.com/forums/dungeons-dragons-discussion/rules-game-mechanics/8760-official-wizards-of-the-coast-errata
Pun-loving nerd | She/Her/Hers | Profile art by Becca Golins
If you need help with homebrew, please post on the homebrew forums, where multiple staff and moderators can read your post and help you!
"We got this, no problem! I'll take the twenty on the left - you guys handle the one on the right!"🔊
People forget how many haters there were for “invalidated” dead tree products due to errata! lol. I was never that harsh, but those people should LOVE this as much as I do.!
Kreakdude, when you buy a PHB, and later WotC comes out with a special edition cover, do you complain you can't get a free/discounted copy of the special edition for already owning a regular copy? This is the same scenario... same content, different containers. If you want another copy of the material, because the container is different, more pleasing, or more convenient to you, then you should have to pay for the product in full a second time. Although, in this instance, you're already getting a discount on the full price and you've had multiple opportunities to get a discount code on top of that. If it's just about the up front cost, you can buy it piecemeal. If you can't justify even that much discount, then sell the physical copy. They've given you multiple inches, but you won't be satisfied until you get the full mile. This sounds like your problem, not Curse's or WotC's.
Feature Requests || Homebrew FAQ || Pricing FAQ || Hardcovers FAQ || Snippet Codes || Tooltips
DDB Guides & FAQs, Class Guides, Character Builds, Game Guides, Useful Websites, and WOTC Resources
I made the exact same question/point in the previous page of this thread, alas I have been utterly ignored by Kreakdude (as many other times I tried to point out fallacies in someone's logic)... Hope you will have better luck than me.
In any case, the problem itself is more the size and shape of a simple "wall-against-wall" situation, and I am afraid we are not getting anywhere anytime soon...
Born in Italy, moved a bunch, living in Spain, my heart always belonged to Roleplaying Games
Guys, calling someone out for a different point of view is not the best way to go about this. I don't work for DNDBeyond, but I can tell you that most places want to be inclusive, and welcoming of viewpoints. Singling someone out for an opinion is neither welcoming nor kind. Let's not make someone feel ganged up on, or singled out.
I am not interested at all about paper books. I prefer digital much more than paper. But others feel differently. Even if DNDBeyond has a different roadmap then someone else plans to travel, anyone should be welcome to ask why DNDBeyond is choosing that path. You never know if other alternatives were considered until asked.
I personally was surprised this thread has been left open this long as it feels like we are beating a dead horse at this time. But again, others may have a different point of view of the thread.
By way of an explanation of why this thread is still open, it is the experience of the moderator team that locking such threads will result in a new thread starting, or multiple new threads.
We are also not in the business of censoring the forums, as long as everyone involved is being civil and not breaking the site rules/ToS.
Everyone is welcome to express their thoughts and opinions (again, as long as they don't break site rules/ToS).
I do urge people though that, if you feel a conversation is going nowhere and you're getting frustrated, it is a much better plan to just leave the thread, rather than start insulting other people or their viewpoints.
Pun-loving nerd | She/Her/Hers | Profile art by Becca Golins
If you need help with homebrew, please post on the homebrew forums, where multiple staff and moderators can read your post and help you!
"We got this, no problem! I'll take the twenty on the left - you guys handle the one on the right!"🔊
I didn't ignore. I stand by what I said before. The logic applies. I invite you to use common sense and rational thinking to compare your example to the 1.99 feat example I've set forth and entertain why one is offered and one isn't. Then apply what you've come up with against PHB physical copy vs DDB PHB with digital benefits. To me it's obvious, but even if I could explain it to you in a way that you understood you won't be swayed or empathetic unless you come up with it yourself.
EDIT: I'm not sure if what you meant by "size and shape of a simple 'wall against wall' situation" is relevant to what I'm about to say, but yes I think this comes down to whether you see each product as totally totally separate products or do you see them all as parts to a single product which is D&D 5e. I see the latter.
Your 1.99 feat example, unless I missed it in a previous page, comes after my question, and the post I was basing my question on also does not have any mention of such example.
I am not un-empathetic, I can perfectly see a case being made for future copies of the physical books to be sold with a discount/coupon for the digital version of it, a one-time code applicable only once in one of the partnered digital distributors of D&D 5ed content, I'd be all up for it, since I love both physical and digital formats.
What I do not understand is how this can be asked for retroactively, because that is what most people are asking for. You said it yourself several times "I already own the physiscal book, I should be given a discount/access to the digital content for it".
I also feel the feat example is not really fitting, as you are comparing a same-medium option with a cross-medium option. If I buy an episode of a series on a digital platform I am not entitled to a discount on the boxed, DVD version of it. This is the same thing, with the difference that most boxed versions of movies/series nowadays come with a code to redeem a digital version of the product. But before that started happening we were in the same situation you are depicting now with DDB, but I do not think (I might be wrong) someone would claim "I have bought the DVD for this series before redeem codes for the digital version were a thing, I should be given access to/a discount on the digital version of it".
It is entirely up to Wizards of the Coast to include codes for digital content redemption in their books, but believe me when I say that even if they do, there is no economically logical explanation as to why it should apply retroactively, nor a real way to do so (and here we go back to the point that there is no way to validate a single copy of any manual at this point in time, as any code appearing on nay manual is the same across all copies of that same edition of the manual).
So, I ask again: how is what you are asking any different than pretending to have a discount/be given a special edition of a D&D 5ed manual, given the only thing changing is aesthetic and possible quality of the materials involved (and I am applying your own logic from your message I posed this same question on from last page)?
Born in Italy, moved a bunch, living in Spain, my heart always belonged to Roleplaying Games
Just for developer feedback, I am happy with the model and understand that whilst the content is the same, the product is different.
I liken it to a movie, I can stream on Netflix or buy the DVD. Same content, but the delivery methods comes form 2 different sources with their own pros and cons.