I don't mean to sound rude, but your comment was rude by intent.
I have done far more than "crack the spine"... If you actually read more of the thread and read more of the books and paid attention to the mechanical advantage, or lack thereof, with many of the magical items, even the DMG table is just as flawed. Either some magical items need to have their rarity adjusted, and dramatically in some cases, or each item should be individually priced. The exact reasons for this are pointed out above... if you'd bothered to scroll up.
It works as an organization tool as well as giving you the price for every item (official and partnered, currently 4305 items).
The prices are solely based on the item's power. They take into account attunement requirement, if the item is consumable, number of uses as well as many other things. All the prices use formulas in their calculation, so they stay consistent with one another.
This list has now been used actively for some months in a West Marches campaign where all items are available and we've been updating the prices when needed for balancing reasons. If you have feedback about the prices feel free to give it here or on Discord (link in the website).
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
I don't mean to sound rude, but your comment was rude by intent.
I have done far more than "crack the spine"... If you actually read more of the thread and read more of the books and paid attention to the mechanical advantage, or lack thereof, with many of the magical items, even the DMG table is just as flawed. Either some magical items need to have their rarity adjusted, and dramatically in some cases, or each item should be individually priced. The exact reasons for this are pointed out above... if you'd bothered to scroll up.
I've seen many people complain about magic item prices solely based on rarity. I agree with the complaint so I made:
Ryex's Magic Item Prices
It works as an organization tool as well as giving you the price for every item (official and partnered, currently 4305 items).
The prices are solely based on the item's power. They take into account attunement requirement, if the item is consumable, number of uses as well as many other things. All the prices use formulas in their calculation, so they stay consistent with one another.
This list has now been used actively for some months in a West Marches campaign where all items are available and we've been updating the prices when needed for balancing reasons. If you have feedback about the prices feel free to give it here or on Discord (link in the website).