In 5.5, would you allow a human to pick the Prodigy Feat from Xanathar at Lev 1?
It has no 4th level prerequisite nor it gives +1 to an Ability like Skill Expert does, so it seems reasonable to me, but I'd like to hear people's thoughts on the subject.
It's not allowed under RAW since it's not an Origin Feat, and I wouldn't allow it as a house rule because it is very similar to Skill Expert, which is also not an Origin Feat and as you point out has a level 4+ prerequisite.
It's not allowed under RAW since it's not an Origin Feat, and I wouldn't allow it as a house rule because it is very similar to Skill Expert, which is also not an Origin Feat and as you point out has a level 4+ prerequisite.
It doesn't have a 4+ prerequisite. It has a species prerequisite though.
Prodigy is generally a worse Skill Expert since it has no ASI in exchange for a tool proficiency and a language, but much better than Skilled (Origin Feat). It's too good to be an Origin feat.
In 5.5, would you allow a human to pick the Prodigy Feat from Xanathar at Lev 1?
It has no 4th level prerequisite nor it gives +1 to an Ability like Skill Expert does, so it seems reasonable to me, but I'd like to hear people's thoughts on the subject.
No, I wouldn't.
It's not allowed under RAW since it's not an Origin Feat, and I wouldn't allow it as a house rule because it is very similar to Skill Expert, which is also not an Origin Feat and as you point out has a level 4+ prerequisite.
pronouns: he/she/they
It doesn't have a 4+ prerequisite. It has a species prerequisite though.
Prodigy is generally a worse Skill Expert since it has no ASI in exchange for a tool proficiency and a language, but much better than Skilled (Origin Feat). It's too good to be an Origin feat.
How to add Tooltips.
My houserulings.