Hey everyone, I noticed that there is a lot of races and monsters in D&D that are said to be master blacksmiths. But D&D doesn't specify which one of the races/monsters that exist are actually the best smith's in all the realms and dimensions. Anytime I've tried looking into it, every race/monster that read about is said to be a master and their craft is unmatched by others. So I've been wanting to hear from others what race/monster is known to be from least to greatest at blacksmithing all in all.
Sure there may be individuals who are better than other races at crafting, but I want to know what race/monsters are known to be the best at blacksmithing in all the realms of D&D.
Hm, I'd say there's a spectrum. For sheer metalwork, in my games, it's the dwarves. But then there's crafting in stuff that isn't metal (not smithing, I know), for which I'd say elves. Elven blades are made from glass, you know. So, not smithing, but in direct competition with metalwork. And then there's enchanting. Both elves and dwarves are good at this, but by their natures, they have certain limitations that - again, in my games - other creatures do not. For instance, magic is much more naturally abundant on the inner and outer planes. So, as an example, Azer or Salamanders would be the top tier guys to go to if you wanted a flame enchanted weapon.
So, TLDR: No clear answer =)
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Blanket disclaimer: I only ever state opinion. But I can sound terribly dogmatic - so if you feel I'm trying to tell you what to think, I'm really not, I swear. I'm telling you what I think, that's all.
I would tend to categorize different things to different craftsmen based on culture.
Dwarves make incredible heavy armor that moves well and their weapons are great heavy weapons with ornate decorations thematic to dwarves.
Elves make incredible medium armor, particularly when mithril is used. It is light but wears so well you hardly notice it is on. Their weapons include blades of all lengths and longbows of elegance and function.
Orcs make incredible heavy armor without ornate designs, but the form and fit is very menacing while not adding encumbrance. Their weapons include things with spikes and they are very well balanced and the grip is especially comfortable and functional so that the user rarely loses their proper grip. They also tend to make the handle with a spike that can strike from that end too.
Half-Elves make the best pieces of wooden craftsmanship. They make fantastic pieces of splint armor of leather and wood that fit and move well. They likewise make the best quarterstaves and crossbows. Their longbows are high quality but lack some of the Elvish top tier decorations. They also make a special fluted arrow shaft that reduces drag like dimples on a golf ball.
Gnomes make incredible crossbows that are unusually light and have beautiful metal fittings. They are also known for the best scale armor with all the links and plates shimmering like a piece of fabric.
Dragonborn make exquisite heavy armor for creatures with tails. They also make special war shields with spikes that can be used as weapons along the perimeter. A special fighting technique is employed to make use of the shield in this way.
Those are some examples of how you might approach it. The masters have a niche where they are unusually great standouts.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Cum catapultae proscriptae erunt tum soli proscript catapultas habebunt
Sticking strictly with smiths ( metal workers), least is easy - all the various races that don’t have metalworking as a known skill and use various stone/bone/ etc or found/taken (metal) objects and weapons - all tied for worst since they have no (official) ability.* Best is somewhat different, the reality ( yes I know it’s a fantasy game relax) the materials themselves limit what is possible to do with them (you are never going to hammer iron into sheets as thin as gold leaf). Yes magic can help but given that all species are bound by the same 10 levels of magical power that negates the effects magic might have had on this question. So realistically all the different species listed as “great smiths” are pretty much equal as they are skilled enough to take the metals and magic to their natural limits. Their styles are different but the actual quality of their mastersmith’s products are the same.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Wisea$$ DM and Player since 1979.
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Hey everyone, I noticed that there is a lot of races and monsters in D&D that are said to be master blacksmiths. But D&D doesn't specify which one of the races/monsters that exist are actually the best smith's in all the realms and dimensions. Anytime I've tried looking into it, every race/monster that read about is said to be a master and their craft is unmatched by others. So I've been wanting to hear from others what race/monster is known to be from least to greatest at blacksmithing all in all.
Sure there may be individuals who are better than other races at crafting, but I want to know what race/monsters are known to be the best at blacksmithing in all the realms of D&D.
So please, tell me your opinions.
Hm, I'd say there's a spectrum. For sheer metalwork, in my games, it's the dwarves. But then there's crafting in stuff that isn't metal (not smithing, I know), for which I'd say elves. Elven blades are made from glass, you know. So, not smithing, but in direct competition with metalwork. And then there's enchanting. Both elves and dwarves are good at this, but by their natures, they have certain limitations that - again, in my games - other creatures do not. For instance, magic is much more naturally abundant on the inner and outer planes. So, as an example, Azer or Salamanders would be the top tier guys to go to if you wanted a flame enchanted weapon.
So, TLDR: No clear answer =)
Blanket disclaimer: I only ever state opinion. But I can sound terribly dogmatic - so if you feel I'm trying to tell you what to think, I'm really not, I swear. I'm telling you what I think, that's all.
I would tend to categorize different things to different craftsmen based on culture.
Dwarves make incredible heavy armor that moves well and their weapons are great heavy weapons with ornate decorations thematic to dwarves.
Elves make incredible medium armor, particularly when mithril is used. It is light but wears so well you hardly notice it is on. Their weapons include blades of all lengths and longbows of elegance and function.
Orcs make incredible heavy armor without ornate designs, but the form and fit is very menacing while not adding encumbrance. Their weapons include things with spikes and they are very well balanced and the grip is especially comfortable and functional so that the user rarely loses their proper grip. They also tend to make the handle with a spike that can strike from that end too.
Half-Elves make the best pieces of wooden craftsmanship. They make fantastic pieces of splint armor of leather and wood that fit and move well. They likewise make the best quarterstaves and crossbows. Their longbows are high quality but lack some of the Elvish top tier decorations. They also make a special fluted arrow shaft that reduces drag like dimples on a golf ball.
Gnomes make incredible crossbows that are unusually light and have beautiful metal fittings. They are also known for the best scale armor with all the links and plates shimmering like a piece of fabric.
Dragonborn make exquisite heavy armor for creatures with tails. They also make special war shields with spikes that can be used as weapons along the perimeter. A special fighting technique is employed to make use of the shield in this way.
Those are some examples of how you might approach it. The masters have a niche where they are unusually great standouts.
Cum catapultae proscriptae erunt tum soli proscript catapultas habebunt
Sticking strictly with smiths ( metal workers), least is easy - all the various races that don’t have metalworking as a known skill and use various stone/bone/ etc or found/taken (metal) objects and weapons - all tied for worst since they have no (official) ability.* Best is somewhat different, the reality ( yes I know it’s a fantasy game relax) the materials themselves limit what is possible to do with them (you are never going to hammer iron into sheets as thin as gold leaf). Yes magic can help but given that all species are bound by the same 10 levels of magical power that negates the effects magic might have had on this question. So realistically all the different species listed as “great smiths” are pretty much equal as they are skilled enough to take the metals and magic to their natural limits. Their styles are different but the actual quality of their mastersmith’s products are the same.
Wisea$$ DM and Player since 1979.