Battles are the moments that many Dungeons & Dragons DMs and players live for, but they can also become routine. The players and monsters roll initiative, take hits at each other, use magic, miss or connect, and then repeat until one side goes down or escapes.
There’s nothing wrong with this in theory, but if you want to introduce a degree of dynamism into even the most mundane of random encounters, one way to do so is to utilize environmental hazards.
When we think of what hazards mean in D&D, we too often only imagine the rogue stopping at a dungeon door to roll an Investigation check, or perhaps the druid creating difficult terrain with Spike Growth. But there are a plethora of other ways that we can integrate these features into our games, and before I plot out any combat scenario, I like to ask the following questions:
- Where is this combat taking place, and are there any traps, obstacles or other assorted “gimmicks” nearby that might naturally come into play?
- Take a brief tour of the environment: What’s in the sky? What’s on the ceiling? The walls? What’s the ground like? Quick decisions about small details can provide new dimensions to an encounter.
- Can both the players and the monsters be affected by these elements during the fight?
Let’s look at how these questions helped me amp up fights in three separate campaigns. Warning - light spoilers describing battles in Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden, Ghosts of Saltmarsh, and Curse of Strahd await.
A Wall of Spikes and a Zombie Kebab
Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden features an early moment where players may be tasked with invading a duergar outpost. When I was prepping this area, I immediately asked what “gimmicks” were present, and how could they be utilized by both players and enemies?
- The text listed two unique features in the outpost’s main rooms. The first was a caged ogre zombie that the duergar used to pull their dogsled, and the second was a set of lever-activated iron spikes that could spring from the floor and ceiling along two entryways, snaring adventurers and protecting the duergar mastermind, whose quarters were on the other side.
- If free, the zombie would side with the duergar in a fight. The trap, however, was an open season free-for-all depending on whoever gained access to the lever activating it.
There are a number of ways this encounter can go down. Players can kill the ogre in its cage, or they can let the undead monstrosity lie, sneak past the trap without activating it, and catch the duergar chief in his sleep. But my players decided upon a different, more chaotic path. After they passed their Perception and Investigation checks to analyze their surroundings, I took great care to describe the gimmicks I’d noted. Fixated on my descriptions, they came up with an excellent plot to cause shenanigans by freeing the zombie and baiting it.
Shortly after they released the creature, the duergar leader came running, but the party’s fastest members activated the trap before he could, with the ogre exactly in the right spot. KRUNCH! The zombie was skewered, and what followed was a ridiculously gory combat where the party was divided, facing duergar on both sides of the trap, with everyone fighting over control of the lever that maneuvered the spikes! These razor-edged barriers went up and down several times as the lever wiggled back and forth, and the zombie always ended in the middle, taking damage each time it failed its Dexterity saves. Meanwhile, both my players and their duergar foes chucked ranged weapons at each other whenever the spikes were briefly lowered, and it was a chaotic affair that only ended when one of my players ignited the trap mechanism with Fireball, roasting both the duergar leader and what remained of the zombie, which resembled a giant rotting kebab at that point.
Once again, another group could approach this scenario differently. But the novelty of an ogre zombie within a duergar outpost - as well as a spike trap that could affect both enemies and players - stood out to me as rich nuggets that could elevate rote combat into something utterly bombastic, and my players did not disappoint.
Playing Tetris on a Cargo Ship
Ghosts of Saltmarsh contains instances of close-quarters combat on ships, which are fantastic arenas for environmental hazards. In a homebrew game that combined elements from two of the adventures in the book, Tammeraut’s Fate and The Styes, I created a moment where my players were fighting skum and drowned assassins on a ship that had partially taken on water. As always, I asked myself how the setting could make combat more engaging.
- I decided to pack the ship’s interior with large cargo boxes that would make an already cramped battle map even more claustrophobic. The goal was to amplify the horror of being stuck in a confined space with freakish foes who could be lurking behind any box, just waiting to spring out with crossbow bolts and psychic attacks.
- These boxes could be pushed around with successful Strength checks by any creature, and they also served as cover. In fact, when envisioning this fight, I imagined cover-based combat reminiscent of a video game such as Gears of War, with players ducking behind boxes to fire their weapons at slowly advancing enemies.
The battle initially played out much as I had anticipated, with my players making liberal use of cover. Suddenly, however, the bard threw a monkey wrench into the mix by casting Thunderwave, which sends unsecured objects 10 feet away from the caster.
This was the perfect moment to maximize the obstacles I’d placed around the battlefield and take the fight to a new level, and what followed was what my players later referred to as the “Tetris effect.” The boxes went sliding everywhere, some of them trapping enemies against walls, others knocking the players backward. As the map shifted and new choke points were created, both my players and the monsters I was running had to adapt, and the bard repeated the Thunderwave one more time near the battle’s climax, resulting in more block-pushing madness.
In other words, I’d expected Gears of War, and I got both that and Tetris by ensuring the map was filled with hurdles that could be manipulated by D&D physics.
The Stained Glass Fury of Strahd
Speaking of bosses, why not spice up a campaign’s climax with a dynamic battlefield? Curse of Strahd gives DMs numerous options when it comes to dueling Barovia’s vampire lord, and in my version of the campaign, the party met Strahd in his throne room, which is described in the text as having a giant broken window in its west wall.
- Taking inspiration from the gothic arenas in Castlevania, I decided to fixate on this window as an environmental gimmick. In fact, I ramped up Ravenloft’s decor and placed multiple windows around the throne, all of them stained glass fixtures.
- How could the windows affect both Strahd and my players? Well, as the vampire became more vicious with bloodlust, I hoped to have him grapple characters (which is listed as a built-in feature of his Unarmed Strike) and thrust them through the windows. The goal was to have stained glass explode everywhere for flavor, but also to emphasize Strahd’s undead strength, which is something you always see in vampire films. Perhaps Strahd could also drag a character out of a window and drop them or continue the fight on Ravenloft’s roof. After all, he has Spider Climb, a bat form, and the ability to turn into mist - why couldn’t he potentially fight outside his castle walls as well as within them? Meanwhile, the players had Acrobatics scores high enough to land on ledges, and one was also a monk with the ability to move along vertical surfaces, so I wasn’t hugely worried about them. Maybe they could even impale Strahd on a rooftop spire in a very fitting demise!
In practice, all of the windows broke at intervals in the battle, and Strahd grappled the monk, who fought back, shoving the vampire outside with her. She took damage from the stained glass (Strahd received a reduced amount thanks to his resistances), and they both landed on a ledge and exchanged blows, with Strahd eventually using his Spider Climb in a moment reminiscent of the original Dracula novel, where Jonathan Harker witnesses the titular vampire skittering like an insect along a wall. At the same time, the other players fired ranged attacks at Strahd, but they ran the risk of careening from the open windows themselves - especially due to Strahd’s Gust of Wind spell, which can push creatures up to 15 feet.
Strahd didn’t end up impaled on a spire, alas, but the fight was still a dramatic exercise that left everyone on the edge of their seat. None of the players had the Fly spell, either - just imagine the unpredictability that could have resulted there!
Endless Possibilities for Invigorated Combat
I’ve only scratched the surface with these examples. Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden’s tundra setting offers numerous chances to fight on icy cliffs or maybe even a frozen lake, which could shatter and plunge everyone into freezing water. Ghosts of Saltmarsh features an attack on a sahuagin stronghold, which is a great chance to imagine underwater hazards. (Rooms full of jellyfish poison or sheets of sharp seaweed acting like barbed wire, anyone?) Curse of Strahd has an entire winery dungeon, with vats of blood-red liquid that could spill everywhere, turning the battlefield into difficult terrain and offering colorful fuel for grim storytelling.
And with the reveal of Van Richten's Guide to Ravenloft, a massive horror expansion with 30 all-new Domains of Dread, utilizing environmental hazards to manufacture a feeling of tension and terror will only become more vital. The slippery ground can easily bring an adventurer to their knees as they struggle to outrun a horde of ghouls, weaving through the rubble of a ruined fortress might be the best means of outmaneuvering a gibbering mouther, and the silver cross in a cathedral could be your party’s only defense against a pack of werewolves.
Once you pay close attention to the environmental hazards that lurk behind combat scenes and communicate them to your players, the possibilities are never-ending.
Jeremy Blum (@PixelGrotto) is a journalist, gaming blogger, comic book aficionado, and fan of all forms of storytelling who rolled his first polyhedral dice while living in Hong Kong in 2017. Since then, he's never looked back and loves roleplaying games for the chance to tell the tales that have been swirling in his head since childhood.
Those were probably my three favorite series, so I can't wait!
Same. Especially with class 101!!!!
I’ve been begging for more info on designing traps and interesting environment mechanics for the source books. Please more of these articles!
My daughter and I built a small dungeon for a session she was DMing where it was a series of rooms that would both rotate on their center axis and shuffle around. It made for some very exciting and hilarious combat as groups would get separated, or monsters trapped in one room with one character.
Cool.
Great article!
It’s always the little things as said that can make or break an encounter. My players are notorious for “I check the door” and never look at the hallway...
I tend to adjust my encounter difficulties the Encounter Builder gives me up a level because you never know what a pack of kobolds with a pet rust monster are capable of!
I am trying so hard to not chuck Themathmagician down the first door trap I find in CoS
I once had my party exploring a haunted mansion and the front foyer had a starburst-patterned wood mosaic on its floor underneath a chandelier. It was pretty obvious this was a trap, but one character did end up accidentally triggering it anyway but did well enough on a DEX save to avoid damage.
Much later we returned to the foyer to travel to a different part of the mansion, but this time we had a large ghostly grim reaper figure on our heels. Our tabaxi monk ran behind the panel on the floor and encouraged the others to do the same, forcing the ghost to chase after us. As soon as it did, she stomped on the panel, making it land on top of the ghost. Now, the ghost didn't take any damage from the hit, but it was forced to end its turn inside the chandelier that had fallen on top of it, and the force damage from being shunted out of the light fixture was enough to kill it!
I gave the monk inspiration for that because it was very smart that she remembered it several sessions later, and that inspiration ended up saving her when another ghost tried to age her 50 years.
This is very cool.
This is a really cool article. Thanks.
this is amazing.
To be honest, I wasn't sure what to expect after recent departures, but this is great, can't wait to see new content from you guys.
Great idea! Tomorrow I'm running Curse of Strahd, and we're having
Van Richten's Tower.
I plan on
making the pack of werewolves attack them while they're still inside
and I'm sure gonna take advantage of all the environmental hazards there!
The floors and scaffoldings could collapse, the golems may activate, Khazan's electrical trap may activate and players couldeven fall into the lake!
This is really good. I am a DM and I think that I will now think more deeply about how I could incorporate natural hazards and beneficiaries. Maybe I could have a character break his leg by tripping over a tree, or if I was feeling generous I could make the parched, thirsty characters find a cold spring.
Wow! this was great thanks!
This is great!
Is there any way to:
1. Put a like to a post
2. Either via like or any other way, to keep all favorite posts on D&DB?
Great article!
Nice article! I like the bite-sized examples.
There has been so much talk about combat encounters lately we put out an episode about it today. You can hear it at https://www.ttjourneys.com
This reminds me of one of the things I love the most about the Pirates of the Caribbean films, or at least the early ones. Think of the first fight between Will and Captain Jack were there fighting in the blacksmith shop, and there's the donkey and the gears and all the weapons lying around. At different times both of the characters benefit from the environments, and it makes it an epic battle in a small space.
Obviously, those are very elaborate fight scenes planned out in great detail. But as this article points out, one or two features that can pitch the battle one way or the other can be a really fascinating way of making a combat memorable.
Kudos on a great and inspiring article!