Having both editions present simultaneously is neither an improvement nor helpful, it just causes bloat and makes everything more confusing. Please give us the option to fully disable 2024 rules site-wide if we so choose.
Partnered content is not working with the 2024 rules with regards to subclasses. Just made a half sea-elf paladin, wanted to be Oath of the Open Sea, but it was not an option.
The 2024 version of the Resilient Feat does not assign the Saving Throw option to the attribute chosen as the feat states but instead gives you an option to choose any attribute that the character does not already have proficiency in.
Partnered content is not working with the 2024 rules with regards to subclasses. Just made a half sea-elf paladin, wanted to be Oath of the Open Sea, but it was not an option.
Read the existing posts in the forum. There's multiple threads on this and all say the same: It's a known issue and one that's acknowledged in the official bugs and support thread for the 2024 PHB. All third-party content is affected and they're working with their partners to bring it forward. Likely they don't have sole permission to do so.
My Monk got updated to the new monk rules, I haven't bought them and my table's not changing to the new rules until the next campaign. How to change it back?
My Monk got updated to the new monk rules, I haven't bought them and my table's not changing to the new rules until the next campaign. How to change it back?
Again, read the main update. They don't have the system set up to differentiate yet, they're working on it.
I don't want "free rules". I want to run my 5e content without having to wade through this 2024 garbage that has nothing to do with the game I'm running.
Having both editions present simultaneously is neither an improvement nor helpful, it just causes bloat and makes everything more confusing. Please give us the option to fully disable 2024 rules site-wide if we so choose.
I agree with this. I would rather have one or the other when it comes to legacy vs. 2024 spells. I have no interest in the old spells and would really like to have all my characters and homebrew have access to 2024 tool tips without having to spend hours redoing all of them.
Just to clarify to some people. Not all of the new content is available right now, but it will be once they actually release the books on the seventeenth. Even then, however, I expect they will only provide one subclass for each class, and just a couple feats, as they are right now. If you want access to everything, purchase the books online.
Just to clarify to some people. Not all of the new content is available right now, but it will be once they actually release the books on the seventeenth. Even then, however, I expect they will only provide one subclass for each class, and just a couple feats, as they are right now. If you want access to everything, purchase the books online.
Not entirely true. All twelve base classes are already released with all four subclasses in the PHB, if you own the PHB and have a Master Tier sub. However, there's bugs within the content.
Hopefully the major bugs can be squashed by the 17th though. We've already seen progress.
No it doesn', just becouse you like those changes doesn't mean they are objectively better. you what would make changes better? If there was aption to togle off 2024 for those who dont want to use it. for exaple character creation is now based on 2024 core rule book which is something beyond me? Why can't we create character based on 2014 core rules anymore. ducking SpEciEs. give me a break.
I thought the intention all along was 2014 and 2024 were going to be distinct versions of the game that could be played side by side but never mixed. Peas beside carrots but never peas mixed with carrots. Yet now all my 2014 characters automatically default to the new Weapon Mastery rules. So now you can just mix them willy nilly I guess. Yes, a toggle is needed. Also, the default toggle should be EVERYTHING off instead of everything toggled on.
I thought the intention all along was 2014 and 2024 were going to be distinct versions of the game that could be played side by side but never mixed. Peas beside carrots but never peas mixed with carrots. Yet now all my 2014 characters automatically default to the new Weapon Mastery rules. So now you can just mix them willy nilly I guess. Yes, a toggle is needed. Also, the default toggle should be EVERYTHING off instead of everything toggled on.
It seems instead of just making a new edition, they made an invasive species to slowly make 5e choices obsolete and ruin the edition.
No it doesn', just becouse you like those changes doesn't mean they are objectively better. you what would make changes better? If there was aption to togle off 2024 for those who dont want to use it. for exaple character creation is now based on 2024 core rule book which is something beyond me? Why can't we create character based on 2014 core rules anymore. ducking SpEciEs. give me a break.
Legitimate complaints: "The order of character creation is new and frustrating to navigate." "I don't like that the 2024 spells and 2014 spells both show up, causing the list to be longer when selecting spells." Not legitimate complaints: "They changed 'races' to 'species' and now my game is ruined."
I thought the intention all along was 2014 and 2024 were going to be distinct versions of the game that could be played side by side but never mixed. Peas beside carrots but never peas mixed with carrots. Yet now all my 2014 characters automatically default to the new Weapon Mastery rules. So now you can just mix them willy nilly I guess. Yes, a toggle is needed. Also, the default toggle should be EVERYTHING off instead of everything toggled on.
2014 characters don't get Weapon Mastery features. The weapons show what traits they carry for characters who DO have them, but that's as far as that goes.
Personally, I like having the option of both. The ability to create a character under 2014 rules is actually unchanged if you just take a couple of minutes and learn where the buttons are now. I do agree that having toggleable tooltips would be nice.
Not legitimate complaints: "They changed 'races' to 'species' and now my game is ruined."
This I 100% agree, and dislike the thought that positive efforts toward inclusivity will be a scapegoat, instead of what I find as flaws in the design.
Personally, I like having the option of both. The ability to create a character under 2014 rules is actually unchanged if you just take a couple of minutes and learn where the buttons are now. I do agree that having toggleable tooltips would be nice.
Previously, I was honestly open minded about mixing and matching between rules updates until the rollout pushed me deep into a dissatisfaction with the 2024 rules.
Yes, you can make a 5e character still, as they thankfully walked back from turning 5e into "homebrew," but it's far less convenient. It was previously so convenient I had repurchased my entire 5e library, and more, when I adopted the tools and invited my table to join.
The 2024 rules should be considered optional content, with a toggle to turn them off. And "legacy" shouldn't be shoved to the bottom of every page and tooltip.
Not legitimate complaints: "They changed 'races' to 'species' and now my game is ruined."
This I 100% agree, and dislike the thought that positive efforts toward inclusivity will be a scapegoat, instead of what I find as flaws in the design.
Personally, I like having the option of both. The ability to create a character under 2014 rules is actually unchanged if you just take a couple of minutes and learn where the buttons are now. I do agree that having toggleable tooltips would be nice.
Previously, I was honestly open minded about mixing and matching between rules updates until the rollout pushed me deep into a dissatisfaction with the 2024 rules.
Yes, you can make a 5e character still, as they thankfully walked back from turning 5e into "homebrew," but it's far less convenient. It was previously so convenient I had repurchased my entire 5e library, and more, when I adopted the tools and invited my table to join.
The 2024 rules should be considered optional content, with a toggle to turn them off. And "legacy" shouldn't be shoved to the bottom of every page and tooltip.
I can agree that it's less convenient. Though I don't mind the new flow in creation, it just rearranged a few items. But that's me. And yeah, I could agree to a toggle to turn off the 2024 content just like any other source.
Not legitimate complaints: "They changed 'races' to 'species' and now my game is ruined."
This I 100% agree, and dislike the thought that positive efforts toward inclusivity will be a scapegoat, instead of what I find as flaws in the design.
Personally, I like having the option of both. The ability to create a character under 2014 rules is actually unchanged if you just take a couple of minutes and learn where the buttons are now. I do agree that having toggleable tooltips would be nice.
Previously, I was honestly open minded about mixing and matching between rules updates until the rollout pushed me deep into a dissatisfaction with the 2024 rules.
Yes, you can make a 5e character still, as they thankfully walked back from turning 5e into "homebrew," but it's far less convenient. It was previously so convenient I had repurchased my entire 5e library, and more, when I adopted the tools and invited my table to join.
The 2024 rules should be considered optional content, with a toggle to turn them off. And "legacy" shouldn't be shoved to the bottom of every page and tooltip.
I don't disagree with what you say here, except for one point. I would consider 2024 the current content and stat of the game and anything legacy as optional content. Basically the same end state as what you said, but from a different veiw point.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Having both editions present simultaneously is neither an improvement nor helpful, it just causes bloat and makes everything more confusing. Please give us the option to fully disable 2024 rules site-wide if we so choose.
Partnered content is not working with the 2024 rules with regards to subclasses. Just made a half sea-elf paladin, wanted to be Oath of the Open Sea, but it was not an option.
The 2024 version of the Resilient Feat does not assign the Saving Throw option to the attribute chosen as the feat states but instead gives you an option to choose any attribute that the character does not already have proficiency in.
Read the existing posts in the forum. There's multiple threads on this and all say the same: It's a known issue and one that's acknowledged in the official bugs and support thread for the 2024 PHB. All third-party content is affected and they're working with their partners to bring it forward. Likely they don't have sole permission to do so.
The Stormborn Level 10 Subclass Ability for the Druid Circle of the Sea are not showing up in the Character Sheet.
My Monk got updated to the new monk rules, I haven't bought them and my table's not changing to the new rules until the next campaign. How to change it back?
I'm having the same problem with Oath of the Sea and other partnered content.
Again, read the main update. They don't have the system set up to differentiate yet, they're working on it.
My last post answered this.
No. This is not okay.
I don't want "free rules". I want to run my 5e content without having to wade through this 2024 garbage that has nothing to do with the game I'm running.
I agree with this. I would rather have one or the other when it comes to legacy vs. 2024 spells. I have no interest in the old spells and would really like to have all my characters and homebrew have access to 2024 tool tips without having to spend hours redoing all of them.
Just to clarify to some people. Not all of the new content is available right now, but it will be once they actually release the books on the seventeenth. Even then, however, I expect they will only provide one subclass for each class, and just a couple feats, as they are right now. If you want access to everything, purchase the books online.
Not entirely true. All twelve base classes are already released with all four subclasses in the PHB, if you own the PHB and have a Master Tier sub. However, there's bugs within the content.
Hopefully the major bugs can be squashed by the 17th though. We've already seen progress.
No it doesn', just becouse you like those changes doesn't mean they are objectively better. you what would make changes better? If there was aption to togle off 2024 for those who dont want to use it. for exaple character creation is now based on 2024 core rule book which is something beyond me? Why can't we create character based on 2014 core rules anymore. ducking SpEciEs. give me a break.
I thought the intention all along was 2014 and 2024 were going to be distinct versions of the game that could be played side by side but never mixed. Peas beside carrots but never peas mixed with carrots. Yet now all my 2014 characters automatically default to the new Weapon Mastery rules. So now you can just mix them willy nilly I guess. Yes, a toggle is needed. Also, the default toggle should be EVERYTHING off instead of everything toggled on.
It seems instead of just making a new edition, they made an invasive species to slowly make 5e choices obsolete and ruin the edition.
2024Legitimate complaints: "The order of character creation is new and frustrating to navigate." "I don't like that the 2024 spells and 2014 spells both show up, causing the list to be longer when selecting spells."
Not legitimate complaints: "They changed 'races' to 'species' and now my game is ruined."
2014 characters don't get Weapon Mastery features. The weapons show what traits they carry for characters who DO have them, but that's as far as that goes.
Personally, I like having the option of both. The ability to create a character under 2014 rules is actually unchanged if you just take a couple of minutes and learn where the buttons are now. I do agree that having toggleable tooltips would be nice.
This I 100% agree, and dislike the thought that positive efforts toward inclusivity will be a scapegoat, instead of what I find as flaws in the design.
Previously, I was honestly open minded about mixing and matching between rules updates until the rollout pushed me deep into a dissatisfaction with the 2024 rules.
Yes, you can make a 5e character still, as they thankfully walked back from turning 5e into "homebrew," but it's far less convenient. It was previously so convenient I had repurchased my entire 5e library, and more, when I adopted the tools and invited my table to join.
The 2024 rules should be considered optional content, with a toggle to turn them off. And "legacy" shouldn't be shoved to the bottom of every page and tooltip.
2024I can agree that it's less convenient. Though I don't mind the new flow in creation, it just rearranged a few items. But that's me. And yeah, I could agree to a toggle to turn off the 2024 content just like any other source.
Why do tools still note show up with skills? Or how do I quickly see stats for tool usage?
I don't disagree with what you say here, except for one point. I would consider 2024 the current content and stat of the game and anything legacy as optional content. Basically the same end state as what you said, but from a different veiw point.