Now I take my Aoo against Runthiel...

Attack: 23 Damage: 10

The attack is. Very good. Although, I did not notice that the DM already rolled my attack.

(First, it's not your call. Second, I am not being disruptive if I have a right to challenge certain actions. It's all well in good if you are sitting in the sidelines but you are not playing this game. Stay in your lane)

 (It also doesnt make sense. A melee attacker should be able to sacrifice their chance to do damage to move a target around. That's tanking mechanics 101 but its whatever.) 

Using the Attack action, you can make a special melee attack to shove a creature, either to knock it prone or push it away from you. If you're able to make multiple attacks with the Attack action, this attack replaces one of them.

(The rules state that you must use the attack action to shove, AoO is not the attack action, which is why you do not get multi-attack on it. Normally I would rule to favor the players, but in this case we have players on both sides so rulings will be made RAW 99% of the time)

(You have the right to challenge, but calling a ruling "bs" is not a challenge. If someone is overstepping their boundaries, it is my prerogative to tell them so and to ask them to leave if they will not stop. You, as a player, should not be telling other players, involved in this combat or not, what they can and cannot do. You may bring such a thing to my attention, if you feel like I am not addressing something you feel is important, but that is best done through a PM to minimize drama.

If you do not feel like I am a good DM, you may bring that up to BDaddly or simply leave. No one is forcing you to play here, and I will shut down this thread if BDaddly does not believe that I am doing a good enough job for the Coliseum.

As for this match right now, I am already stressed out enough by classwork and exams. I have no more patience for players being disruptive either through excessive complaints, challenges, or arguments. This is everyone's last warning, any more disruptive actions will be met with removal from the match. My goal is to have this combat go as smoothly as possible, and I will remove players if I believe it will help. If you feel like any of this is unjust, you may bring it up to BDaddly, and his word is most definitely final)

(And Nara, I apologize but I have already rolled your AoO. You cannot wait over 24 hours to post and then make your own rolls, regardless of if mine are good or bad. As for the advantage vs straight roll, the attack is a straight roll because it is on Runthiel's turn before he makes his first reckless attack. Advantage on attacks against you due to reckless attack lasts until your turn, and reckless attack is only established on your first attack, so you would not have advantage on the AoO)

(@Keneux I stay in my lane, you stay in yours.  Your lane is not to be the DM.)

(Also, you were being disruptive.  There's about half a page that was strictly devoted to one of your challenges, and I'm not sure what that is if not disruptive.)

(I apologize if that's not my place, but I'm starting to get irritated by the constant pointless challenging as a spectator, and I can only imagine how annoying it is for the other players.)

(I sent a response in another chain. Let's keep moving.)

(Let's take these discussions to PM. The ruling stands. Future rulings May be handled differently.)

Scarab moves to F15 and heals 25 HP.

[edited]

(Since I should have PMed Nara instead of going to post for her after 24 hours, she does get to keep that roll, it does not change the outcome of Runthiel's turn, however)

Library Round 4:

Scarab backs off and restores his health.

(Sarah, Nara, Swigg is unconscious)

  A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P
16  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  . !.  .  .  .  .
 %%%%===...........=============.....%%%%%%===%%%
15  . S=  .  .  . Q=  .  .  .  =  .  .  .  =  .
 ......=...........=...........=...........=.....
14  . G=  .  . G.  =  .  .  .  =  .  .  .  =  .
 ......=...........=============...........=.....
13  .  =  . N.  .  .  .  %  .  .  .  .  .  =  .
 ......=.................%.................=.....
12  .  =  . !.  .  .  .  . R. s.  .  .  .  =  .
 ......=...........=============...........=.....
11  .  =  =  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  =  =  .
 .........====.......................====........
10  .  .  .  =  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  =  .  .  .
 ............====.................====...........
09  .  .  .  .  .  .  +  +  +  .  %  .  .  .  .
 ...............=.....+~~~~~+.....=..............
08  .  .  .  .  %  .  +  +  +  .  %  .  .  .  .
 ............====.................====...........
07  .  .  .  =  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  =  .  .  .
 .........====.......................====........
06  .  =  =  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  =  =  .
 ......=...........=============...........=.....
05  .  =  .  .  .  .  .  %  .  .  .  .  .  =  .
 ......=.................%.................=.....
04  .  =  .  .  .  .  .  %  .  .  .  .  .  =  .
 ......=...........=============...........=.....
03  .  =  .  .  .  =  .  .  .  =  .  .  .  =  .
 ......=...........=...........=...........=.....
02  .  =  .  .  .  =  .  .  .  =  .  .  .  =  .
 %%%%===%%%%%%.....=============.....%%%%%%===%%%
01  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .
  A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P

Key: '=' Bookcase (10 ft tall), '.' Wooden floor, '%', Door, '+' Stone Fountain (3 ft tall), '~' Water (3 ft deep).

(I edited my move, if that's ok. If not, I can keep what I posted originally.)

(Sure)

Sarah cast zepher strike and moves to D16. Opening the door she takes aim at Scarab and lets two arrows fly. She then moves to B16 where she climbs the wall and then moves to A13

Attack: 27 Damage: 12

Attack: 26 Damage: 7

Zepher 1

Colossus 4

Acrobatics 19

(Sorry for the confusion, but I'm at F15)

(Ok looks like i need to edit my post a little. O.o Lol no prob man.)

Nara powers forward, bloodied and determined to bring down Ganathor. She attacks recklessly, a ragged warcry rattling out from the back of her throat.

Attack: 23 Damage: 13

Attack: 25 Damage: Unable to parse dice roll.

(got rid of the potion)

(My post has been edited.)

(Sarah is too fancy for opening doors, I guess. Although, honestly, I would do the same if I could.)

(Didn't have a choice. Already opened one door so that took my free action. Lol)

(Not sure if you can move that far without a climbing speed (or maybe even with it), but will let DM decide.)

( i should at least be close to it. Mabey 5' short.)