I have not revisited this topic since the release of the 2024 rules and their new, mastery weapon properties. I do not know if things like cleave, graze, nick, etc can be weapon properties you can ignore. Add a blurb "Ignore everything after this point" still should suffice for putting in writing where the end of your description ends and the unremovable stuff begins.

Also I have not looked into what is needed for ranged or firearms weapons to be used as STR based weapons. I imagine adding the versatile property could do it and that may be the simplest method. Unless you're in those niche cases where:

• the weapon isn't technically supposed to have the versatile property
• is a STR based weapon
• the character has a higher DEX modifier than STR.

That is several if this and if that's to consider however unlikely, might still come up. I would hope that anyone in this complicated of a situation would know how to customize their character sheet manually to get the result they need.

Is there a way to make a weapon more effective against certain enemy types? Or would I just have to flavor that via descriptive text?

That sounds like a flavor text kinda thing.

I'm not even sure how it would work mechanically in game. Like "creatures that are usually resistant to necrotic damage take full damage when hit by this weapon" ??

How do I actually create the weapon? Do I do it from the home brew create page or duplicate something somehow??

Quote from TimmyJoeBob >>

How do I actually create the weapon? Do I do it from the home brew create page or duplicate something somehow??

Pull down the "Collections" menu at the top of the screen, and under the "Homebrew" section on the right, click "Create Magic Item".

Went to update this thread with all the new 3pp wepons that have been added to the site that we can use to make homebrew weapons. Also updated a couple from the 2014 rules to their new 2024 rules (Trident, Yklwa, and Lance). A few things of note:

• We now have 3d4 weapons include a martial weapon! Try the Drive Shaft. 
• We have 2d4 and 2d6 simple weapons.
• We have 2d8 martial weapons. They are still firearms and have the range property, but you no longer need to add proficiency to firearms if you want to make a homebrew 2d8 weapon.

I'll be updating the weapon tables in the initial post over the next day or so, in fact I've already started. Anyone interested can check the google sheet I made to help sorting and filtering weapons we can use to base homebrew weapons off of.

EDIT

It looks like you do not need to own any book to use any mundane weapon as a base weapon in building homebrew.

Hi, I want to create 2 tasers. I've tried following the basic advice here but can't seem to get it right. Can someone please help me?

1) Handheld Taser

• Name: Taser
• Type: Melee Weapon
• Damage: 1d8 Lightning
• Properties: Finesse, Light, Loading
• Weapon Mastery: Sap
  
  

2) Ranged Taser

• Name: Taser Gun
• Type: Ranged Weapon (15feet)
• Damage: 1d8 Lightning
• Properties: Finesse, Light, Loading, Range (15)
• Weapon Mastery: Slow

Both weapons are based on the Shocking Grasp cantrip: "You have advantage on the attack roll if the target is wearing armor made of metal. On a hit, the target takes 1d8 lightning damage, and it can't take reactions until the start of its next turn."

Thank you! x