This post has potentially manipulated dice roll results.
Marlyth: Dexterity(Acrobatics) x Sliding towards the walls: 11
Marlyth's Turn
Eaglyth transforms into her natural tiefling form and casts Freedom of Movement on herself so that she can slip through the gaps of the golden cage. If she's successful, she will use the window of the second floor to leap into the water of the lake.
"Climbing over the floor, now more a wall, that once stood between the third and fourth floor, the source of the fire bolt, standing on the narrow stone that was the fourth floor, stands the Cobalt Mage, his hooded cloak waving in the wind."
Edit for clarity: on the topview map, there is a Large blue square near the bottom of the image, the line just above it represents a wall that was a floor. He is standing on it (specifically so you csn see him... otherwise he could have just hopped down behind the wall to stand in the former fourth floor, or possibly right through the window if he wanted to escape to the lake.. but he didn't. Instead he's skylined in clear view of everybody, unless they're underneath the opening tower, and even then, maybe partial cover? Looking through the window from underneath.)
<Fluff text issue; there was never a fire bolt, originally I was going to have this cantrip, but then I decided on the armor instead.>
(From that description, it seems like the Cobalt Mage is very close to where Tabaqui, Angus and Hamish are located. If Hamish manages to get within melee distance of the mage, Tabaqui will get sneak attack damage.)
One of the tines of the trident grazes Tabaqui's back, but he shrugs off the injury and aims his longbow at the mage.
<Tabaqui used his action last round to dash over the water, wearing a ring of water walking, toward Angus and Hamish. From there, the water elemental that attacked him could make that attack and then head inside the keep (rolls for ranged and melee are the same in this case, unless he melee'd with both hands, then the damage die would be bigger). The other elemental also headed into the keep, then made his attack. It's not really possible for Hamish, despite being a giant, to reach through the window overhead and then another 25 ft across the former floor to where the mage was. He could however chuck a rock at him. Likewise, a melee attack seems impossible from Tabaqui barring some special movement. If the previous rolls can be commuted to a ranged attack, they can be applied at your discretion. Sorry I couldn't tokenize the map earlier. Another option - if you'd like to try it.. since Hamish could throw 2 boulders, but can't find any in a lake at the moment, there is the old Fastball Special which would allow the melee attack - because that would be awesome. Offer applies to Angus as well (though melee would be next round)>
Angus will cast cure wounds at 2nd level on Hamish for 5 hp, and say, "Can you throw me far enough to reach the mage? or to help our friends? That wurm is going to be a problem."
< Ah-hah! I missed this before. I guess great minds think alike.... Done and done.>
Hamish lifts the Paladin and toesses him toward through the window to the spot just below the mage. (sorry I am adding this after the post.. it would be hamish backing away from the keep and tossing Angus through the window over the closest Banner of Blades ("A") and then he'd be able to grab the rafters of the 3rd floor ceiling. That will require a Str check (DC14) to hold on, otherwise he falls between the two blades below.)
(Tabaqui's attack was a ranged longbow attack. But if Hamish chucks Angus up there close to the mage, that would give me the sneak attack damage for my arrow.)
<My long response, probably roo long, but I hope it clarifies the intention of this challenge. It's the kind of thing that happens when the BBEG in a campaign is an Illusion Wizard - stuff is just weird and unexpected and the line between reality and Illusion is blurred.>
Quote from Brian_Avery >>
(ooc: not sure what you mean by a work around? in 5e the rules for doffing heavy armor is 50 rounds. if I can't get out of the armor I can't cast any spells. do you mean another work around to get out of the armor?... or a work around for doing stuff while keeping the armor on?)
Yes. It's not chess, there are always cases the rules weren't designed for. In this case, becasue of the unusual nature of the situation, my interpretation of what is possible is more relaxed. If my wizard was in your shoes, I'd polymorph. The rules on it are unclear as to which occurs to gear - it's either melted into the new form or dropped on the ground. There are many spells that explicitly state objects are effected as if part of the person, but there's probably some wiggle room there. I'm also aware of various monsters that will damage armor to the point where it is destroyed. That would certainly also work if you could create the same effect - I'm not sure how. I might even agree to treat the armor as I would an escape from [Tooltip Not Found] This isn't that, but the idea is similar enough thst the escape mechanic described would probably also apply. It's not really up to me tonsay hie you should try to escape.. though I do think it's best to escape. If Tyreus had identified Calners school of magic, and decided somatic components were very important, he may have just used some sort of mannacles: if verbal, perhoas some aort of bit ir gag. This is a wider net, so not as durable but pretty effective- as such any DC for this would he lower than anything else. Not everything would warrant a DC - some things are not possible by chance alone, and DCs will vary based on what is attempted, while still other options could succeed with no DC.
Hiding in the keep is viable, but Tabaqui dashed out onto the lake. He can dash back in or hide but not both, unless I'm missing something. It's just that hide has a prerequisite of having something to hide behind. Even if he took the ring off to submerge, I already ruled that PCs could target submerged elementals, so using the water to hide would be a dubious proposition at best.
Also, Tabaqui should have rolled with DA, so definitely no sbeak attack. I failed to include it, mostly because i had a lot of things to juggle, but its also part if an effort to create an atmosphere of uncertainty commensurate with the powerful illusionmagic combined with the creative power if the stone of creations, but it is a thing from his stat block. There are conditions that can remove it, but it's hard to say just why without telling you exactly the BBEGs weakness. Ultimately I called it a hit and it stays a hit, but no sneak attacks unless the DA is negated. I'll let you all know if the condition changes.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Marlyth: Dexterity (Acrobatics) x Sliding towards the walls: 11
Marlyth's Turn
Eaglyth transforms into her natural tiefling form and casts Freedom of Movement on herself so that she can slip through the gaps of the golden cage. If she's successful, she will use the window of the second floor to leap into the water of the lake.
"There's a dragon in the dungeon!"
InkedBee (Undead_Analyst)
Covetous, Dragonish Thoughts - Jenviel Tsumara: Fallen Aasimar- Monk|Crimson Sands of Time - Navarra Iltazyara: Human- Druid/Warlock| Bleak Prospect - Ermasnietsz: Reborn- Clockwork Soul Sorcerer
Walks will move towards the nearest window and jump into the water.
"Sooner or later, your Players are going to smash your railroad into a sandbox."
-Vedexent
"real life is a super high CR."
-OboeLauren
"............anybody got any potatoes? We could drop a potato in each hole an' see which ones get viciously mauled by horrible monsters?"
-Ilyara Thundertale
so where is the Cobalt mage on this map?
"Climbing over the floor, now more a wall, that once stood between the third and fourth floor,
the source of the fire bolt,standing on the narrow stone that was the fourth floor, stands the Cobalt Mage, his hooded cloak waving in the wind."Edit for clarity: on the topview map, there is a Large blue square near the bottom of the image, the line just above it represents a wall that was a floor. He is standing on it (specifically so you csn see him... otherwise he could have just hopped down behind the wall to stand in the former fourth floor, or possibly right through the window if he wanted to escape to the lake.. but he didn't. Instead he's skylined in clear view of everybody, unless they're underneath the opening tower, and even then, maybe partial cover? Looking through the window from underneath.)
<Fluff text issue; there was never a fire bolt, originally I was going to have this cantrip, but then I decided on the armor instead.>
Humans 20 ✅✅✅✅✅✅
Angus Initiative 16 ✅✅✅ ✅✅✅
elementals: 14 ✅✅✅✅✅✅
Hamish: 13 ✅✅✅✅✅▶️
Marlyth: Initiative 10 ✅✅✅✅✅▶️ OK
Walks Initiative 10 ✅✅✅✅▶️ OK
Tauzan Initiative: 9 ✅✅✅✅▶️
Tabaqui Initiative 6 ✅✅✅✅▶️ OK
Calner's Initiative: 6 ✅✅✅✅▶️
Apparently I missed Hamish. I have actions for Marlyth and Walks
(From that description, it seems like the Cobalt Mage is very close to where Tabaqui, Angus and Hamish are located. If Hamish manages to get within melee distance of the mage, Tabaqui will get sneak attack damage.)
One of the tines of the trident grazes Tabaqui's back, but he shrugs off the injury and aims his longbow at the mage.
Attack: 29 Damage: 9 magical piercing + (potentially) 23 sneak attack.
And with his movement, Tabaqui will take cover behind one of the ceiling/walls, and use his bonus action to attempt to hide.
Stealth 30
<Tabaqui used his action last round to dash over the water, wearing a ring of water walking, toward Angus and Hamish. From there, the water elemental that attacked him could make that attack and then head inside the keep (rolls for ranged and melee are the same in this case, unless he melee'd with both hands, then the damage die would be bigger). The other elemental also headed into the keep, then made his attack. It's not really possible for Hamish, despite being a giant, to reach through the window overhead and then another 25 ft across the former floor to where the mage was. He could however chuck a rock at him. Likewise, a melee attack seems impossible from Tabaqui barring some special movement. If the previous rolls can be commuted to a ranged attack, they can be applied at your discretion. Sorry I couldn't tokenize the map earlier. Another option - if you'd like to try it.. since Hamish could throw 2 boulders, but can't find any in a lake at the moment, there is the old Fastball Special which would allow the melee attack - because that would be awesome. Offer applies to Angus as well (though melee would be next round)>
< Ah-hah! I missed this before. I guess great minds think alike.... Done and done.>
Hamish lifts the Paladin and toesses him toward through the window to the spot just below the mage. (sorry I am adding this after the post.. it would be hamish backing away from the keep and tossing Angus through the window over the closest Banner of Blades ("A") and then he'd be able to grab the rafters of the 3rd floor ceiling. That will require a Str check (DC14) to hold on, otherwise he falls between the two blades below.)
(...but fools seldom differ)
owlbear.rodeo code: vEYeDXuNa
(The situation on the second floor North (lower right) is pending resolution. Tauzen and Calner are up;)
(Tabaqui's attack was a ranged longbow attack. But if Hamish chucks Angus up there close to the mage, that would give me the sneak attack damage for my arrow.)
Angus' STR (Athletics) check to catch the beam 10
<@Brian: there's really no mechanical answer to this. It suggests that the best course of action might be to find a work around.>
<edit n/m if you read the previous.. forgot ring of water walking>
Tabaqui's arrow hits Tyreus. Angus holds fast to the ceiling rafters below.
<Tabaqui cannot hide on top of a lake, unable to submerge himself in the water. It's not possible.>
<My long response, probably roo long, but I hope it clarifies the intention of this challenge. It's the kind of thing that happens when the BBEG in a campaign is an Illusion Wizard - stuff is just weird and unexpected and the line between reality and Illusion is blurred.>
Quote from Brian_Avery >>
(ooc: not sure what you mean by a work around? in 5e the rules for doffing heavy armor is 50 rounds. if I can't get out of the armor I can't cast any spells. do you mean another work around to get out of the armor?... or a work around for doing stuff while keeping the armor on?)
Yes. It's not chess, there are always cases the rules weren't designed for. In this case, becasue of the unusual nature of the situation, my interpretation of what is possible is more relaxed. If my wizard was in your shoes, I'd polymorph. The rules on it are unclear as to which occurs to gear - it's either melted into the new form or dropped on the ground. There are many spells that explicitly state objects are effected as if part of the person, but there's probably some wiggle room there. I'm also aware of various monsters that will damage armor to the point where it is destroyed. That would certainly also work if you could create the same effect - I'm not sure how. I might even agree to treat the armor as I would an escape from [Tooltip Not Found] This isn't that, but the idea is similar enough thst the escape mechanic described would probably also apply. It's not really up to me tonsay hie you should try to escape.. though I do think it's best to escape. If Tyreus had identified Calners school of magic, and decided somatic components were very important, he may have just used some sort of mannacles: if verbal, perhoas some aort of bit ir gag. This is a wider net, so not as durable but pretty effective- as such any DC for this would he lower than anything else. Not everything would warrant a DC - some things are not possible by chance alone, and DCs will vary based on what is attempted, while still other options could succeed with no DC.
(@Wile_E_Coyote, Does Hamish have proficiency in Smith's Tools and Leatherworker's Tools? Calner's Ring Mail can be modified using these tools.)
InkedBee (Undead_Analyst)
Covetous, Dragonish Thoughts - Jenviel Tsumara: Fallen Aasimar- Monk|Crimson Sands of Time - Navarra Iltazyara: Human- Druid/Warlock| Bleak Prospect - Ermasnietsz: Reborn- Clockwork Soul Sorcerer
(I thought it was stated previously that we could take cover behind some of the walls of the keep that are bending over.)
(And the mage should make a concentration check on any spells that require it).
Not in his statblock. Why would he?
@Syd
Hiding in the keep is viable, but Tabaqui dashed out onto the lake. He can dash back in or hide but not both, unless I'm missing something. It's just that hide has a prerequisite of having something to hide behind. Even if he took the ring off to submerge, I already ruled that PCs could target submerged elementals, so using the water to hide would be a dubious proposition at best.
Also, Tabaqui should have rolled with DA, so definitely no sbeak attack. I failed to include it, mostly because i had a lot of things to juggle, but its also part if an effort to create an atmosphere of uncertainty commensurate with the powerful illusionmagic combined with the creative power if the stone of creations, but it is a thing from his stat block. There are conditions that can remove it, but it's hard to say just why without telling you exactly the BBEGs weakness. Ultimately I called it a hit and it stays a hit, but no sneak attacks unless the DA is negated. I'll let you all know if the condition changes.